Mommar Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 On 11/12/2019 at 7:09 AM, renegadeleader1 said: In the armor? Expand Then it may depend on two people. Quote
Mommar Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 Reviews for The Mandelorian have been pretty positive so far. I'll have to view it for myself though. I'm skeptical of Star Wars reviews ever since I was told TFA was good too. Quote
Tking22 Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 The app was being screwy this morning but I got it to stay stable long enough to finish the first episode and hot damn, I loved it. Not too much cheesy humor, which I love, Disney pushes too much cheesy humor into everything they do now IMO and it's gotten old. The show is gorgeous, looks fantastic in 4K, the blend of CG and practical is right on point. IG-11 was awesome, and looked great in motion. The ending though, holy crap, that ending is something else, and carries HEAVY implications for the future, came out of left field for me, very unexpected. I'll have a spoiler tag below that is about the very end of the episode and the big reveal, it's in a spoiler tag so spoilers obviously, but DO NOT click if you don't want to read about the big ending! Reveal hidden contents The big bounty the episode focused on was a baby of the same species as Yoda and Yaddle! Whatever species they are, I don't think it was ever explicitly stated, was the big bounty so many people were after. Being of that species, it's safe to say they are very, very strong with the force, and could be viewed as a major ally or enemy to a number of different groups, or honestly just a weapon in the wrong hands. Once again, not expected in the slightest, Yoda and Yaddle are, from what I recall, the only two creatures of their species in cannon, so yeah, that's a big reveal IMO. Quote
Tking22 Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 On 11/12/2019 at 1:40 PM, Hikuro said: I’ve got slow load times and not able to add things to my watch list. Expand I got jerked around for nearly an hour trying to watch Mandalorian, the app is quite spotty on every platform right now it seems. I had login issues at first, but then like you mentioned, things from my watch list were disappearing or were being removed, then when they re-appeared after I closed and relaunched the app they couldn't be watched. Quote
Axelay Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 WOW. Watched the first episode this morning and am completely on board with this. I cannot wait to see where this goes - especially with the big spoiler at the end of the episode. Talk about some implications for the future of the franchise! I feel like we're in good hands with Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau. I hope I don't get proven wrong about this by the end of this season. I do find it intriguing now that the last episode is set to premiere after Rise of Skywalker. Wonder if there's going to be any sort of tie-in? Quote
Mommar Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 On 11/12/2019 at 5:00 PM, Axelay said: WOW. Watched the first episode this morning and am completely on board with this. I cannot wait to see where this goes - especially with the big spoiler at the end of the episode. Talk about some implications for the future of the franchise! I feel like we're in good hands with Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau. I hope I don't get proven wrong about this by the end of this season. I do find it intriguing now that the last episode is set to premiere after Rise of Skywalker. Wonder if there's going to be any sort of tie-in? Expand Is it going to tie in with one of the eight endings now? Quote
Knight26 Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 On 11/12/2019 at 5:00 PM, Axelay said: WOW. Watched the first episode this morning and am completely on board with this. I cannot wait to see where this goes - especially with the big spoiler at the end of the episode. Talk about some implications for the future of the franchise! I feel like we're in good hands with Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau. I hope I don't get proven wrong about this by the end of this season. I do find it intriguing now that the last episode is set to premiere after Rise of Skywalker. Wonder if there's going to be any sort of tie-in? Expand I would be beyond excited if LF/Disney came out and said that they are passing the creative reigns of Star Wars over to Filoni and Favreau. While some of their stuff has missed the mark, they pummel the target quite effectively in terms of canon and what fans really want. Quote
jvmacross Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 Finally got it to work and saw the first episode of The Mandalorian..... I can only "hope" it will get better Quote
jvmacross Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 Reveal hidden contents Sooooo.....Yoda or Yaddle clone? If it is 50 years old....it could put it's "creation" around the Clone Wars era. Darth Sidious is playing the ultimate long game....LOL Quote
Big s Posted November 12, 2019 Posted November 12, 2019 I really liked it . The quality in the epic gunfight had my eyes glued to the screen. It’s very close to movie quality visuals throughout. My only complaint might be that they never talked about how carbonite freezing became a standard method of handling prisoners. Quote
Dobber Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 I liked it a lot, too...but it definitely is a pilot. There’s a great foundation to build off of. Looking forward to seeing more. Chris Quote
TangledThorns Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 Good pilot, interesting to see where it goes. Quote
Roy Focker Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 Wasn't that impressed. Felt like a live action episode of the Clone Wars. The pacing was slow with the traveling from one place to the next taking forever. The first bounty started with the capture, a walk, a speeder ride and ship ride. They showed our lead walking doing his errands. In the later half he meets a guy and they ride some lizards. In the episode he meets a few comedic actors who don't add much to the story other than to lighten the mood. If you edited out the excessive traveling scenes and character interactions that have no effect on the story the entire episode would be half it's length. Quote
azrael Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 I think Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau (mostly...,ok 99%, Filoni) probably gets Star Wars the most. But that's in part because Filoni worked on Clone Wars and Rebels and is a hold over from pre-Disney LucasFilm. This show gives me the same "Ok this feels like Star Wars"-vibe that Rogue One gave me (and that's due to Jon Knoll being another pre-Disney Lucasfilm minion). Maybe it's me but maybe Disney should pull from the pre-Disney Lucasfilm/LucasArts talent pool for Star Wars than the talent they have running it now. As for this episode...it's a pilot episode. Enough to get me interested, but now they gotta sustain that. Quote
Chronocidal Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 All joking aside, I'm waiting to hear more about later episodes, but so far, it's sounding like this show is off to a pretty good start. Quote
Knight26 Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 On 11/13/2019 at 6:27 PM, Roy Focker said: Wasn't that impressed. Felt like a live action episode of the Clone Wars. The pacing was slow with the traveling from one place to the next taking forever. The first bounty started with the capture, a walk, a speeder ride and ship ride. They showed our lead walking doing his errands. In the later half he meets a guy and they ride some lizards. In the episode he meets a few comedic actors who don't add much to the story other than to lighten the mood. If you edited out the excessive traveling scenes and character interactions that have no effect on the story the entire episode would be half it's length. Expand You can tell that they are going for an old school "Space Western" feel, and in that way, all the travelling scenes make sense. I am willing to bet that the slow pacing in the first episode is intentional, and that the pace will speed up as we near the climax, kind of like it did in the episode. On 11/13/2019 at 7:21 PM, azrael said: I think Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau (mostly...,ok 99%, Filoni) probably gets Star Wars the most. But that's in part because Filoni worked on Clone Wars and Rebels and is a hold over from pre-Disney LucasFilm. This show gives me the same "Ok this feels like Star Wars"-vibe that Rogue One gave me (and that's due to Jon Knoll being another pre-Disney Lucasfilm minion). Maybe it's me but maybe Disney should pull from the pre-Disney Lucasfilm/LucasArts talent pool for Star Wars than the talent they have running it now. As for this episode...it's a pilot episode. Enough to get me interested, but now they gotta sustain that. Expand Agreed Quote
Big s Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 Honestly, I didn’t mind the pacing. The slow bits helped me feel how big the star wars universe can be. He’s not instantly somewhere. And I think it works for this type of story and that it’s a series rather than a rushed movie. Quote
Chronocidal Posted November 13, 2019 Posted November 13, 2019 On 11/13/2019 at 7:21 PM, azrael said: I think Dave Filoni and Jon Favreau (mostly...,ok 99%, Filoni) probably gets Star Wars the most. But that's in part because Filoni worked on Clone Wars and Rebels and is a hold over from pre-Disney LucasFilm. This show gives me the same "Ok this feels like Star Wars"-vibe that Rogue One gave me (and that's due to Jon Knoll being another pre-Disney Lucasfilm minion). Maybe it's me but maybe Disney should pull from the pre-Disney Lucasfilm/LucasArts talent pool for Star Wars than the talent they have running it now. Expand I've heard this point made elsewhere, and I forget who summarized it, but they compared Disney's acquisition of both Marvel and Pixar to the Lucasfilm deal. The huge difference to both of those situations was that they pulled an existing production pipeline along with the IP. Lucasfilm didn't have much of that, at least as far as the movies went, so they had no existing experience or proven talent to fall back on. If they wanted to stay true to the franchise, they should have been pulling from the people who already had both feet in the pool (or in Filoni's case, practically growing gills). To make a slightly dated comparison (and ignoring the lootbox fiasco), it's the same issue I felt EA had rebooting the Battlefront games. Where the originals actually felt like LucasArts properties with a unique gameplay feel to them, the EA BF games wound up feeling like Star Wars mods for whatever current Call of Duty or Battlefield game they were working on. If you want a successful organ transplant, you use tissue from someone who shares some of the same DNA. If you want something to feel like it belongs in an existing universe, you pull from talent with previous experience in that universe. Quote
renegadeleader1 Posted November 14, 2019 Posted November 14, 2019 Just a thought... Reveal hidden contents Anybody else get the feeling they're going to go Lone Wolf and Cub with this storyline? Quote
Dangard Ace Posted November 14, 2019 Posted November 14, 2019 Saw it. Liked it. Waiting on the next episode. I liked Clone Wars and Rebels so the storytelling seems great to me. Quote
spacemanoeuvres Posted November 14, 2019 Posted November 14, 2019 Best Star Wars story I’ve seen since Clone Wars 2003. Excited to see the next episode on Friday Quote
Mazinger Posted November 15, 2019 Posted November 15, 2019 On 11/15/2019 at 3:44 AM, Hikuro said: Excited for tomorrow’s episode Expand Season 1 episodes: Episode 1 - Tuesday, November 12 Episode 2 - Friday, November 15 Episode 3 - Friday, November 22 Episode 4 - Friday, November 29 Episode 5 - Friday, December 6 Episode 6 - Friday, December 13 Episode 7 - Wednesday, December 18 Episode 8 - Friday, December 27 What an odd release schedule. Well at least we don't have to wait for only 1 episode per week. Quote
Roy Focker Posted November 15, 2019 Posted November 15, 2019 The pacing of episode 2 was better. Entire episode was better and most of it was about a filler side quest. Quote
TangledThorns Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 Good second episode but damn it felt short. Quote
Dobber Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 Cool episode. I’m liking the show so far. Though they really haven’t established a story yet and there are only 6 episodes left. Chris Quote
azrael Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 On 11/16/2019 at 2:16 AM, TangledThorns said: Good second episode but damn it felt short. Expand That's because it was. Guess the season will be made up of 30 minute episodes. Quote
ErikElvis Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 Decent show so far. But yeah what’s the actual storyline going to be. Quote
Kurisama Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 If you knew the storyline, it wouldn't be very interesting to see. Clearly its going to be a lone wolf & cub-ish, clint eastwood spaghetti western-ish, star wars flavoured man against the world remnants of the empire and all the scum suckers trying to make a quick buck in-between. I love it so far, music, cinematography, show-don't tell attitude and world building. Quote
azrael Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 On 11/16/2019 at 11:52 AM, Kurisama said: If you knew the storyline, it wouldn't be very interesting to see. Expand That's a double-edge sword. You can only string your audience for so long before they decide not to take the bait. Quote
TangledThorns Posted November 16, 2019 Posted November 16, 2019 On 11/16/2019 at 5:25 AM, azrael said: That's because it was. Guess the season will be made up of 30 minute episodes. Expand Damn, you're right. Guess I'm just used to live action shows being at least forty minutes in length. The short length does kinda runs against it's potential complexity. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.