Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

The more I see stuff like this, the more I hope someone in Japan makes a live action Macross before there's a live actions RT with horrible actors like McGuire, and turn a great love story into a teenage angst drama with space vampires.

.. That's not M7 lol.

Posted

The more I see stuff like this, the more I hope someone in Japan makes a live action Macross before there's a live actions RT with horrible actors like McGuire, and turn a great love story into a teenage angst drama with space vampires.

.. That's not M7 lol.

Don't forget about Tobey Maguire project to a live action of Robotech...

I believe now what Pacific Rim was released, much studios make their mecha's movies for the next year....

Posted

Since this franchise is pretty much dead to me except for making fun of, I really have no interest in anything Robotech, be it fan projects or official release. I will admit that calling it the "Valkyrie Project" with a Robotech title is mildly annoying. Now, onto the work itself, The animation is OK. The camera angling is good. The CG looks a little blocky and video game-like, but it's something that can be worked on as it goes forward. Thumbs up, man.

Yeah, I'm a bit irked by that as well. I thought most fans should be able to differentiate the two different worlds, whether you're from the Robotech faction, or original Macross side. Was there a reason why didn't they use Veritech Project?

Posted

Yeah, I'm a bit irked by that as well. I thought most fans should be able to differentiate the two different worlds, whether you're from the Robotech faction, or original Macross side. Was there a reason why didn't they use Veritech Project?

I've learned over the years that a lot of people really don't know due to misinformation and/or don't care at this point out of nostalgia and loyalty, even if it is mildly insulting.

Posted

Uhm... The VF-1 is nick-named the Valkyrie in Robotech canon as well. And the Valkyrie project specifically was the developmental project in which the VF-1 was created, as depicted in the From the Stars comics.

Posted

Uhm... The VF-1 is nick-named the Valkyrie in Robotech canon as well. And the Valkyrie project specifically was the developmental project in which the VF-1 was created, as depicted in the From the Stars comics.

Didn't "From the Stars" retcon continuity too?

Posted

Yes, From the Stars is part of the current canon. The Yune-verse have changed or clarified many details so that they are more in line with the original source materials.

Posted

Yes, From the Stars is part of the current canon. The Yune-verse have changed or clarified many details so that they are more in line with the original source materials.

And the VF-1 has still been refered to as a Valkyrie in Robotech going back to 1985

Posted

And yet, amongst both communities and within both niche franchises, Veritech is the status quo term for Robotech, and Valkyrie has been the term associated with Macross. Technicalities don't do a whole lot of justice with what maybe considered social norms in these two franchises.

Posted

I'm a Macross fan but this... I don't know, seems promising... Let's see it and talk about it the next year :D

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

1:45 looks bad, but the overall quality is very good.

Also 1:10 that's more close to Macross than Robotech (Don't make contact with protoculture)

Edited by Gerli
Posted (edited)

I wonder why they changed the canopy design? 1:53 - I'd wager a Yammie 1/48 was the primary inspiration in the design of those CG Valks.

Edited by reddsun1
Posted

Are you expecting "Avatar"?

I expect not to base your titular CG model off a 30 year old children's toy. That's a flying Takatoku with tiny wings.

Posted

I will say the look of the Valks is a bit of a let down design-wise. The rest is done extremely well for something not funded by Hollywood money, but that design is chunky/stubby and... does not look good.

Posted

Legs are too fat and too far apart. They look "tacked on" and not an integrated part of fighter mode. Reminds me of most Transformerâ„¢ toys that way.

Fuselage (mainly glove area) is too wide.

Posted

Ok... wow.

LOL. Yeah words fail me on that clip. I will say however that if people can rave over Pacific Rim then that Telemundo/Sabado Gigante version of Macross should be equally worshipped...

Posted

LOL. Yeah words fail me on that clip. I will say however that if people can rave over Pacific Rim then that Telemundo/Sabado Gigante version of Robotech should be equally worshipped...

Fixed. :D

Seems like the short was filmed in english and later dubbed to a "neutral" spanish, so it's aimed to USA and Latin America in general... interesting move from the studio.

Let's see how it goes... it kinda has some... "thing" from Macross I think... (And some from Top-Gun) :D

Posted

Fixed. :D

Seems like the short was filmed in english and later dubbed to a "neutral" spanish, so it's aimed to USA and Latin America in general... interesting move from the studio.

Let's see how it goes... it kinda has some... "thing" from Macross I think... (And some from Top-Gun) :D

Minor Stealth references, too?

Posted

Ok, so what's the deal here, did we figure out if this is a fan film or a studio production?

Posted (edited)

Ok, so what's the deal here, did we figure out if this is a fan film or a studio production?

Both I think... because the fan who made it owns the studio :D

For reference, the guy did some animation for a History Channel special about the Malvinas War

Edited by Gerli
Posted

Are you guys so desperate for some kind of live action version of transforming plane mecha that you actually look forward to something this.. Bad?

This makes Sharknado look good.

No offense, but yikes, HG won't have to do much to impress RT fans if that's all it takes.

Posted

Are you guys so desperate for some kind of live action version of transforming plane mecha that you actually look forward to something this.. Bad?

This makes Sharknado look good.

No offense, but yikes, HG won't have to do much to impress RT fans if that's all it takes.

But it's not backed by HG right? This is just a misinformed fan who hasn't discovered Macross in it's original form right?

Posted

Quite cool for a fan made project, 2nd trailer shows some improvement. I will say that they seem to have focused more effort on the Zentradi more then the actual Valks model wise.

Posted

But it's not backed by HG right? This is just a misinformed fan who hasn't discovered Macross in it's original form right?

It's 100% fan made, HG only was asked for permission.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...