Einherjar Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 I hope Pete is feeling appropriately embarrassed by this after having gone out on a limb to defend MEMO. Pete has nothing to be embarrassed about. He acted diplomatically to the situation compared to some of us. It's all on Memo for deciding to take that route with what he know from these discussions. And he really does have the right to do that on a site he has influence in.
Seto Kaiba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Memo should be allowed to have his say, and let people see for themselves that his arguments have no merit. Yes, I agree that people should be allowed to express their own opinions, but there comes a time after someone has used their "say" to deliberately and maliciously deceive people for personal gain that they should honestly not be given the chance to continue to use their say to deceive people. If he could break the pattern it'd be one thing, but it's been one attempt after another on his part to prop himself up as an authority on a subject he doesn't understand and portray the lot of us as idiots and frauds. I'd say the same for Doug. How many times can we expect to excuse him calling us all pedophiles and child pornographers before we stop treating it as "his say" and start treating it as reprehensible behavior? At this point, I'm reminded of a scene from Futurama where Dr. Zoidberg is trying to convince Amy to remove the rubber bands from his claws, and she fires back with "Fool me once, shame on you... fool me six or more times...". It doesn't change that fact that he said that YOU don't shut up...and yet HE came here, seeking YOU. Everybody sees that. It's a damn shame HE can't see that... he might actually change his behavior if he did. It's all on Memo for deciding to take that route with what he know from these discussions. And he really does have the right to do that on a site he has influence in. MEMO may have the ability to do that on a site he has influence on, but that doesn't make it any less sleazy or wrong. In fact, I would argue that it's an even more ethically unsound to do it there, where he professes that his site is "by the fans, for the fans" and advertises it as an alternative to the ThinkPol-esque attempts to quash dissent and free expression that have become Robotech.com's characteristic traits. You don't see something wrong or ethically questionable about him exploiting his authority (self-granted or otherwise) to deliberately mislead people? We tear into Harmony Gold employees on a semi-regular basis for doing exactly that. Why should MEMO be an exception?
HappyPenguins Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 oh shi- watch what you say about doug or he might talk about you on his podcast =] I'm already famous along with seto, viper, & JT... But in all seriousness.. why is doug even here? is he a masochist or something?
Funkenstein Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 I think he's practicing his writing skills. A man's gotta improve somehow.
Einherjar Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 (edited) MEMO may have the ability to do that on a site he has influence on, but that doesn't make it any less sleazy or wrong. In fact, I would argue that it's an even more ethically unsound to do it there, where he professes that his site is "by the fans, for the fans" and advertises it as an alternative to the ThinkPol-esque attempts to quash dissent and free expression that have become Robotech.com's characteristic traits. You don't see something wrong or ethically questionable about him exploiting his authority (self-granted or otherwise) to deliberately mislead people? We tear into Harmony Gold employees on a semi-regular basis for doing exactly that. Why should MEMO be an exception? Because in all honesty, he's a nobody and this is the Internet. It's still a crazy place years after it came to be. And as a lot of people have seen here, his actions recently have really damaged his and others' credibility. I realize that he can do whatever the heck he pleases, but for the things he says and does to really matter, it totally relies on HG to take real action for Robotech. It's also up to the people really listening to this stuff to make their own conclusions about the situation eventually in the long run. After all, they are all still at the same position they were a year from now, if not worse. Wow, I've been here long enough to actually say that. And who cares about that podcast? He's eventually going to record a show that very few people are going to be able to participate in or actually download and listen anyway. Edited December 12, 2009 by Einherjar
HappyPenguins Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 I think he's practicing his writing skills. A man's gotta improve somehow. This is true! he never did tell me what ewalks were though...
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Ranka looks like she's 12. Big effing deal. Since when does looking like a 12-year old automatically mean that a person actually is 12 years old? Is it somehow impossible in the real world for a 20-year old to look like she's 14 or 15? Hell, my mother looks like she's about 20 years older than my aunt, despite the fact that my aunt is only 2 years younger than my mom.
dougbendo Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 you guys are nothing more then a joke. To even pretend that ranka need seen was ment to be seen as her "peak" to when she is conformable with her self as a sing and then saves the universe is more the laughable. So are you telling me that if Ranka didn't loose all her clothes in that moment the universe would have been doomed, lol. I think you should lisson to your arguments before you make them. You guys seem to forget that she was laready singing with her clothes on and singing just fine. Then at the final momment she had to loose all her clothes. Now why did she loose all her clothes? Because it was meant to entertain the audience. That is the whole point of macross ft in the first place. Are you guys trying to run that hard from the truthe? The whole point of macross frontier is to entertane its views so it can sell stuff and gain sponsors. Ranka is nude for the purpose in the show to entertain you the viewer if you are into that kind of thing. Its that dry and simple. VTFT1 your liberal spin isn't going to work on me. You can try to make it about children learning about the birds and the bees. You can try to make it sound like its ment to bring up sexual topics so teens can talk openly. You can even try to say that macross frontier is a family show that is ment for the whole family to sit down and watch together... but its all bull poo. I don't see any gi joe public service announcement on the topic of sex in macross frontier. If any one is into naked little kids her it would be you. It could just be me but the idea of a grown man wanting to watch a cartoon as you call it with a child just so that the child can see nudity so the child can ask the grown man what the nudity is about so that the grown man can lead into the conversation with sex with the child is WRONG TO ME. I'm glad to know your all about that. I'm glad to know that you don't mind mixing your mecha with your sexual explorations. personally I don't think you have any right telling any child about sex just because you "happened" to watch macross ft with them and the naked girl came up. Because the bottom line is if the clip wasn't there in the first place they you wouldn't get that "moment" you are so looking forward to with the child. So by your own admition you have just said that macross frontier is setting up viewer of you a younger age to have to engade in sexual conversations with people that aren't the best in the matter of such things. Knowing those people like yourself are going to go into some bullshit on sexual liberation and god only knows what else. Of course this is coming from a guy that thinks its ok to think a certain way about children because as long as you don't touch them because we all know touching is illegal. So Yes it is child porn no matter how you like to look at this poo you call macross frontier. What I find so amazing is that seto tried to say she was of legal age when he first made his arguments. Seto "16years of age is that of an adult in post space war one so it is ok that she is nude because ranka is an adult!" But VFVT1 you just come right out and say "yup she is a child and I am proud that the creaters made her naked in the final senes! It mean so much to the story that she was naked and she was even able to save the universe because of it!" Now let me hit up on one more thing MR. look but just don't touch. The fact that you are into stories where is has the whole "the girl was able to sing so the univers was saved" is the perfect reason to why macross sucks so bad when compared to robotech. It may have been a neat idea the first time around. But how many times has macross sang this same song? The fact that your all mecha fan boy's and (if your not I am afraid to see what makes you macross fans) your all over a story where all the big bad robots fail and in the end a little girl a song that saves everything just show how lame this fan base (macross) really is.
Seto Kaiba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 But in all seriousness.. why is doug even here? I don't think an answer will be long in coming. [...] The fact that your all mecha fan boy's and (if your not I am afraid to see what makes you macross fans) your all over a story where all the big bad robots fail and in the end a little girl a song that saves everything just show how lame this fan base (macross) really is. And here we have it... "trolling".
HappyPenguins Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 I don't think an answer will be long in coming. And here we have it... "trolling". I think hes got the hots for you
justvinnie Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 snip Wow all the drama of late. I'm just glad that my sig is so relevant during times like this. vinnie
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Dude, are you just that fartING STUPID that you can't understand symbolism or the fact that a person appearance's DOESN'T necessarily determine how old they are. Maybe you're just so sexually frustrated that every bit of nudity MUST be pornography or have some sort of sexual meaning. I must be a huge pervert since I like to take all of my clothes off when I take a shower. I've never met you, but from the five or so posts that you made on this site, I can tell that you're the most ignorant, illiterate farting buffoon that I've ever come across. I hope I didn't use too many big words for your little, illiterate mind to comprehend.
Wanzerfan Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 (edited) Ranka looks like she's 12. Big effing deal. Since when does looking like a 12-year old automatically mean that a person actually is 12 years old? Is it somehow impossible in the real world for a 20-year old to look like she's 14 or 15? Hell, my mother looks like she's about 20 years older than my aunt, despite the fact that my aunt is only 2 years younger than my mom. Case in point, in the Detective Conan (Case Closed) series, a couple of characters were regressed in age (including Conan). Edited December 12, 2009 by Wanzerfan
Seto Kaiba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 (edited) Dude, are you just that fartING STUPID that you can't understand symbolism or the fact that a person appearance's DOESN'T necessarily determine how old they are. Oh no, I assure you he's perfectly capable of understanding it. In fact, he even went so far as to say that both he and his "girlfriend" look younger than they actually are. He says he's 28, and professes to be frequently mistaken for someone of between 16 and 19 years of age. Of course, he claimed that it was problematic because he was being hit on by underage high school girls, so we can't discount the possibility that it's fantasizing or idle bullshit on his part. If he actually stopped ranting long enough to notice the hypocrisy of saying that he looks younger than he is and following it with the argument that Ranka looks twelve to him and therefore must be twelve irrespective of all evidence to the contrary, he might have been able to avoid making a fool of himself and getting banned from multiple websites. He got onto this particular tack after seeing me criticize Robotech: the Shadow Chronicles for blatantly and pointlessly making every female character look like a porn star, and seeing Viper post a comparison between the animation quality of Macross Frontier and that of Robotech: the Shadow Chronicles. This whole business with "Ranka naked in space" started as nothing more than a straw man for Bendo to rail against in hopes of making Macross Frontier look bad, and he escalated the verbal offensive when he couldn't get anybody to agree with him or even take him seriously. Edited December 12, 2009 by Seto Kaiba
azrael Posted December 12, 2009 Author Posted December 12, 2009 Mod mode How about this, let's end this year on a quiet note. Seto, those 2 grammar-deficient kids followed you here because you keep pointing out their lies, stupidity, and general denial symptoms. Seriously, we get it. We all know what they said is completely false, mindless, and illiterate nonsense. The few posts that they've made in the past 2 days has made that so crystal clear. It is of no use to point out the bleeding obvious. So you can quit doing it. Please. And this applies to rest of you. We know what they say is so nonsensical, so mindless, that we could probably fill 100+ books on the subject. Let's just wrap this all up and move on. From now on, let's just assume everything they spit out is false and has no real substance. That way, instead of pointing out what kind of mindless kids run the asylum over there, we can look for some glimmer of actual intelligence. A SETI project, if you will compare.
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 http://www.youtube.com/user/dougbendo Please tell me that he doesn't actually believe the garbage that he's saying in this video.
Gubaba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Memo...Dougbendo...Maverick_LSC... What the hell is going on here? Have they suddenly realized how awesome Macross is in comparison to schlock like Robotech? If so, I welcome all of you! BOMBAA!!
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 I think it's just a shared nightmare, Gubaba!
Seto Kaiba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 (edited) Seto, those 2 grammar-deficient kids followed you here because you keep pointing out their lies, stupidity, and general denial symptoms. Seriously, we get it. We all know what they said is completely false, mindless, and illiterate nonsense. The few posts that they've made in the past 2 days has made that so crystal clear. It is of no use to point out the bleeding obvious. So you can quit doing it. Please. It's not like I invited them to come here or did it to draw them here, I was just posting observations on what's causing the Robotech franchise to slowly self-destruct... but yeah, okay. If you want me to change topics, I'm game. That way, instead of pointing out what kind of mindless kids run the asylum over there, we can look for some glimmer of actual intelligence. A SETI project, if you will compare. Oh, it's no secret that intelligent Robotech fans exist... it's just lamentable how rare they are, and that until recently they were largely under the thumb of the inmates who now run the asylum. No need to launch a SETI-style project to find 'em, they're obliging folks who'll come out if you call. I'm actually working to facilitate their plans for a Robotech fan site which will actually adhere to the motto of "By the fans, For the fans" and provide a less Orwellian place for RT fans to hang out and share fan projects. I've actually got a couple people lined up who are practically champing at the bit to be given access to my collection of Robotech publications and carte blanche to use them to write a new "Infopedia" which will cover everything (show, novels, comics, games, etc.) and be hosted on that new site. The official Infopedia on Harmony Gold's official site is lamentably incomplete, and contains some stuff that's just plain wrong, and it's been driving those guys nuts for ages but they haven't been able to get Tommy to let them fix it. http://www.youtube.com/user/dougbendo Please tell me that he doesn't actually believe the garbage that he's saying in this video. I'd happily tell you that he doesn't actually believe what he's saying in those videos, but I'd be lying if I did. Edited December 12, 2009 by Seto Kaiba
dougbendo Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Seto I came to macross world to see if you were as great as you told me you were. What I have already found in your nothing more then a commoner. But it is TFVF1 that is the main sqeeze. Seto you are nothing more than an after thought to me now. Mentioned in memory only! Seto you died at robotechx.com when you faced me so now I have to set my sites on the bigger things in the macross random. Seto your just not number one anymore in the macross fandom. I always new there had to be macross fans greater then you.
Robelwell202 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 So, um, anyway...How was everyone's day? not too shabby, really... Yesterday, I got a called for an interview for a REAL job, so, in a couple months, I might be in a position to start ordering the VF toys I want. Today, I just rode that 'Happy-high' for all I could. How was yours?
dougbendo Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Nope seto said that you guys said he was the number one macross export. He said that you guys looked at him that way. by a robotech fan... "About the song thing it got old and fast and they drug that one out like a poor brian dead soul on life support. And that whole mecha that dubbled as a musical instrument piloted by Maxamillions and Millia's youngest Pink hair daughter"
HappyPenguins Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 So, um, anyway...How was everyone's day? not bad not bad.. I was off from work but I was sick but I got to spend time playing with my wacom cintiq I bought for myself hehe.. I love that thing
Gubaba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 not too shabby, really... Yesterday, I got a called for an interview for a REAL job, so, in a couple months, I might be in a position to start ordering the VF toys I want. Today, I just rode that 'Happy-high' for all I could. How was yours? It was all right. Took an ill-advised long nap this afternoon, so I probably won't be able to sleep much tonight. Dropped by Kinokuniya and picked up the new Macross Chronicle, and a new Chronicle binder as well. My day had nothing to do with Robotech, however.
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 What the hell? Does Mav make his posts then delete them a few minutes later? Or am I just losing my mind?!
Seto Kaiba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 My day had nothing to do with Robotech, however. Ah, mine did... I ran into a Robotech fan on my way to an offsite meeting. Noticed him because of the blue MPC Alpha in his cubicle and ended up stopping to chat on my way out of the building. Also spent a bit of time researching content management systems for that aforementioned RT website project I'm helping with. What the hell? Does Mav make his posts then delete them a few minutes later? Or am I just losing my mind?! I think azrael's deleting them, actually.
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 My day was a bit of a torture. The heat at work isn't working properly and it was a bit chilly in the store. Stupid me neglected to wear a long-sleeve shirt and spent almost my entire work day shivering. I'm nice and toasty warm now, though!
Beltane70 Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Ah, mine did... I ran into a Robotech fan on my way to an offsite meeting. Noticed him because of the blue MPC Alpha in his cubicle and ended up stopping to chat on my way out of the building. Also spent a bit of time researching content management systems for that aforementioned RT website project I'm helping with. I think azrael's deleting them, actually. God, I hope so. I'd hate to learn that I was losing my mind at 39!
azrael Posted December 12, 2009 Author Posted December 12, 2009 Seto I came to macross world to see if you were as great as you told me you were. What I have already found in your nothing more then a commoner. I'd hate to break this to you, but you're a commoner too. So you can either politely join this discussion or leave peacefully. And trust me, the next mod to stop by probably won't be as gracious as me.
Gubaba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 So, um...if they made a Robotech Christmas album, what do you think would be on it?
Seto Kaiba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 (edited) So, um...if they made a Robotech Christmas album, what do you think would be on it? White noise... they don't exactly have any thematically-appropriate music in their current repertoire, and I can't see them springing for new music when they've put everything else on hold for the live-action movie. If I remember, Minmei's voice actress (Rebecca Forstadt) has expressed that she doesn't want to sing again, so she's probably out. I guess they could get Michael Bradley on it, though he's doing his own thing these days, or so I hear. God, I hope so. I'd hate to learn that I was losing my mind at 39! Indeed... I was kind of perplexed myself when I saw the first one vanish. My day was a bit of a torture. The heat at work isn't working properly and it was a bit chilly in the store. Stupid me neglected to wear a long-sleeve shirt and spent almost my entire work day shivering. I'm nice and toasty warm now, though! I know that feeling, I left my overpowered gaming rig running all day while I was at work just so it wouldn't be twenty degrees colder in the den than the rest of my house. It turns into a veritable meat locker during the winter... Edited December 12, 2009 by Seto Kaiba
Funkenstein Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Oh, I would love to see The Robotech Christmas Special. It would have a family of Zentraedi trying to celebrate "Cloning Day".
Gubaba Posted December 12, 2009 Posted December 12, 2009 Oh, I would love to see The Robotech Christmas Special. It would have a family of Zentraedi trying to celebrate "Cloning Day". Or maybe "A Very Invid Christmas"...? That might be fun.
Recommended Posts