bzdup Posted May 23, 2009 Posted May 23, 2009 With all this hype about Macross Ace and Macross Chronicle, has anyone heard of the Macross camp just flat out redoing a complete anime of the original Macross? or finally providing a sequel and end to Hikaru and Misa Hayase? I remember reading that the the original guy (Showori?) sorry, saying he didn't want to do sequels. I hope as this guy gets older he comes to his senses and a) gives the fans what they want and b) friggin cash in!!!. Anyways, thanks for reading my post. I still want an ending dammit!!!! Although I must say Macross Frontier ROCKED (I just got a Malaysian DVD version, not bad, not great quality but not bad) Quote
JB0 Posted May 23, 2009 Posted May 23, 2009 There IS an ending. TWO endings, even! A. The final battle of Space War 1. Hikaru and Minmay go their separate ways, Hikaru and Misa finally get together. B. The battle of Macross City. Hikaru rebuffs Minmay and goes off with Misa again. Minmay gets invited along on the Megaroad. What would they do for a sequel? Have Hikaru break it off with Misa to chase Minmay AGAIN, only to realize AGAIN that he wants Misa? Quote
RedWolf Posted May 23, 2009 Posted May 23, 2009 (edited) With all this hype about Macross Ace and Macross Chronicle, has anyone heard of the Macross camp just flat out redoing a complete anime of the original Macross? or finally providing a sequel and end to Hikaru and Misa Hayase? I remember reading that the the original guy (Showori?) sorry, saying he didn't want to do sequels. I hope as this guy gets older he comes to his senses and a) gives the fans what they want and b) friggin cash in!!!. Anyways, thanks for reading my post. I still want an ending dammit!!!! Although I must say Macross Frontier ROCKED (I just got a Malaysian DVD version, not bad, not great quality but not bad) That's Shoji Kawamori. Besides the endings so to speak Macross Flashback 2012, though most of it are music videos, gives us an epilogue of SFDFM. As Minmay said she did join Misa and Hikaru in the first emigration fleet. Four years after leaving Earth nobody has heard of them. Their last known position is somewhere in the core region of the galaxy. Where all sort of crap happen. Protodevlin, Vajra who knows what else is there. That is why old school Zentradi fanboy Richard Bilrer was hoping the Vajra could have the answer in finding Minmay. Edited May 23, 2009 by RedWolf Quote
Gubaba Posted May 23, 2009 Posted May 23, 2009 With all this hype about Macross Ace and Macross Chronicle, has anyone heard of the Macross camp just flat out redoing a complete anime of the original Macross? or finally providing a sequel and end to Hikaru and Misa Hayase? I remember reading that the the original guy (Showori?) sorry, saying he didn't want to do sequels. I hope as this guy gets older he comes to his senses and a) gives the fans what they want and b) friggin cash in!!!. Anyways, thanks for reading my post. I still want an ending dammit!!!! Although I must say Macross Frontier ROCKED (I just got a Malaysian DVD version, not bad, not great quality but not bad) As you say, Frontier rocked. And clearly, based on how popular it's been, THAT'S what the fans want. And "Showori" is complying. Quote
taksraven Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 I definitely agree with those who say that the show should keep moving forwards. A little backwards glance is OK once in a while (I loved the fact that Macross Zero gave us a little bit more time with Roy and Macross 7 gave us a little bit more time with Max and Miriya) but the series really should keep moving ahead. Like I have said before, I would love it if a future program had humans finally encountering the Protoculture. That would be the enemy to end all enemies as far as Macross goes. Taksraven Quote
Valkyrie addict Posted May 24, 2009 Posted May 24, 2009 I still keep my theory that Misa catched Minmey doing the dirty with Hikaru and steered the Megaroad01 to a black hole in anger Quote
bzdup Posted May 25, 2009 Author Posted May 25, 2009 As you say, Frontier rocked. And clearly, based on how popular it's been, THAT'S what the fans want. And "Showori" is complying. Yeah, I guess all replies have been fair. I guess a big part of it is from consuming formulaic american pop entertainment for most of my life!!! Macross definitely doesn't fit that mold. I'm pretty stoked Shoji is doing anything Macross related so no complaints here. Macross Ace could be some preliminary feelers to gauge interest in the original series and maybe spin something off? Quote
Gubaba Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 Yeah, I guess all replies have been fair. I guess a big part of it is from consuming formulaic american pop entertainment for most of my life!!! Macross definitely doesn't fit that mold. I'm pretty stoked Shoji is doing anything Macross related so no complaints here. Macross Ace could be some preliminary feelers to gauge interest in the original series and maybe spin something off? I doubt it... Tokusatsu Ace had "Ultraman the First," but they didn't turn that into a series. Gundam Ace has "Gundam the Origin," but that hasn't become a series. I don't think "Macross the First" will be any different. Besides, Space War I has been done as an animated TV show, a movie, some novels, and now a comic. Isn't that enough? Quote
Sdf Prime Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 Yeah, I guess all replies have been fair. I guess a big part of it is from consuming formulaic american pop entertainment for most of my life!!! Macross definitely doesn't fit that mold. I'm pretty stoked Shoji is doing anything Macross related so no complaints here. Macross Ace could be some preliminary feelers to gauge interest in the original series and maybe spin something off? I don't know if Macross the First appearing in Macross Ace is feeling out to see if there is interest reanimating SDF Macross or creating animation of the original characters after Flashback 2012,but I think Macross the First maybe a way of introducing the original series to people who may not want to watch older animation like SDf Macross. I also think Shoji Kawamori came up with the ending he did for our heroes after they left on the Megaroad 01 was so no one would come in and mess up his characters after he told their story. Quote
HannouHeiki Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 That is why old school Zentradi fanboy Richard Bilrer was hoping the Vajra could have the answer in finding Minmay. That was the only thing I didn't like about Frontier. I took FB 2012 to show our characters "riding off into the sunset" and just ignored the "never heard from again" business in my personal canon. I just took it that their story was over and complete. That approach just put that nagging feeling to rest. Now that their loss is somewhat acknowledged by Bilrer in Frontier...within the Macross animation itself...that was actually kind of a big deal for me. Now I'm bugged about them being lost in space as I ever was... Quote
Zinjo Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 Kawamori likes enigmas... Every Macross title he's done has unanswered questions in them, no tidy little bow as the North American masses have been programmed into believing is necessary. As I get older I appreciate this approach more and more, as it keeps creative options open for future tales if inspiration hits right. The whole Brilar motivation only reinforces the legend of Minmay, not only within the universe, but also for the fans. I expect that now, no story, no matter how inspired could possibly live up to the fans' expectations of what the original triangle could have become. It is true that after DYRL, Kawamori swore off Macross for nearly a decade, but his clout in the franchise is what got him the funding to do Plus, which was not written as a Macross story originally. When he did return the inevitable Megaroad question came up and he's always maintained that the story of Hikaru, Misa and Minmay has been told and he has no interest in revisiting it. That isn't to say he never will, but so far after 25 years he has never been inspired to tell any new stories about that trio. I'd suggest accepting the fate of the Megaroad as one of the many mysteries of the Macross universe and move on. taksraven, I doubt we'll ever see any Protoculture fleets in Macross. The PC are the ultimate enigma and I kinda like it that way. Every production reveals a new kernel of information about the civilization. Besides, if the remnants of the PC's were to come out in force, they'd wipe out any NUNS forces they'd feel the need to attack, so it would be a very short show.... Quote
thankheaven Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 (edited) They could do a show set onboard the Megaroad-01 featuring new main characters with Hikaru and company as supporting characters, abit like how M&M was in Macross 7 (Though i think they had a bigger part then that), but something similar anyway. Though i feel their story is finished, they have been developed as far as they can get as characters and there really isn't much more to do with them. Doing more might ruin it. That being said i still would like to see a show set onboard a Megaroad ship with VF-4's. There is a rather large gap between Flashback 2012 and Macross Plus set in 2040 that i would want explored abit more. And i still want to get a wrap on the protoculture story though. It was featured in Macross 7 very well but still not concluded. I'd love to have someone actually meet a survivor or something. Edited May 25, 2009 by thankheaven Quote
MjrMisaHayase Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 They could do a show set onboard the Megaroad-01 featuring new main characters with Hikaru and company as supporting characters, abit like how M&M was in Macross 7 (Though i think they had a bigger part then that), but something similar anyway. Though i feel their story is finished, they have been developed as far as they can get as characters and there really isn't much more to do with them. Doing more might ruin it. That being said i still would like to see a show set onboard a Megaroad ship with VF-4's. There is a rather large gap between Flashback 2012 and Macross Plus set in 2040 that i would want explored abit more. I agree with you. More Macross stories set between FB2012 and Macross Plus as well as a series set onboard the Megaroad-01. Quote
Clay Cliff Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 (edited) I still keep my theory that Misa catched Minmey doing the dirty with Hikaru and steered the Megaroad01 to a black hole in anger +1... Remember, when anything (like a Colonization Fleet ) enter a black hole's event horizon it won't feel the effects inmediately, but it will be already trapped into it and it won't be able to escape... Nothing can escape a black hole's event horizon, NOT EVEN COMMUNICATIONS... Hey, wait a minute... I think contact with Megaroad 01 was lost some time ago, maybe they actually reached the Milky Way's center as planned. BTW in our galaxy's center there is a Suppermassive Black Hole, so maybe they're still unharmed. More info about the Supermassive Black Hole here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supermassive_black_hole *EDIT* I'm watching to much History Channel... Edited May 25, 2009 by Clay Cliff Quote
Kronnang Dunn Posted May 25, 2009 Posted May 25, 2009 Besides, if the remnants of the PC's were to come out in force, they'd wipe out any NUNS forces they'd feel the need to attack, so it would be a very short show.... Maybe the Megaroad 01 people discovered them and in order to avoid more destruction they simply stopped communicating with NUNS High Command and are currently living among them... Quote
BlueMax Posted May 26, 2009 Posted May 26, 2009 haha... when i saw the title of this thread, I thought there was going to be a new anime based on SDF: M! I don't think there'll be anything to do with the 3 original characters, but Lord knows how much i would love to see the VF-1 in action in spanking modern animation! Quote
peter Posted May 26, 2009 Posted May 26, 2009 (edited) haha... when i saw the title of this thread, I thought there was going to be a new anime based on SDF: M! I don't think there'll be anything to do with the 3 original characters, but Lord knows how much i would love to see the VF-1 in action in spanking modern animation! Me too. Although the idea of of a new show based on the original crew would be cool, it's not likely and sort of impossible (Hikaru's voice actor, and some other are no longer with us). I'd kill to see the VF-1 have more screen time....it was nice to see Hikaru's VF-1 in Frontier, as well as a few VF-1s in the airshow special, but it just left me wanting more. The VF-4 does absolutely nothing for me. Just looks hideous compared to the VF-1 All I can hope for is the original show with all the animation redone but keep the original voices, sound effects and music. It'd be nice if they threw in ai, oboete imasu ka? for the fleet battle like in the movie. This will never happen from the studio, one can only hope that in 15 or 20 years, a group of dedicated and skilled fans may get together and just do it. Maybe CGI will progress enough one day to the point where accomplishing this would be a piece of cake for anyone to do. Sorry, straying off topic here. Back to the topic, doubt anything will happen from the studio. What you hope for will only happen by the fans. I still keep my theory that Misa catched Minmey doing the dirty with Hikaru and steered the Megaroad01 to a black hole in anger That was hilarious, I can totally see that happening! Edited May 26, 2009 by peter Quote
Thom Posted May 26, 2009 Posted May 26, 2009 I don't know if it's because I'm American and do to too many 'happy ending' scenarios, but I would like to know what really happened to Misa and Hikaru and Minmay. I don't like have endings just dangling like that. But seeing as the voice actor for Hikaru is deceased, and this was apparently a good friend of Kowomori, I doubt we would see the actual characters themselves in anything but flashbacks or pictures on a mantle. If Kowomori however did continue with the original story, I would think it would best be done through Misa and Hikaru's daughter Miku Ichijyo. In the Macross universe, the possibilities are truly endless... Quote
dreamweaver13 Posted May 27, 2009 Posted May 27, 2009 (edited) If Kowomori however did continue with the original story, I would think it would best be done through Misa and Hikaru's daughter Miku Ichijyo. Oh, I just couldn't resist reviving this old casting call... SDFMacross: The Next Generation Edited May 27, 2009 by dreamweaver13 Quote
RedWolf Posted May 27, 2009 Posted May 27, 2009 If Kawamori however did continue with the original story, I would think it would best be done through Misa and Hikaru's daughter Miku Ichijyo. In the Macross universe, the possibilities are truly endless... I have been thinking of writing a Macross fic about her. The Nupetiet-Vergnitzs refit escorting Megaroad 1 is found abandoned with her in suspended animation. As a child she is adopted by one of the Jenius sisters. Quote
Gubaba Posted May 27, 2009 Posted May 27, 2009 Oh, I just couldn't resist reviving this old casting call... SDFMacross: The Next Generation Crap, I'd almost completely forgotten about that... And you made me snort. Again. Quote
Kronnang Dunn Posted May 27, 2009 Posted May 27, 2009 (edited) don't think there'll be anything to do with the 3 original characters, but Lord knows how much i would love to see the VF-1 in action in spanking modern animation! You should watch Macross Zero then... (the closest thing right now) Edited May 27, 2009 by Kronnang Dunn Quote
sharky Posted May 27, 2009 Posted May 27, 2009 They could do a show set onboard the Megaroad-01 featuring new main characters with Hikaru and company as supporting characters, abit like how M&M was in Macross 7 (Though i think they had a bigger part then that), but something similar anyway. Though i feel their story is finished, they have been developed as far as they can get as characters and there really isn't much more to do with them. Doing more might ruin it. That being said i still would like to see a show set onboard a Megaroad ship with VF-4's. Agreed, one of the things I asked myself was why wasn't Macross 7 about the further adventures on the Megaroad. I think they could have had more stories to tell if we followed them on their travels looking for a planet to colonize. Quote
Thom Posted May 27, 2009 Posted May 27, 2009 I have been thinking of writing a Macross fic about her. The Nupetiet-Vergnitzs refit escorting Megaroad 1 is found abandoned with her in suspended animation. As a child she is adopted by one of the Jenius sisters. That sounds like a cool idea. If you get it going post a link. I've been thinking about one off and on, having to do with a fleet leaving Earth just before the Zentradi attack. There were two great projects being done at the same time, the Grand Canon and the very first emigration fleet, seen more as a last ditch effort to try and save some people... It's main cast would be decedents from original Macross characters - or their extended families for the most part. It would use familiar aspects from Macross, Macross II and Robotech, and entail these people running from their new home and stumbling across an abandoned Macross Long Rang Colonization fleet. Of course, that's just the beginning... Quote
BlueMax Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 You should watch Macross Zero then... (the closest thing right now) Haha... yeah, thats about as close as it gets.... but you know, coca-cola zero (pun intended) just ain't coca-cola. Quote
nexxstrait Posted May 28, 2009 Posted May 28, 2009 (edited) I like tha fact that every new Macross series is a step forward, and I also like hints at the past (personally, Frontier would have been nearly orgasmatic if it had Macross 7 instead of Macross 11 at the end, even in a small glimpse). That's why M0 was ok but left me somehow less enthusiastic (altough Roy rocks). And I think it is not correct to say tha Kawamory doesn't like sequels, as each and every Macross series is a sequel: M7 is a sequel to SDF Macross, along with Plus; Dynamite is a sequel to M7, along with Frontier (wich in turn is a sequel to M0). Quick list of returning characters and mecha (along with cameos) in Macross sequels and prequels: M0: Roy fokker MPlus: VF1 Valkyrie, MAC Monster II, SDF Macross M7: Exedore, Max, Mirya, VF1 Valkyrie, VF11, VF19 & 22, Destroids, Megaroad 01, Zentradi Warships, SDF Macross (cameo by Hikaru, Misa, Minmay & Britai) MF: VF0, VF1, SDF Macross, Megaroad 01, M7 warships (cameo by Minmay, Misa, Hikary, Roy, Britai and Mao, Shin and Sara) Edited June 3, 2009 by nexxstrait Quote
thankheaven Posted June 2, 2009 Posted June 2, 2009 Full series should always move forward, but OVA's could be set in between other shows or as sidestories. Quote
Chokinzoku SG-01 Posted June 3, 2009 Posted June 3, 2009 I completely agree. Big West can produce a show that features Max & Miria alongside new characters but not a show with Hikaru, Misa and Minmay? Come on. There are fans that supported Macross in the beginning--back in 82'-'83! Fans of the original show that spent tons of money to propel it to the success that spawned all these sequels set 50+ years in the future. Fans buying stacks of Bandai 1/55 valkyries and books and records/cassette tapes/CDs in 1984. They never got the ending they wanted. I remember when the Flashback 2012 LD came out in '87 there was so much interest in the new footage and..then in turned out to be just a glimpse of what could have been. Imagine a Megaroad 01 movie/OVA/series with the original cast, VF-4s in full-blown ultra modern CG battle scapes, Breetai, Minmay singing old and new songs--it would be colossal in both size and box office/DVD/BD impact. It would be a worldwide sales phenomenon for Big West. With that cast, it could be marketed everywhere. At the end of the day, Big West is a business, and clearly there is a business case that can be made for such a project. At this point I know there is a slim chance of the original cast ever returning (maybe for the 30th?) but imagine if Bilrer meets Minmay in the Macross Frontier movie and she sings the ending song along with Sheryl and Ranka...?! Yeah right. Lastly, I would rather have no continuation of the original cast anime than a Hollywood live action flick that desecrates everything beyond comprehension. God help us if Hollywood ever makes a Macross live action flick with Charlie Sheen playing Hikaru and Ziyi Zhang playing Minmay....don't laugh...with the success of Transformers, worse things may happen... Agreed, one of the things I asked myself was why wasn't Macross 7 about the further adventures on the Megaroad. I think they could have had more stories to tell if we followed them on their travels looking for a planet to colonize. Quote
JB0 Posted June 3, 2009 Posted June 3, 2009 ... Fans buying stacks of Bandai 1/55 valkyries and books and records/cassette tapes/CDs in 1984. They never got the ending they wanted. ... Imagine a Megaroad 01 movie/OVA/series with the original cast, VF-4s in full-blown ultra modern CG battle scapes, Breetai, Minmay singing old and new songs... That's what everyone wanted in 1984? Okay, I grant more Minmay songs. I reiterate: The story HAD an ending. It had TWO endings, even. The post-war arc is almost painful with it's re-opening of the love triangle. (I love the fact that the show actually deals with the ramifications of the end of the world, but the core love triangle makes me cringe.) Throw in DYRL's alternate version and there's THREE endings. The original cast's story is over. All we'll get out of revisiting them is a bunch of Minmay fans whining about how Hikaru needs to break it off with Misa. ... Or worse yet, he WILL break it off with Misa and start the triangle all over again. Quote
nexxstrait Posted June 3, 2009 Posted June 3, 2009 I reiterate: The story HAD an ending. It had TWO endings, even. The post-war arc is almost painful with it's re-opening of the love triangle. (I love the fact that the show actually deals with the ramifications of the end of the world, but the core love triangle makes me cringe.) I agree. SDF Macross is probably the most complete anding we have in Macross terms. The hero gets with the woman he loves, the enemies are vanquished and a new era for mankind begins. With 2012 we even get to see them departing to the stars! Quote
thankheaven Posted June 3, 2009 Posted June 3, 2009 (edited) If they do go back to Hikaru and company they should ONLY be supporting characters and no more love triangle or something like that. Their story is finished but to have a show set onboard the Megaroad 01 featuring a new set of characters with Hikaru and company in the background would be okay in my opinion. Hikaru, Misa and Minmey were completely developed as characters when the show ended and it finished well with no loose ends. Max and Miriya didn't get that much attention as a couple but it got further explored in Macross 7. Even Roy Focker got more attention in Macross Zero so all the main characters got what they deserved. I feel that exploring them any further then that may end up hurting them in the end. Edited June 3, 2009 by thankheaven Quote
ClassicCowboy Posted April 28, 2020 Posted April 28, 2020 On 6/3/2009 at 7:20 AM, thankheaven said: If they do go back to Hikaru and company they should ONLY be supporting characters and no more love triangle or something like that. Their story is finished but to have a show set onboard the Megaroad 01 featuring a new set of characters with Hikaru and company in the background would be okay in my opinion. Hikaru, Misa and Minmey were completely developed as characters when the show ended and it finished well with no loose ends. Max and Miriya didn't get that much attention as a couple but it got further explored in Macross 7. Even Roy Focker got more attention in Macross Zero so all the main characters got what they deserved. I feel that exploring them any further then that may end up hurting them in the end. I agree. But I would love to see a new series with a new gen finding the Megaroad-01 and finding out what actually happened. The whole just disappearing doesn’t leave us with any closure at all. Preferably without guitar playing giant robots and Hikaru and Misa not given the Dr Shaw treatment from the last Alien movie. Minmei... eh. She probably died from trying to pet something that looked cute and ate her. And I’m ok with that. Quote
Bolt Posted April 28, 2020 Posted April 28, 2020 "Die hard original Macross fan" would be down with love triangles, singing idol and transforming mecha action. And depending on which side of which pond were talking, that definition gets warped. 39 minutes ago, ClassicCowboy said: The whole just disappearing doesn’t leave us with any closure at all. Welcome to Macross! How about Shin and Sara. And Alto Saotome...? I'd rather know where Basara is at now Quote
Tochiro Posted April 29, 2020 Posted April 29, 2020 Well Kawamori did say on television just a little under a year ago that he had concept for a Macross 7 sequel that he was interested in doing. Which would make sense given how Basara is the 2nd most popular character in the entire franchise. Will he actually do it though? Personally, I doubt it. But the hope that Fire Bomber will return to our screens one day springs eternal :-) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.