Einherjar Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 The designs are okay, but can they transform?
Knight26 Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 where are your designs? Are they in that link in your signature? Some of them are, I've also got a lot of old WIP threads on here showcasing more of them. They are all for my books, the first of which should be released no later then February 09, just waiting on my editor and cover artist.
Knight26 Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 The designs are okay, but can they transform? Mine or their's, Mine do not, their's do not really look like they can without alot of anime magic.
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 4, 2008 Author Posted December 4, 2008 The designs are okay, but can they transform? it seems some of them do http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Of88RlA5_f8
SchizophrenicMC Posted December 5, 2008 Posted December 5, 2008 Simple rule to apply: Fanfic / Fan productions = non-canon CRAP! And that goes for anything. *Imitates John Madden* Now this is a guy who has never read a good fic. I tell ya, this guy has never read a good fic. This guy has never read a good fic. And that's what that's all about.
taksraven Posted December 5, 2008 Posted December 5, 2008 *Imitates John Madden* Now this is a guy who has never read a good fic. I tell ya, this guy has never read a good fic. This guy has never read a good fic. And that's what that's all about. To be honest I have read a few that were above average but still, I consider it to be really pointless. Taksraven
yellowlightman Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 You really need to respond to a thread that you last posted? With no new information or worthwhile input?
Morpheus Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 I think Lindem Herz stated it well. Their modelling and animation is fine, but their designs are horrible and show no sense of engineering design principles. In my own designs everything has a purpose, there are no "hey would cool tacked on here" parts. If something is there it has a purpose. What is the purpose of those stupid balls on the shoulders, or the ridiculously huge guns or unneeded fins. Besides I think the whole of the production is tripe, it makes no sense to make, the designs are a mess, now the animation itself looks great for a fan production, almost better then Shadow Chronicles in some ways. lol, I don't think most fan ever consider engineering design principle in their design, the only thing that came into their mind is "it would be cool if I place this thingy here". I have to admit that I also made several ludicrous design and posted them on scifi mesh forum, but I was lucky enough that most of the critic are positive lol.
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 10, 2008 Author Posted December 10, 2008 haha... well I was going to keep this thread like it was, but since it was bumped.. I found a couple of new screenshots I thought the Southern Cross fandom was dead, but it seems there are a couple around yet And this pictures just looked cool to me
taksraven Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 You really need to respond to a thread that you last posted? With no new information or worthwhile input? Yeah, why not. Its a fun thread that just needs a new injection of steam to keep it going. Taksraven
Tober Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 haha... well I was going to keep this thread like it was, but since it was bumped.. I found a couple of new screenshots I thought the Southern Cross fandom was dead, but it seems there are a couple around yet Southern Cross ? Besides wasn't 'Robotech: Genesis' about the escape of the SDF-1 and it's landing on Earth before the Zentradi arrived?
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 11, 2008 Author Posted December 11, 2008 Southern Cross ? Besides wasn't 'Robotech: Genesis' about the escape of the SDF-1 and it's landing on Earth before the Zentradi arrived? I dont know, it seems you know more about the argument than I do. Where did you get that?
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 11, 2008 Author Posted December 11, 2008 I just said so because of those southern cross based mecha and vessels
Roger Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 These designers are really big on the "reeded edge" effect.
taksraven Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 I've seen LEGO spaceships that are more streamlined than that monstrosity in the first few pics. Should be named USS BLOCKY. Taksraven
Morpheus Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 Wow, an SDF-1 on steroid Make it transform and watch this thread explode
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 11, 2008 Author Posted December 11, 2008 Where is the SDF-1? Did you mean the last picture I posted? That one looks pretty much that vessel from Southern Cross which is used to try to destroy a Robotech Masters vessel
Knight26 Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 For the love of god someone show them how to turn on the anti-aliasing filter. And that ADF-1 looks like the unholy love child of the Macross and those southern cross ships with a hint of mospeada thrown in there.
Keith Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 Robotech has some of the worst fanfiction in all of aci-fi
Tober Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 I dont know, it seems you know more about the argument than I do. Where did you get that? The novel by Jack McKinney http://www.amazon.com/Robotech-Genesis-1-J...2608&sr=8-3 The Graphic novel by Mike Baron and Carl Macek http://www.amazon.com/Robotech-Graphic-Nov...608&sr=8-12 I read them 25 odd years ago. There was also a comic series by Jason and John Waltrip as well but I haven't read it.
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 11, 2008 Author Posted December 11, 2008 The novel by Jack McKinney http://www.amazon.com/Robotech-Genesis-1-J...2608&sr=8-3 The Graphic novel by Mike Baron and Carl Macek http://www.amazon.com/Robotech-Graphic-Nov...608&sr=8-12 I read them 25 odd years ago. There was also a comic series by Jason and John Waltrip as well but I haven't read it. I see what you mean, I'm not sure they called the movie Robotech Genesis because of that
eugimon Posted December 11, 2008 Posted December 11, 2008 wait wait wait... that thing is supposed to be the SDF-1 before it was the SDF-1? And what is that mecha thing? The original "veritech"? I have to see this now, this is going to be awesome! But then what are those alpha looking "veritechs"? I'm confused.
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 12, 2008 Author Posted December 12, 2008 I just found a new bioroid picture. But it looks different than the former one
Excillon Posted December 12, 2008 Posted December 12, 2008 Those pics look like funky ride armors to me.
taksraven Posted December 12, 2008 Posted December 12, 2008 Just watched the teaser trailer thingy for the first time, UGH!!!! Taksraven
Lindem Herz Posted December 12, 2008 Posted December 12, 2008 ... I think I just understood why the Trekkies complain so much about the redesigned Enterprise. But at least that thing looks decent. This is as pretty as a kick on the nuts
Morpheus Posted December 12, 2008 Posted December 12, 2008 ... I think I just understood why the Trekkies complain so much about the redesigned Enterprise. But at least that thing looks decent. This is as pretty as a kick on the nuts Well fanfic are created by fans with no funding and sometimes only a few people dedicated their life into it, don't compare it to mainstream industry where the producers are gambling funds with dozens of talented artist and plethora of studio art backing up. I still say this fanfic film is >>>> Shadow Chronicle and Star Wreck >>> any Star Trek after Search of Spock.
taksraven Posted December 12, 2008 Posted December 12, 2008 (edited) ... I think I just understood why the Trekkies complain so much about the redesigned Enterprise. But at least that thing looks decent. This is as pretty as a kick on the nuts Right. I like how it is pretty clear that they have spent 99% of their effort on the *mecha* and about 1% effort on the character design and implementation. And ALL of it STILL looks crap! Taksraven Edited December 12, 2008 by taksraven
VFTF1 Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 That's because the topic title is so wierd. Macross Saga "based" movie?... I think I remember reading this thread, but I forgot what it said and am too lazy to go re-read it Pete
yellowlightman Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 Things are pretty quiet here. Taksraven Are posts like that really necessary? If you don't have something to contribute, why bump a discussion thread?
taksraven Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 Are posts like that really necessary? If you don't have something to contribute, why bump a discussion thread? Sorry, I like to bump funny threads once in a while. You complained last time anyway so your objections were duly noted. (joke) Taksraven
kamikaze_kamujin Posted December 31, 2008 Author Posted December 31, 2008 Guess what, you cant edit a topic's name (or at least it seems so)
taksraven Posted January 2, 2009 Posted January 2, 2009 Guess what, you cant edit a topic's name (or at least it seems so) Only mods have that POWER!!!!! Taksraven
Recommended Posts