Chuey Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 RX-93 (with and without HWS) FAZZ GFF 0014 EX-S Gundam Taskforce Alpha Gundam Mk II Sazabi MS-18E Kämpfer Alex NT-1 Quote
drifand Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Simple... RX-178 Gundam Mk-II. No stupid gimmicks, just clean and brawny design - excellent update on the original. This opinion was build around the fact that back when Zeta was released, the RX-78 hadn't been retconned by Katoki yet and was still the same old fuddy duddy Ohkawara original. It was also the first DX Gundam toy I ever owned. Beautiful construction, excellent detailing and poseability. Quote
GobotFool Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 (edited) Well as a mod to my last post I have decided there are too many cool mecha to choose from in this series. That’s probably the one thing that keeps gundam so strong, variety. It has something for everyone, silliness, utilitarianism, slick pointless designs where the only purpose is to look cool. Variable designs, massive destruction. Generally speaking I just like the mechanical design of gundam. I have only seen one series all the way through, but still love all the designs from the original MS gundam, to seed. I'm a toy and model nut, sue me Though on a side note I have to agree with Mr. March. The best mecha keep it simple and to the point. That’s probably why my favorite Japanese mecha are ground ponders like Votoms, Dougram, and macross destroids. With patlabors, Zaku 2's, and valks coming next. What makes gundam so cool is the sheer absurdity of it mixed with a modicum of plausibility. Edited October 16, 2003 by GobotFool Quote
Roy Focker Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Only 3 are ones that I really like: The basic cannon fodder Zaku, that all grey GM in Gundam 0083 and the Kampfer. For the most part I like the cannon fodder mobile units over the super powered suits with all the extras. PS and that red Zeon one in 0080 that appear in the Zeon's first attack on the colony. Quote
Mr March Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Ugh. I hate the overly stylized mecha like the Xi Gundam, FAZZ, and Sentinel designs. Those designs are far too busy looking, with too many unecessary segments, flanges, and protrusions. A solid mecha design that stands the test of time will always look good based simply on the basic aesthetic essentials, like the VF-1 Valkyries of Macross, the RX-78-2 from Gundam, or the Ingrams of Patlabor. Totally agree. The Sentinel designs were really scratch build models Frankensteined from a bunch of different, unrelated parts without much rhythm or reason except to "look cool". Well yes, the Sentinel designs do have that problem as well. Design chaos is one of the additional reasons I don't care for many of them. But I just don't care for all the fluff Quote
Mr March Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Though on a side note I have to agree with Mr. March. The best mecha keep it simple and to the point. That’s probably why my favorite Japanese mecha are ground ponders like Votoms, Dougram, and macross destroids. With patlabors, Zaku 2's, and valks coming next. What makes gundam so cool is the sheer absurdity of it mixed with a modicum of plausibility. It's very interesting how much can be done with so little. Subtlety and basic form can count for much when designing a mecha. Quote
Mr March Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 *snip*PS and that red Zeon one in 0080 that appear in the Zeon's first attack on the colony. THis is probably the fella you're thinking of: Mobile Suit Gundam 0080: War in the Pocket MS-14jg Gelgoog Jaeger Quote
mikeszekely Posted October 16, 2003 Author Posted October 16, 2003 How about we limit it to 3 or so. "Favorite," doesn't mean much if you list 15 of 'em. If you want my just my three favorties, two off the bat would be the Gundam Mark II and the Nu Gundam. In my opinion, they are the two most elegant takes on the whole Gundam design. Every Gundam before them was too much like the robots of 70's sci-fi. Every Gundam since has been too stylized or over the top. That'd make my third choice come from one of the alternate universe stories. So for that one, Gundam Virsago from Gundam X. It had what's cool about Epyon and Shenlong from Gundam Wing amalgamated and polished until you had a supremely cool, supremely evil Gundam. Quote
Abombz!! Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 hey Abombz!!, where did you get those pics of the High Mobility and Heavy weapons Ez-8?? you posted them on the old boards, but i don't remember where they were. You mean these 2? I got both of them from mahq.net. They are customs that showed up in the SD Gundam: Gather Beat I Wonderswam game. Quote
GobotFool Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 My god..... that armored up EZ........ Quote
Abombz!! Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Ugh. I hate the overly stylized mecha like the Xi Gundam, FAZZ, and Sentinel designs. Those designs are far too busy looking, with too many unecessary segments, flanges, and protrusions. A solid mecha design that stands the test of time will always look good based simply on the basic aesthetic essentials, like the VF-1 Valkyries of Macross, the RX-78-2 from Gundam, or the Ingrams of Patlabor. Different strokes for different folks. I like the Xi not because of its look, but more for its story as the first and only MS to be self sufficient. It flew from Jupiter to Earth on its own. And while I could agree with your point.... I simply have to say that while simplistic MS can be good, they have astetically pleasing, otherwise they look too ugly. <_< Thats said.... the Quebley is my favorite MS design. It looks simplistic, has simplistic weapons, one heck of a pilot, and an overall pleasing roundness. Quote
Isamu Atreides 86 Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 thanks Abombz!!. damn those are sweet!! Quote
Vostok 7 Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 (edited) and an overall pleasing roundness. Ke ke ke ke I usually like full armor stuff and things, but the Heavy Weapons Ez-8 is a little much. Looks like it'd fall over easy. Not to mention all those things hanging off would make movement in a forest next to impossible. The High Mobility type is a little better, but seems out of place considering the story line. Vostok 7 Edited October 16, 2003 by Vostok 7 Quote
motley Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 my longstanding favorite is the Zaku line, every single one from the Zaku I to the Geara doga, including the Zaku III and the Hi-zak. though my favorites are the Geara doga and the Zaku FZ from 0080. as for gundams, i prefer the Zeta and the nu gundam. after that, its the Zeta plus C1 and the gundam MK III, with the RX-78 and the alex lagging behind. beyond that the gyan, gouf, and kampfer are favorites, along with the shining and master gundams from G, and any incarnation of the GM. i loves the cannon fodder, leos too. Quote
GobotFool Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Ugh. I hate the overly stylized mecha like the Xi Gundam, FAZZ, and Sentinel designs. Those designs are far too busy looking, with too many unecessary segments, flanges, and protrusions. A solid mecha design that stands the test of time will always look good based simply on the basic aesthetic essentials, like the VF-1 Valkyries of Macross, the RX-78-2 from Gundam, or the Ingrams of Patlabor. Different strokes for different folks. I like the Xi not because of its look, but more for its story as the first and only MS to be self sufficient. It flew from Jupiter to Earth on its own. And while I could agree with your point.... I simply have to say that while simplistic MS can be good, they have astetically pleasing, otherwise they look too ugly. Thats said.... the Quebley is my favorite MS design. It looks simplistic, has simplistic weapons, one heck of a pilot, and an overall pleasing roundness. I've said it before and I'll say if again, the quebly is one funky looking mecha Quote
GobotFool Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 On the other hand the Z'gok E, thats a really nifty guy. Quote
treatment Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 (edited) CCA: [*] Sazabi [*] Nu 0080: [*] Kampfer [*] NT1 Alex 8th MS-Team: [*] RX-79 (G) [*] Ez-8 [*] Sniper-GM 0083: [*] GP-01 FB Gundam-X [*] GX-9901 [*] Leopard Wing/ Endless Waltz [*] Zero (endless waltz) [*] TallGeese III [*] Nataku [*] Sandrock Kai [*] Heavy Arms Kai [*] Serpent G-Gundam [*] tequila gundam !!!! [*] sailor moon gundam nobel!!! Edited October 16, 2003 by treatment Quote
Californium Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 RX-93 Nu and the Mk II. As others have said, sleek, straightforward, and well-defined. Quote
Smut Peddler Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 I'm Zeon all the way: Gouf Flight Type Gerbera Tetra Gouf Custom Kämpfer Zaku II's - all variations Gelgoog Dom Tropen Quebley Hizak etc. Quote
rnurmin Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 My favourites: 1) S- Gundam, although I have never seen them in the anime 2) Zeta Plus Gundam, looks cool 3) Sazabi, looks mean. 4) Kampfer, an upgrade of Zaku with a bunch of weapons of mass destruction Quote
Mr March Posted October 16, 2003 Posted October 16, 2003 Ugh. I hate the overly stylized mecha like the Xi Gundam, FAZZ, and Sentinel designs. Those designs are far too busy looking, with too many unecessary segments, flanges, and protrusions. A solid mecha design that stands the test of time will always look good based simply on the basic aesthetic essentials, like the VF-1 Valkyries of Macross, the RX-78-2 from Gundam, or the Ingrams of Patlabor. Different strokes for different folks. I like the Xi not because of its look, but more for its story as the first and only MS to be self sufficient. It flew from Jupiter to Earth on its own. And while I could agree with your point.... I simply have to say that while simplistic MS can be good, they have astetically pleasing, otherwise they look too ugly. Thats said.... the Quebley is my favorite MS design. It looks simplistic, has simplistic weapons, one heck of a pilot, and an overall pleasing roundness. Fair enough. IMO, most of the over-the-top designs just look too impractical to build. So many elements of the design would hinder efficiency; even simple articulation would be problematic (without animation magic of course). Basically, a mecha that's too busy hinders my suspension of disbelief. Personally, I have no real preference for round vs. blocky mecha designs. I know most people stick by their love of all things circular or all things square, but a good mecha design can be either...or both! Many of my favorite Valkyries are smoth and rounded yet I love some of the very blocky Gundam designs. Quote
Shade Posted October 17, 2003 Posted October 17, 2003 All around favorite - Gundam Mk II - It's the RX-78, only with muscles. Runner-up - Hi-Nu Gundam - Mainly because I made one into a monster unit while playing G Generation Zero. If I'd had the money, I'd consider buying the B-Club 1/100 mod for the MG. Up and coming - Providence Gundam - NT equipped Gundam Mk II on steroids. Quote
Abombz!! Posted October 17, 2003 Posted October 17, 2003 Fair enough. IMO, most of the over-the-top designs just look too impractical to build. So many elements of the design would hinder efficiency; even simple articulation would be problematic (without animation magic of course). Basically, a mecha that's too busy hinders my suspension of disbelief Yep... I agree. In that case, its what we call "pretty on paper, but ugly when animated" or the other way around too. I like the Xi Gundam and other over the top designs, but if I was to seem them animated, I doubt I would still like them (though, some of those over the top designs spend most of the time "floating", so articulation wouldn't really be an issue). Just take the Ex S Gundam. Its an extremely over the top design, but when you look at if, articulation isn't really an issue because the Ex S Gundam is always floating in space. Quote
Mr March Posted October 17, 2003 Posted October 17, 2003 Fair enough. IMO, most of the over-the-top designs just look too impractical to build. So many elements of the design would hinder efficiency; even simple articulation would be problematic (without animation magic of course). Basically, a mecha that's too busy hinders my suspension of disbelief Yep... I agree. In that case, its what we call "pretty on paper, but ugly when animated" or the other way around too. I like the Xi Gundam and other over the top designs, but if I was to seem them animated, I doubt I would still like them (though, some of those over the top designs spend most of the time "floating", so articulation wouldn't really be an issue). Just take the Ex S Gundam. Its an extremely over the top design, but when you look at if, articulation isn't really an issue because the Ex S Gundam is always floating in space. Hehehe, then why bother with arms or legs? Just build a Starfury or X-Wing Quote
Abombz!! Posted October 17, 2003 Posted October 17, 2003 Fair enough. IMO, most of the over-the-top designs just look too impractical to build. So many elements of the design would hinder efficiency; even simple articulation would be problematic (without animation magic of course). Basically, a mecha that's too busy hinders my suspension of disbelief Yep... I agree. In that case, its what we call "pretty on paper, but ugly when animated" or the other way around too. I like the Xi Gundam and other over the top designs, but if I was to seem them animated, I doubt I would still like them (though, some of those over the top designs spend most of the time "floating", so articulation wouldn't really be an issue). Just take the Ex S Gundam. Its an extremely over the top design, but when you look at if, articulation isn't really an issue because the Ex S Gundam is always floating in space. Hehehe, then why bother with arms or legs? Just build a Starfury or X-Wing Then it wouldn't be a Gundam show. And because while the articualation might not be as critical, some might be required for versatility of a MS. Quote
Commander McBride Posted October 18, 2003 Posted October 18, 2003 Mmmmm... Qubeley..... I don't know, I used to hate that kind of stuff, but now I can't get enough of that kind of stuff. The curviness, the pink and white, all of it. It's part of what I've been thinking of as my turning into the world's only heterosexual male fangirl. Quote
Vostok 7 Posted October 18, 2003 Posted October 18, 2003 heterosexual male fangirl. Ke ke ke 0_o ^_~ Vostok 7 Quote
Yohsho Posted October 18, 2003 Posted October 18, 2003 So I'll put up my list, but most of my fav mobile suits have been listed. So I'll try to stick up some that haven't been listed. There alot more of them, but I can't remember their names right now or have been listed. Zeta plus Blitz Gundam Freedom Gundam GM Cannon Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.