What Happened To The VFX2 Visual Guide

[briscojr84]

Anybody know what happened to the VFX2 Visual guide thread in the book review forum.

[SuperOstrich]

Sure it wasn't in the old forums?

[briscojr84]

Nope, I just replied to it myself a few days ago when someone asked about the book and I gave a break down of it's contents.

[Agent ONE]

If something is posted in the review section and it isn't really a review in a traditional sense of the word, it usually gets canned.

[SuperOstrich]

That would probably be why. The review forums are for permanent reviews of Macross items. If you just want to mention something small about a book, video, etc, it goes in the Movies and TV Series forum.

[briscojr84]

What would be considered a full blown review then.

Accidently hit send button.

Here is pretty much what I did as an example

Pages 1-4 Covers Such and such an item

I also gave a comment on how I would rate the book and my opinion of it.

I'm not trying to argue a point I'm just curious to know what a full blown review would cover.

Edited September 16, 2003 by briscojr84

[Roy Focker]

Bingo. That was the reason why it was nuked.

Look at Area's Seven Anime views or better yet read a news paper for book or movie reviews. It isn't a short couple of sentences saying I think this is neat. A review is good length, well written paragraph or two about your opinion of "X". It should be something that we would want to save for all of history to see. A review is something that can stand on it's own without someone starting it off by asking what is your opinion of "X".

[briscojr84]

Maybe you guys should put a pinned guidelines thread in there then.