Gubaba
-
Posts
11673 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Gubaba
-
R.I.P. Davy Jones...
-
He's the anime messiah for people who hate anime, then?
-
Does the fact that it happens on "Island Reno" help you build your case?
-
Wait...there are no hair metal bands on that list. I call shenanigans.
-
So, uh...what did he do that was so amazing? Character design? Scriptwriting? WHAT?
-
Which question?
-
No, he said the "frakkING JAPANESE" are to blame. I'd argue that the "frakkING JAPANESE" also CREATED the show in the first place. I'd also argue that they aren't "frakkING" at all. Damn New Mexicans...
-
Huh? I don't get your logic here...so blaming everyone in a CONTINENT is racist, but blaming everyone in a COUNTRY isn't...? So, for example, saying, "Damn Irish!" isn't racist, but saying "Damn Europeans!" is? By what standard?
-
Maybe "you, Cobra" should stop being such a racist! And of course, by "you, Cobra," I mean a ton of Robotech fans. Be more flexible! Anyway, Mommar said you corrected yourself. What was he referring to?
-
His post still says... ,does it not? How did he "correct himself" after being totally racist the first time 'round?
-
Still...you're blaming an ENTIRE RACE ("the Japanese") for the way ONE COMPANY decides to do business. There's a word for that, isn't there...?
-
Ah. I see the problem. You're assuming Tatsunoko actually CARES about what happens to their properties outside Japan.
-
Here's an idea...why don't you let Robotech sink or swim on its own...?
-
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT...? Isn't Macross doing well on its own...?
-
Suit yourself... From my perspective, Robotech can go. What has it ever done for itself?
-
Dude, what do you think the last FIVE YEARS have been, if not a hiatus...? New Robotech? Nowhere to be seen! New Macross? EVERYWHERE. New Mospeada? Well, there was that book...
-
No. Mostly, I just try to be educational.
-
-
But, but...you don't UNDERSTAND! They looked at the scripts AFTER they wrote the scripts! And revised them to fit the originals! Bah, screw this. If RT fans are THAT delusional, there's no saving 'em. At any rate, this is the last time I ever defend one of 'em. I'm sorry I did it in the first place.
-
So what we've got is a "he said/she said" type argument, yes? Noboru Ishiguro said the Macross staff didn't approve of the Robotech dub. Greg Snegoff says they went without a script and that the Japanese staff liked it. Which part of this is "verifiable"? I don't live far from the Big West office. If I go to them and ask what they think of Robotech, is that "verifiable" evidence to you?
-
I met my first girlfriend at a terrible college... ...what's your point?
-
I'm sorry, I simply don't believe that. The similarities between the two are too great. Have you watched both versions? I'm sorry, I must be stupid. You keep asking me to re-read what you wrote, but I see nothing verifiable in your posts. What am I supposed to be re-reading again...? Let's just say that I've had trouble before. I defended more than one Robotech fan as being sincere, when they were simply trolls trying to be as disruptive (and idiotic) as possible. I figured I'd been made a patsy again, by someone who just wanted to argue about Robotech rather than discuss Macross. Am I wrong, and you're actually on the level...? How many Macross threads have you posted in recently? Forgive me for probing, but, as I said, I've been burned before.
-
True...but if he;s saying what I think you're saying he's saying (basically, that they made the scripts THEN looked at the translations), then I think he's either misinformed or lying. I'm not implying anything. I'm flat-out STATING that if he said they made the scripts before they looked at the translations, then he's lying. Agreed. But, a question: How many Macross Zero vids on Youtube have the word "Robotech" attached to them? Conversely, how many Sentinels vids have the word "Macross" attached to them? I see lots of Robotech fans trying to incorporate Macross-only stories into Robotech (Hell, Relak even came up with a way to fit Macross 7 into the party...just change Captain Mac Jenius into Captain Scott Bernard and you've got it!), but I haven't seen any Macross fans trying to fit Robotech into the Macross timeline. Have you found any...? Of course. But respect doesn't mean capitulation. You like Robotech. Great. Have fun. But why are you on a Macross site again...? Huh...Noboru Ishiguro's interview in Animag gives a VERY DIFFERENT view of the staff's reaction. I wonder who's right...?
-
Weren't you the one who asked me "Why the fuck are you here?" on RTX? Can I ask you the same question now...?
-
Yes, you said the scripts arrived after. Do you have proof of this or no? Like most RT fans, you jump to assumptions when they serve you. But, no. Sure, be a Robotech fan, if you want. I know that any post I make on RTX is crushing another Robotech fan's illusions. Can you say the same...? Again, if you've posted in other threads, then you're not who I'm talking about. I mean, hell, I find it FASCINATING what Robotech fans dupe themselves into believing, but obviously, I don't think I should be banned from a Macross forum. Do you want me to name names...? I can do that, I've just been too polite to.
