Master Dex

The old list also didn't have the VF-25 or 27 T-W figures because Marchy made it before those were released. So if it is to be amended, might as well add all known figures, heheh. Hmm.. one might think the VF-2SS would have even more power than the 25 being at a later year. However it is an alternate universe so maybe not. I'll have to wait and see what it is I suppose.

I didn't comment on all of this as I just hadn't visited the site in a while, but good to see it will be running again. Good to see you back as well March. M3 has always been the best way for me to totally geek out about the various engineering facts related to practically every Valkyrie in existence. I also rather enjoy that Thrust to Weight ratio chart.

I've just neglected this almost totally. Been really busy with school work. If I find the time, I'll try to catch up.

Maybe next time then, . Everything seems to be well squared off here. Good point too that the full thrust of even the YF-21 was enough to rip it apart. I remember seeing there were safe atmospheric values for the VF-25 and VF-27. In space this is irrelevant as long as you have the Inertial Damper thing to make the pilot not dead. I have a bit of a science nitpick though. A lot of people keep referencing burn up due to atmospheric friction. The classic burning through the atmosphere thing is in fact not caused by friction. This is a very very common mistake as most people just aren't aware though. It is actually that the high speeds causes the craft to violently compress air in front of them, heating it up. This is what causes the red glow and the burning effect. It is true that there is friction due to air resistance, but it isn't what is causing all that heat during re-entry. This is also why the feathering gimmicks of SpaceShipOne and SpaceShipTwo negates this, it keeps the air from compressing so much by changing the craft's surface area, therefore allowing it to re-enter without as much heat. The friction is there, but it doesn't do as much in reality. That being said, the VF-25 and VF-27 engines are pushing the craft at forces far greater than weight due to gravity, so maxing those in atmosphere is just death waiting to happen. QED.

Hah, I doubt that. Now if you really want me to explain why (though Seto seems to have the gist of it down), I can. I am an Aerospace Engineering student, this stuff is what I do. I rather not spend the time typing up the explanation (partly because Seto got the key points down). Suffice it to say if you put VF-25 engines on a VF-1 and tried to fly it, the forces would rip the plane to shreds. Possibly even burning shreds if the air in front of the plane were to violently compress to the levels it does when spacecraft re-enter the atmosphere (more so actually). The VF-25 airframe is designed to work with that thrust, the VF-1 was not.

I still haven't watched episode 11... yeah, school work and other projects getting to me. I'll try and get to it though.

So... did we do episode 11?

In fact there are thrusters on the VF-25 Gerwalk in the back area where the shield connects in fighter mode. They are under the backside piece and are very small. Considering the technological development of NUNS/Shinsei/LAI it is likely that despite size these small thrusters have a lot of power behind them.

You have a point for the jets. However we don't know if it was even Mars. I am skeptical to the terraforming still. Your mention of the scene from the last episode of SDFM is notable, but it could have been when that area was animated they forgot everything was supposed to be dead, or perhaps that was a lucky area that wasn't blasted (only about 70% of the planet was hit, which means a lot of water was hit I guess...). Though that does seem unlikely. The thing is, in the Reconstruction episode, Hikaru just found a flower which was a sign life was coming back after almost two years. Seems unlikely after that they realized they could reforest entire mountains in less than a year. I don't even know how you would do that, terraforming aside. Incidentally I'm going to go on a science bit here, even though it isn't related to an episode in general. Terraforming doesn't necessarily have to do with planting either, it is just that for Mars that is a necessity to increase oxygen levels. The biggest problems for Mars is it's low temperature due to thin atmosphere (itself due to lower gravity) and the planet's lack of a magnetic field to shield from cosmic radiation. The latter is likely caused by Mars' inner core solidifying millions (perhaps billions) of years ago due to cooling. We can raise the heat of Mars by (ironically) polluting it to raise greenhouse gases. In other words... global warming. Another way is to put a spacecraft near an asteroid to tug it over several years so it will impact Mars in the northern icecap (there are reasons for the northern over the southern but I won't get into that). This impact will melt the ice there and spread it out increasing carbon dioxide levels which will cause the same type of greenhouse gas effect. We will have to do more work to make the atmosphere cleaner for us but either way we have to dirty up the planet first to heat it up. The greenhouse gases could also increase air pressure. It would be to the point where you'd only need an oxygen mask to walk outside instead of a full space suit. Then you can work on the breathing bit. As for the magnetic field... I don't know if we can naturally restore that or not. However in the future I can see us being able to artificially generate a planet sized magnetic field to protect the planet. Would take a lot of power but planetary magnetic fields are actually pretty weak compared to some things we have done. They are just big. I have no doubt in the future, probably some hundred years ahead that living on Mars could be common place. My point to all this is that it seems unlikely that even if the UN Spacey could reforest entire mountains and as such set up forests on Mars in such a short time, I don't know if they could do all the other things (plants wouldn't survive very well in the cold temperatures, and the cosmic radiation will not be nice to them either). Now of course this doesn't mean that the writers of the show knew all this, so it certainly could be possible that Mars is completely terraformed in the context of Macross because they just decided that it is possible for them. So yeah, it could be that Gamlin was on Mars there in the show. I am just using my science bit to explain what it would really take. After all we don't know how terraforming processes have been advanced thanks to overtechnology.

Could be a large enclosure on Mars using holography to simulate Earth appearances like the colony fleets do. 30 years is too short for terraforming to have done anything so I'd guess this to be the case. Or the flashbacks are when he was elsewhere for whatever reason.

Ok then, Episode 10. I liked this episode, really did. Ray is an interesting character and we learn a bit about his past for the first time here. I know there is an M7 Plus short eventually that goes into detail with his friendship with Stephan and how both had a thing for Akiko but Ray backed off. I am watching the remastered episodes though and they don't have those so I have only seen that once. I don't remember if it was attached to this episode or later. Anyway, they say Ray vowed to never use a gun or fight again after he inadvertently caused Stephan to get killed. They don't label it but that could be classified as a type of Post Traumatic Stress disorder. In this case the trauma being the loss of his best friend. Luckily it seems meeting Basara and finding somthing new for him helped him get over a lot of that. They don't directly say, but Ray's secret friends that got Basara's Valkyrie out to the catapult were most likely friends he had from when he was in the Pink Pecker squadron. So special favors for him are no big deal. It isn't said how much of Ray's past Basara is privy too. He says he doesn't know anything and doesn't stick his nose into other people's past but he could be saying that because he believes it is Ray's business to tell people if he wants. Akiko clearly didn't think that way. Of course Basara might not really know. I think he does though because after everyone left the hospital room and just Ray and Basara are there, there seems to be a silence of understanding. Basara would never wonder why Ray didn't shoot. We know why Basara wouldn't but the reasoning is different. I got the impression he knew and his silence was sort of a way of saying he understood. On that note I figure Basara knows more about Ray because their friendship is more than just being band mates. I personally believe Ray is who taught Basara how to pilot a valkyrie. It isn't often stated but Basara is a truly exceptional pilot. Actually it is stated in this very episode, by Max himself. That is true acknowledgment there. Of course in true Max fashion he allows himself some self-gloating about the fact that he is still the best. Max will always be my favorite Macross character for traits like that. While Basara isn't as good as Max, he is still really good. This becomes even more apparent much later on in Dynamite 7 when we see him piloting a valkyrie with normal controls but using his acoustic guitar to nudge them and he is still able to fly well. That is some crazy skill! So Basara had to learn this skill somewhere, and Ray was a pilot. So it stands to reason that Ray is who taught Basara the basics at least. We also know that Ray is who gave Basara the VF-19. Hinted at in this episode was that it was a part of a secret operation known as Operation M. All of us who've seen the show before know what that is but since it wasn't elaborated on further I'll keep quiet on that for now. So we learn a lot about characters in this episode. Unfortunately as I said before, I couldn't find anything obvious or outstanding that I could talk about for my science bit this time. It rained again in City 7 but I talked about that already. For anyone though who thinks I overdo it with the science bit, I just like clarifying things and clearing misconceptions. I'm not really out to nitpick everything done wrong, it is an anime after all and not everything will be correct. If I wanted to be really annoying I'd talk nonstop about how all the valks and ships move around in space. 90% of sci-fi tends to not portray accurate movements in microgravity. However I don't talk about this because it would be futile and it is just a show. Hence why I only talk about various specific things I see in each individual episode. I have just as much fun noting something they did that was scientifically accurate as I do explaining why something is not. Finally, I'm a sucker for Totsugeki Love Heart, always good to hear that song. I do like Planet Dance (easily a victim of the aforementioned Planet Dance effect) but I'd listen to Totsugeki Love Heart over that any day.

Perhaps a bad pun on 'New' UN Spacey?

Ok, I cheated. Only Thursday night and I watched episode 10, but I like this one. I'll wait a day or so to post my stuff though. Big character episode, Ray mostly. I don't know if I have much to say for the science bit in this episode, so that may be a bit dry. Either way, I'll get to my review tomorrow.

Yeah, there can be only one Max.

Yeah, I've been saying it for months.

Ok, I just watched it. I'm not going to review every aspect, especially the Alice Holiday stuff because people did that already and all. I was thinking a lot about Pete's musing as questions about spiritia. I'm not going to talk about sound energy since we aren't there yet so I'll cover spiritia based only on the observed stuff so far. Now I am not a neurologist so can only say so much. It is a proven fact that music can change someone's mood. Here it seems to me that when the vamps were stealing Alice's spiritia she was getting more and more depressed to the point she didn't even feel like standing. Had that been pushed further I imagine a person would let themselves stop breathing and just die. Spiritia isn't a life force per say as we can live without it but without it we might not care to live. In this aspect spiritia kind of becomes a term with no clear definition. Now to go back on the brain chemistry bit, when certain songs are heard (there are also many other stimuli for this as well), our brain can emit various chemicals like horomones that can change how we feel, making us feel better or worse (music making you feel worse is a rarity and depends on your mood and tastes). It seems to me when spiritia is drained, the Protodeviln are robbing our brains of the ability to secrete these chemicals that can makes us feel better or even to feel anything. This is why the worst of those drained end up in catatonic states. They aren't dead, they have just lost the will to continue living. It isn't Fire Bomber's music necessarily that is helping them, but the reason their music works is because Basara strives to sing from his heart and not just to what is popular. That makes the difference here, even if it might not sell well initially. So in a sense what the protodeviln are feeding off isn't our life, but our brain chemistry, emotions, perhaps the nature of the soul. Of course we cannot yet quantify what exactly the soul is (like I said until we get to the subject of sound energy later I'm not going to cover that). I think that is why it is so hard to get a clear idea of just what spiritia is. I think to the protodeviln, it is just something they know they need and they can see we have it. They are from another universe where physics are different and they are energy (I know the show says another dimension but if you know the difference between universes and dimensions what I say really does make more sense). Here they are physical, and they don't know how to keep themselves alive or better yet, how keep their bodies working. So they noticed the difference others had and stole the difference. The fact that they have the ability to measure spiritia is more of a necessity than anything. They developed technology to do what they needed. What they are measuring is probably about the chemicals in the brain are affecting the body and all that. Now, I still want to mention the rain bit. They do have plants on board the ship, so they need rain. Obviously they have a reservoir of water, perhaps split into base elements and compressed as gas (water as a liquid is an incompressible fluid, splitting into gas to compress would make transportation easier). This water is also their drinking water, and every other use of water (remember my commentary on the resort ship's water supply?). The rain is mostly to keep up the plant life, and to resemble realistic Earth conditions. Any of the rain water not absorbed by plant life is probably drained through, cleaned, filtered, and reused for other water needs. Also I should note, that means even the water is finite. While you could stop places to find more water, more than likely they are recycling a lot of stuff. Some people balk at the idea of astronauts on the International Space Station recycling their urine and filtering the water out, but it does result in perfectly clean water. Whether you want to think of it or not, this is most likely happening. Though I imagine most people on the colony don't even realize it.

That makes sense, it also explains why NUNs had a lot of red tape issues with getting things done in Frontier. That is why they started contracting SMS to do work. NUNs was clearly held back by civilian oversight with what it could do anymore, so SMS was able to fill in the role of quick military action for a cheaper price than the regular military as SMS was paid both by their contractor and Mr. Bilrer's company which started them.

I wasn't going to talk about sound energy until they actually brought it up in the show, and that is a bit of a ways off. I do have quite a bit to say though. Also in Frontier those were just 'fold boosters' (they has to add fold as a prefix to everything in that show, I didn't like that). They basically applified the small fold waves that Ranka was apparently creating when she sang. The Vajra were in space, they couldn't hear her, they were sensing the fold vibrations she made. The boosters just amplified those vibrations. It could be theorized that the whole fold waves Ranka emitted was some new form of sound energy that permeated super dimensional space, but that is a bit of a stretch with no evidence to back it up. We know she generated them because she got the V type infection whilst in the womb. I still haven't watched episode 9, sorry. I'll talk about some spiritia stuff next post though, there is a bit I can say on that as well.

This seems very unrelated to Fire Bomber or Fukuyama.

I've heard of that maneuver, it is full of several inconsistencies but the basic idea you are mentioning is correct. Mostly the big problem is that the nuke's EMP effected them. Electromagnetic pulses can't happen in the vacuum of space where there is no magnetic field. In orbit of a planet you do have the field of the planet itself but planetary magnetic fields are very weak and in a high altitude like orbit the gamma rays from the nuke will disperse quickly and generate little to no magnetic field. However this has nothing to do with the topic, the fact remains: ramming is generally a last ditch move.

That is the simple answer, I'll address this in more detail probably in my science bit when I do my review. I haven't watched it yet though. Circumstance foils me again. Soon though.

Yeah, I just got busy, start of the new semester at school and all. I'm sure I'll get around to the episode sometime this weekend.

Yes, despite all that and even Sketchley bringing up that bit from Nemesis (Star Trek loves the ram as a last resort maneuver believe it or not), the reality is ramming a spacecraft into another as an attack is unlikely to ever work. Space warfare is most likely going to be a long distance endeavor where weapons are being fired toward each other while the two craft can barely see the other. They'll have it on radar or sensors or whatever they have. There is no real stealth in space after all. Even if a ship did try a ramming move, because of the distance, the other guy is going to notice what is going on an move out of the way. I will note though that with the size of spacecraft and the velocities they'd carry, a ram such as those would have tremendous energy release, like nuclear bomb levels of energy or more. The two ships would probably vaporize. In Macross though this is still possible, it is in a long line of sci fi shows that doesn't bother with the correct scale (not that this is terrible though) and has the ships relatively close to each other when they fight. Makes it more dramatic, which is why it is done, and that is good enough for me.

Regardless of the circumstances of the punch tactic or how it was conceived, when it comes to ship warfare (both naval and the fictional space based) it is a fact that one of the best attacks of last resort is the ever effective ramming the enemy ship with yours. The Daedalus attack gets away with the fact that while that part of the ship is ramming, it is protected by a shield. Most times, ramming maneuvers are finite and leave both ships out of the equation.

Man I think you are a little too hung up about the dress. I don't think there was any design to other characters wearing similar clothes, lol.