JB0

Why not shoot at short range too? There IS something besides "sniper" and "boxer." Which is why the Army has retired tanks for HUMVEEs? And the destroids that NEED to move CAN move. A spartan is relatively nimble. Not as much as a battroid or GERWALK, but again, it's built for a diffrent role(tank VS HUMVEE). Because they have guys to the side too? You're still thinking 1-on-1, which is NOT realistic. And you can see what you're shooting at from quite a distance thanks to amazing overtechnology inventions like telescopes. We already fight at extreme ranges now, and technology is INCREASING, not decreasing, the effective range of everything other than melee weapons. NEITHER SIDE would take ANYONE on one-by-one. A platoon of Tomahawks would be taking potshots at a platoon of Regults from the moment they were visible. I don't think I've said a single word about ANYBODY lining up to do a single-file charge. So the zentradi will rush the Tomahawks, losing signifigant men and machines in the process. They will penetrate the Tomahawk lines, to be greeted by... the Spartans built and equipped to deal with a close-combat situation. Or could if there weren't more destroids behind the line they just penetrated. Don't forget when Millia chased Max into Macross City. Neither situation involves destroids in their natural habitat. In fact, both situations involved all ship's defenses being baited away from the area in advance. And of course, there was the reversed Daedalus Attack, in which most of the ship's destroid compliment was decimated by a surprise attack by an overwhelming force, and the few remaining for the defense of Macross City were hopelessly outnumbered. Macross has had very little ground combat. Most if it was during reconstruction, where a shattered infrastructure left surprisingly little in the way of military bases, and the high speed of a Valkyrie was a necessity for rapid response to uprisings. But when they attacked protected facilities, like the airport, they were met with... destroids.

BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This is the funniest thing I've seen in ages.

A. There's no attacking aliens or evolution. Well, there's ONE attacking alien, but it only lasts half an episode. And while there's talk of the aliens WANTING to evolve, no one's actually DOING it. B. Yuki > Rei.

Isn't Starscream supposed to be sticking a dagger in Meggie's back?

Yes. And it rules. 408089[/snapback] Well then it's HELLA different from the manga! Which is on the boring side while feeling like a rip-off of NGE and just makes me wanna shot the b@tch(Asuka-clone). So... it's like FLCL then. 410589[/snapback] There's a manga too? And it's like NGE? Weird, neither the anime nor the novel(s) it's based on are anything like Eva. I'm curious to see the manga now, just to see how different it is from the novel. 410657[/snapback] There's actually TWO mangas. The first one was cancelled a month in because the author didn't like how radically it was deviating. The second one is running alongside the TV series, but it's pretty meh.

Starscream's iconic look is defined by the animation, every comic book from G1, G2, Dreamwave, the newest ones, and all the Super Robot Life TV Magazines and Manga. Every PVC incarnation, over a dozen in addition to the Robot Masters Starscream and the Cartoon Version Reissue of the G1 toy are all aspiring to the cartoon design. I could care less about the original G1 toy. The iconic image of Starcream was derived from the toy and intended to be different from the toy in the first place. Then why are you bent out of shape about the tail fins, when that iconic look is FINLESS? I think I stated as much in the first place, and you threw ANIMATION ERRORS back at me to explain why it needed tail fins on the feet. While hanging them off the hips is still not animation accurate, it at least looks less retarded than having them stick off the feet. An upper body. All that made Starscream was above the waist. Ya know, I considered pointing out exactly what I meant, but thought it would be understood. I guess not. Every rendition of the VF-1, animation errors excepted, is largely the same, save detail level. Yes a Yamato 1/48 kicks all kinds of crap out of a 1/55 Bandai, but when you get down to it, they're the SAME THING. Sure the Bandai is a bit chunkier, but the overall styling is the same. Aside from animation errors, there aren't any stray parts materializing, dematerializing, or moving with the whims of the current artists, except for the gunpod, which is either missing in fighter mode or hanging under the fighter along the centerline. By comparison, every Gen1 Transformer that made it to animation had no fewer than 3 designs: toy, box art, and cartoon. The diffrences were often drastic enough between the toy and animation that the Skyfire/Jetfire substitution doesn't look excessively absurd. If, as you say, only the official animation design counts... Starscream had no foot-fins.

I strongly recommend picking up the original SDF Macross TV series. No better way to cleanse yourself of the dark side than with the purity of the original series.

Because most of the original toys were pretty crappy. Your argument means that no articulation is also a good thing. The vast majority of interpretations of the original Starscream design depict him without tailfins on the legs. And he benefits greatly from it. Same can be said for attaching it to the legs. I agree there's too much attached to the hips, but it's better than having it on the legs. But the official animation design was finless. Are you really so desperate to make a point that you're going to use animation errors to support it? As does Masterpiece Starscream. The stuff on the hips is the only thing that greatly defies the original design, and it's an improvement over the original toy without resorting to the set-aside parts that would likely be necessary for a design consistent with other interpretations. Diffrence is that this is just one more in a long series of re-envisionings of Transformers. There were multiple incarnations of Starscream even during his original release(box art, cartoon, and toy were all diffrent designs). There is no singular "right" look for Starscream, and I prefer the clean-legged versions anyways. The VF-1, by contrast, DOES have a singular "right" look, head excepted.

The point is THE STUFF ON THE WAIST IS ABSOLUTELY UNNECCESSARY - even if the vehicle mode is better. 410396[/snapback] Is it just me, or does it look like Prime is grabbing the wheels like he's about to throw them? Anyways... Prime's statememt rings true in this case. Tailfins dangling off the feet = broke. Moving them makes for a much cleaner robot. And I do admit I had none of the jets as a kid, so my nostalgia isn't getting in the way(which could be an issue, since the Masterpiece toys are all about nostalgia). But I DO remember looking at the pictures in the foldout catalog and thinking the tailfins on the feet were dorky(only one I really wanted was Thrust, for unknown reasons). And Masterpiece Prime was intended to be faithful to the animation, not the toy. Animation Starscream had no leg fins. ... Of course, he had no hip fins either. For a TV-accurate Starscream, you'd have to take the fins off and set them aside.

New Starscream has scrawnie girlie legs. While they better match the high-heels, they just look wrong on him. That's my only real objection.

She stops doing the hair thing right after Kyon brings it up to her. 410323[/snapback] In fact, she cuts it off short so she CAN'T do the hair thing anymore. She COULD color-code the hair ribbon, but apparently it's too much work once someone's noticed she does it.

If you live in America, you're good to go. If you live in Europe, you have problems because your electrical voltage isn't 110-120, and your TV isn't 60Hz or NTSC. If you live somewhere else... You may or may not have problems depending on your areas AC and TV standards

But you got it backwards. The destroid is the device that does one task and does it well. The VF is the device that CAN do another device's task, but at greatly-reduced effectiveness. The clock is a fighter plane, the radio is a battroid. Neither requires powered armor as we know it, though. You could make a VF with similar controls. In fact, we KNOW Glaugs have quite flexible control schemes, as they're capable of using their arm cannons as melee weapons, which was almost certainly NOT part of the designer's intent. Like I said, the big advantage is that the QRau and NosGer are less massive vehicles. In space combat, the issue will be more the incredible lead times than power dropoff. There's no atmosphere to scatter beams or slow down projectiles, so a long-range shot should still be as powerful as a close-range one(except for imperfect beam focus, which appears to be minimal for overtech weapons). But since you have such incredible visibility and range, you can start shooting at each other while still light-seconds, or even light-minutes, apart. For a projectile weapon, this means you WILL miss, because the enemy can see it coming ages before it gets there and change directions. This is likely why the zentradi use energy weapons and missiles exclusively. One arrives much closer to when the initial firing is visible(at the same time if they're using lasers), the other can adjust for evasive maneuvers. Saving ammo is likely a foreign concept to the zentradi, as they use energy weapons, and overtech thermonuclear generators fit massive fuel stores into very small spaces. It's like not using your car's turn signals to save gas. Sure it affects things, but not enough to worry about. The humans are the ones that have to worry about saving ammo, because they use predominantly projectile weapons and the VF's gunpods and missile racks have very small ammo capacities, with the exception of hardpoint micromissile pods and the FAST pack "backpack". The GBP-1 can be ignored as it isn't really intended for space combat, and is a very poor design for such. That's Milia-style combat. She wasn't engaging in safe and rational combat , she was treating it as a game. Most zentradi just shoot stuff. A melee attack is likely a joke compared to the other weaponry available. It's very massive, sure, but it's also very slow, and inflicts damage on BOTH vehicles. Only half of the energy in a puch goes into the point of impact on the target. The other goes right back into the fist and down the arm. QRau arms are also rather poorly designed for melee combat. There's signifigant risk of damage to the laser guns from either a missed punch or debris released during the attack. Any pilot engaging in such activities would have to take special care to ensure the lasers were kept out of harm's way. The ONLY destroid intended to deal with aerial combat is the Defender. And it was designed to do it at long range. If there's QRaus in the area, there's Valkyries scrambled to deal with them. Because that's what they were designed for. You would NEVER see a one-on-one Spartan VS QRau in an actual combat zone. The Spartans and Tomahawks would be blasting at grounded mecha while the VFs handled airborne ones. And generally in groups, because these are combat mecha, not Texas Rangers. The entire anti-destroid argument assumes that armor and firepower are worthless, and that the intended role of all vehicles is that of fighter plane. There's a reason that most real-world nations still own and operate tanks. The fighter plane is NOT the perfect tool for every job. I'd probably have to, given that the Monster would have a signifigant defensive force between me and it on both land and air. Remember, the Monster isn't a macho guy that runs into fights unprotected. There will be Spartans, Tomahawks, and Defenders* on the ground around it, and Valkyries in the skies above it. So if I come at this Monster from the ground, I've got to wade through Tomahawks and Spartans shooting at me while other Spartans are trying to beat me to death. If I come at it from the air, I've got Defenders and Valks trying to shoot me down. And the Monster is STILL lobbing artillery shells at my base while this is going on. * I was mistaken in calling the Defender a jury-rigged hack. It was developed on Earth. Only the Phalanx was developed on the Macross. End part 2 of 2

QRaus have laser guns in the forearms. Anyone you're in a position to punch can be perforated just as easily. Though there IS a certain stylistic flair in lunging at someone with a fist, only to stop at the last second and unload a burst of high-energy photons into their face at point-blank range. NosGers have handguns, presumably with their own self-contained ammo stores. LAME. They also have a plasma cannon in their chest, though. The QRau has "impact cannons" in the chest, and the NosGer's shoulder cannon is also an impact cannon. While what an impact cannon actually IS isn't stated, I can't see a way for these to be projectile weapons as there's very limited space for ammunition and a feed mechanism, especially given the NosGer's cannon is mounted on a swivel. Ammo shouldn't be a concern, as both mechs are loaded with integral energy weapons. Well a spartan is still slower than a valk from getting from place to place. So relative to a lighter mech I put it in crapper tier. Maybe amoungst it's own class (mecha which are mainly for the ground) it is speedy. That doesn't negate the fact it has limits which aren't worth highlighting. What about the Valkyrie's limits? It's very lightly armed and armored. The GBP makes a Valk into a passable Spartan substitute, but not a great one. There's still a signifigant armor disparity, and the VF-1's hands and feet still aren't built for melee. And all that extra mass is going to greatly reduce it's speed advantage. And while the GBP-1 has far more missiles/grenades than the Spartan, it lacks the other integrated weapons, most notably anti-infantry gear. The Spartan is built for an entirely diffrent mission than the Valk, and is infinitely better-suited to said mission. Sure it makes a crappy Valkyrie, but the Valkyrie makes a crappy Spartan too. And the cost of a variable spartan would be... armor. The variable Monster isn't a big issue. A Monster isn't supposed to BE in direct conflict, and if the enemy is landing hits on it, you've probably already lost. The relatively rapid deployment(it's still subsonic) of the variable design greatly outweigh the durability of a fixed-mode vehicle for the Monster. But for a Spartan, which is designed EXPLICITLY to wade right into the thick of things and take hits, a loss of armor is a very serious shortcoming. Because a clock-radio, while capable of functioning as a radio, doesn't do a very good job of it. That's why they never REPLACED dedicated audio systems. The clock radio is a Valkyrie, the stereo system is a Spartan. Better is a relative term. If you deploy a Valkyrie into a situation where it WILL take damage, it WILL be destroyed. If you deploy a Spartan or Tomahawk into a situation where it WILL take damage, it has the armor to shrug it off and come back home later. There's less chinks in the armor because there's no variable-mode joints, many of the joints that ARE there have thick armor skirts or sleeves, and the solid parts are ALSO far more heavily armored. Actually, that's exactly where you WANT a frontline combat destroid. If you've been rushed, then there's too many guns for a Valk to be safe, and way too many targets for it's gunpod to deal with. Remember, the Valkyrie is very lightly armored and very lightly armed. Again, it's a tradeoff. Durability is NOT something you can just ignore because "my army can run away if people start shooting." End part 1 of 2.

Been done over in the "other anime and scifi" section. And yes, the PS3 is just too expensive. I don't care what's in it, it's a game machine. I won't drop a half-grand on a game machine. For the console market to follow the folly of the PC gaming market is a very bad thing.

I'm kinda confused about how no one worked it out when Global started flying around the world going "Hey, we've got a hold full of dead people that are actually alive that we'd kinda like to unload plzkthx" on a general broadcast.

Wow I'm a dumbass/Jack-ass. Thanks JB0! I cleared the cache and it worked perfectly. It was probably always uploading right, and your browser just wasn't properly updating things on your end. They get stupid with the cache sometimes. Now THAT'S a good filter.

Just got around to watching the latest episode... Listen to my song, indeed. Showcases the less self-centered aspect of Haruhi, too. Always good to see her doing something OTHER than making someone's life miserable in the quest for entertainment. Too bad Yuki wasn't on drums. She'd make an excellent Veffidas.

My best guess would be browser cache. I'd clear that before uploading, and if it didn't work, clear it immediatly afterwards.

It happens to other people too. It seems he's got a loose mouth and quite often says something out loud that he's INTENDING to just think. Remember, the story's 1st-person. Any verbal slippage wouldn't be in quotes because Kyon doesn't realize he said it(not until someone replies, anyways).

Actually, the table of contents merely tells you the size of the disk contents. It's not synonomous with content size. You could conceivably create a copy-protection scheme revolving around a corrupt TOC(I believe it's a known scheme on CDDA), so it's a relevant distinction. ... That and I'd like to try and prevent the console warez kiddies from corrupting yet another term like they have with ISO and ROM(Oh man, have they corrupted ROM). Has anyone ever gone back and designed a nice-looking fliptop shell? The lack of aesthetic effort on the replacement shells has always disappointed me. I'd be more inclined to grab a busted PS2 off eBay or something, then go wild with a Dremel.

I assume just pessimism. Space War 2 COULD be the Protodeviln war, though...

I kinda like Haruhi. Bear in mind she was always the social outcast and has always seemed to be until recently all that "genki power" was unleashed when she met Kyon. Her "omnipotent powers" don't help in the brattyness since she keeps getting what she wants. It would be an interesting breakdown of the Haruhi character as the romance develops between Kyon and her. It'd be a REALLY screwed-up relationship. ... Actually, there's interesting personality parallels, which is probably why Haruhi gets along with Kyon in the first place(relative to her other classmates, she DOES get along quite well with Kyon). They're just 2 diffrent responses to the exact same situation. Both think the world would be a better place if more weird stuff happened. Kyon determined it just couldn't happen, gave up on his dreams, and became a well-adjusted, if insufferably dull, member of society. (Was I the ONLY person that wanted to hurt someone over the speech about how only incredibly rare geniuses could change the world and everyone else should just sit back and enjoy the ride because they were too stupid to change anything?) Haruhi determined it just couldn't happen, said screw it, and started trying to make it happen anyways. Not that its important. Maybe Kyon was never a real person (hence no real name) in the end, but a "Opened Space" entity Haruhi created to soothe her loneliness and someone to actually get her to make the SOS Brigade. Haha....i'm sorry but i tend to think every anime now focuses on existentialism. 409655[/snapback] If Kyon was never real and that's why he doesn't have a name, then why do Koizumi, Mikuru, and Yuki have names? Koizumi and Yuki both believe that all 4 of them are in the SOS Brigade specifically because Haruhi willed it to be so. Koizumi is certain his very existence, as well as that of Yuki and Mikuru, and quite possibly everyone in the entire world, is because Haruhi willed it. And Mikuru is hopelessly inept anyways so who cares what she thinks. Why would the one "normal" person on Earth that's worth spending time with and the only person, normal or otherwise, that deserves a place in the new world NOT rank a name? Arguably, Kyon should be the FIRST to get one, as he's the most important person to Haruhi(whether she admits it or not).

People scared to lose memories and intellect by going micro? The giant ape like commander might prefer using a heavy powered armor custom built for himself the same way you have elite ace pilots like char in gundam. Maybe something about the way the powered armor matches your exact body movements and allows you to do more fancy moves at close range, would seem preferable to aliens over robot controls? Think of the difference in agility between the Knight Sabers' powered suits in bubble gum crisis vs the more mechanical mecha the police use? (how they can dance circles around them and do somersaults, cartwheels and spins and poo?) Or a QRau VS a Regult? But the zentradi don't use power suits that way. The NosGer has the big guns. The QRau has enough missiles to equip a moderately-sized air force. It seems they give power suits to the people good enough that they never wind up in melee situations. And the Spartan was the only one designed for a role where speed and melee were needed. That's like griping because a hammer does a lousy job at cutting paper. Great plane, mediocre robot. The battroid reminds me of the saying Jack of all trades, master of none. Sure it can do a little of anything, but it's not great at anything either. Actually, the QRau doesn't match our notion of powered armor. The arms and legs don't fit into the mech's arms and legs. I think the line art shows a conventional control panel(I know Yamato's toy does). Though it doesn't rule out leg-based controls, it DOES rule out just walking to walk. Besides, motion tracking works really well for human actions, and a lot less well for non-human actions like flying through space or shooting missiles out of your shoulders. The big advantage is the form-fitting cockpit reduces the mech volume and surface area. Reducing surface area in turn reduces armor needed. So a Regult masses 37000 kg for the "base model." A NosGer masses 34700 kg. A QRau masses 33600 kg. Less mass = less momenteum = greater maneuverability. Of course, the NosGer has almost twice the power of a Regult, and a QRau has over 3x the power. That certainly doesn't hurt. It's more an issue of complexity. There's just too much information coming in and too many options going back out for a physical interface to remain intuitive. Real world example: Uppercut in Street Fighter 2: Rapidly tap the joystick right, return to center, pull it down, then push it to the lower-right corner while simultaneously pressing one of 3 punch buttons to select the strength of the punch. Uppercut in Real Life 1: Punch something. Punch harder to punch harder. You don't need to consider all the actions involved in actually making the punch. Besides, limited real-world studies have indicated that the brain develops brain regions dedicated to new hardware when hardware is made available. Assuming it scales... when a pilot finishes learning the YF-21 they aren't a big transforming robot pilot anymore, they're a big transforming robot that happens to have a soft squishy core("Mister Owl, how many hits does it take to get to the tootsie roll center of a YF-21?"). Bodolzaa was. As of yet, we don't know which version of Bodolzaa is the "real" one. Bingo. Conventional computers can only do what the programmer and user tell them to do. The DBZ computer hasn't been told to watch actual combat and adjust power levels based on observations. By the same token, the ship's computer on Britai's pickle wouldn't have seen footage of the "miclones" in Macross City after the first attack and reminded Britai that zentradi legend said that Bad Things happened if you messed with miclones. Exedol, as a sentient being, DID make the connection and brought it up. Human(and presumably zentradi) memory is massively crosslinked. "Submarine" might be connected to "really cool boat," "nuclear war," and "annoying song that loops in my head forever we all live in a yellow submarine oh god make it stop," as well as a massive number of other connections. It's a horrible database design, because a computer can't tell which links are contextually appropriate. It works for us because we can evaluate everything at once and determine what links are most likely to be useful. And if we occasionally get annoying bits of songs stuck in our head, well... it's the price we pay for sentience. While Sharon Apple and the X-9 could likely evaluate things in a similar manner to humans and zentradi, Macross AI has proven to be a dead-end technology. It's got nagging issues with mental stability that make it unfit to be implemented outside a research lab.

I like ASPECTS of Haruhi, but not the character as a whole. I think Kyon's just given up. He can't get away from her and he can't make her listen to anyone. So he just tries to keep her from inflicting too much suffering on everyone else. Not that I know of. From what I've heard, it's not established yet.