Jump to content

JB0

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    13153

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by JB0

  1. JB0
    A recreation area, a la the Enterprise-D's Ten-forward? Actually, the 1701-D has a LOT of "transparent aluminum" windows. (granted, ten-forward wasn't a glass dome, which would've simultaneously been gorgeous and destroyed the show budget)
  2. JB0
    Stay classy, HG.
  3. JB0
    I'm hoping they realize how dumb they're being too. I'd hate to see yet another decent show axed because it was used as a tool to try and force an impossible outcome.
  4. JB0
    BALL OR GTFO!11
  5. JB0
    Freyja is being an inane fool, as that is her default personality. And being shouted down. Gotta stick the ears somewhere. Wouldn't be the first catsoldiers with eared helms in sci-fi.
  6. JB0
    NO WAY! Good thing Delta isn't doing that, then? But having catpeople that, while not being obsessed with apples, routinely eat them(and other produce, before the invasion))... doesn't make cat people fresh and exciting, no. But it is definitely not a cat-related visual gag.
  7. JB0
    Trufax: I still instinctively consider the character "Peg". But I just couldn't see Peg becoming a Prime. He WOULD, however, write his self-insert fanfic character, Drift, as becoming a Prime. IDW: This one is free. Make Drift a Prime. It is the story arc we want.
  8. JB0
    Since when does Drift turn into a spacetruck? Did he get ahold of the Matrix when we weren't looking?
  9. JB0
    What they've been saying is episode 1 will air on real television, and everything after that will be CBS All-Access Exclusive, thus dooming it to failure.
  10. JB0
    Loud Pedal? Really? Everyone knows the black Corvette is Ravage!
  11. JB0
    Freyja largely laid off the cat noises. The apple salesman MIGHT have made a nyaa, I had trouble telling and couldn't really say if it was just his accent or not. Yes. Yes, I did. Cats and apples is a WILDLY popular cliche. No, of course I didn't. Cats are carnivores. They eat meat. And milk and cheese. I have NEVER seen someone try to sell catpeople as apple-scarfing herbivores before.
  12. JB0
    Man, you can see his fold waves with the naked eye. DEFINITELY an anima spiritia.
  13. JB0
    ALL the puns are translation artifacts. The japanese would just be ending sentences with cat noises, which is completely awkward and unnatural in english. It really isn't hard to listen to the audio and see how many statements end with a dumb cat yowl. This is not a case where you are dependent on GG's presentation because you don't know japanese. That said: Catpeople eating apples is about as unstereotypical as it gets. And keeps knocking against my suspension of disbelief.
  14. JB0
    Yeah, but the point is I like the Excelsior and wanna see more of it. I will settle for a lower-detail version.
  15. JB0
    Well, of course it does. This is the third movie, EVERYONE knows you blow the ship up in the third movie. After how incredibly badly they did with their take on Wrath of Kahn, I have close to zero expectations for this. The new trailer is doing nothing to inspire confidence.
  16. JB0
    I think they were actually remarkably light on the catty nonsense. In spite of Freyja. Honestly, I liked how quickly they shot her down when she started in with the stereotypical cat accent. Even if it DID deprive us of hearing Messer trying to sound serious and sullen with a "nyaa" appended to the end of everything he said.
  17. JB0
    Just give us a CG Excelsior warping past those planets and nebulas.
  18. JB0
    Saruta got it, pretty much. I enjoy DYRL for what it is, but the significant differences from the source mark the beginning of a fairly strong divorce from the "realistic" drama of the original TV show, most notably in how the power of song is elevated well beyond the bounds of conventional logic. And in fairness, a large part of that is because you can't fit thirty-six episodes of narrative into a single movie. Things had to be reworked significantly to make a movie, and with no reason to assume it would be the foundation of a multimedia franchise, why not run wild? Also in fairness, I note that Macross' universe is more heavily tethered to the now-dated "missing link" problem than ever before, but it does not impair the franchise in the least. (Nor does it impair many of the other fictions that chose to fill then-large gaps in the evolutionary chain with external forces) So it isn't really a problem with realism, just that it chose a direction I liked less than other possibilities.
  19. JB0
    I am in the "add a subtitle" camp. I hate it when a new production just uses the name of the original wholesale. And this would be the FOURTH production to be titled simply "Star Trek". No one is ever going to confuse this with Kirk's Enterprise or Kirk's Enterprise in a cartoon or Kirk's Enterprise with lens flare, but it just makes for awkward conversation... or would if Trekkies ever referred to the first show as Star Trek instead of "TOS".
  20. JB0
    Man, Reina WAS my early choice for favorite. But now? Mirage has had a chance to establish herself as a genuinely interesting character, Mikumo has the "mysterious badass" angle going, Freyja... has the cockpit dance?... Meanwhile, this is the first time Reina's, you know, DONE something in almost two months.
  21. JB0
    That's my assumption too. It's just a representative voice from some point in the past, not a specific person. It is possible it isn't even a real person, just Mirage's personification of a sentiment she is sure exists(because with family like that, it would be stranger if she WASN'T being compared to them).
  22. JB0
    Yes. She is.
  23. JB0
    Having had this discussion with someone else earlier, and... unpopular opinion, but the Macross I love died with DYRL. The instant music stopped being simply the most visible aspect of "culture" and became a special thing unto itself, the Macross I loved was dead. Explicitly magical or not, that was how DYRL handled Minmay. Her singing had an immediate and powerful effect on all the zentradi, with some ridiculous one-liner about genetic memories of pop music thrown in for good measure. I have enjoyed most of the productions that bear the Macross name, but... none of them are heirs to the show I love.
  24. JB0
    Reactions as I made it through the trailer: Narration starts: "Wait, seriously? All you had to do was say "Space, the final frontier", and everyone would be on board. " "Wait, is that the original theme? I really hope that sticks for the entire show." Long story short, I was worried they had no idea who they were selling to, but... they do. We'll put up with a lot, just let us believe greatness is possible.
  25. JB0
    Bomba!
×
×
  • Create New...