Prime

I thought it was all official... But I'm not sure what you are getting at anyways...

And when it fails they'll declare that 3D animation is dead.

I'd say DYRL followed closely my Macross Zero helmets. I don't like the see through "visor" ones from Plus for some reason...

Indeed. I think overall it was a great series in the end.

Excuse my ignorance, but what is OST 2?

That is just awesome!

I haven't heard of anything so far...

I loved planes. I loved robots. Therefore I loved Macross (Robotech at that time). I stayed because of all the other goodness that comes along with it.

If they did do it I'd like to see less of the 3D Macross Zero style and more of a 2D style with computer enhancements. Sort of like Ghost in the Shell: Standalone Complex.

Untrue. The UN failed to enforce its own decree. I'm not trying to make a political statement here. For whatever reason, the US acted without the UN. Making them, in jest, the potential Anti-UN.

I was really surprised what a difference it made watching all the episodes at one time. It made it a much stronger story in my mind, and the "magic" elements seemed to fit better, to me at least. I'd say I like M0 just as much as DYRL now. I only came across DYRL in the last few years, so it doesn't have nearly the same nostalgic feeling as I'm sure it does to many. In any event, I'd say watching M0 all together would be well worth the time. It certainly changed my initial perceptions...

Well, the US did act unilaterally against the UNs wishes. That sounds pretty Anti-UN to me.

After watching the entire series again, I think in the end I am quite impressed with it. Certainly the animation (CGI at parts at least) is fastastic. I am a big Plus fan and not a M7 fan at all, but I think Zero does a good job providing a balance. The first time I watched the series I found the "magic" stuff a little over the top. But watching it again just about everything seems to be explained or at least hinted at in terms original Macross concepts. Even though the AFOS was "out there," it was nice to see so many connections to the original Macross (main gun, barrier, etc.) To me, then really helped ground the series in the Macross universe. Not to argue about the quality of M7, but I think Kawamori did a much better job incorporating the spiritual/magical aspects of the story this time. I'm not sure I buy the literal fish to human theory. I get the impression that the Mayan legends were metaphor and primitive descriptions of how the Protoculture altered life on Earth.

There are a lot of cosmetic differences though...

I'd say 3 for me, followed by 2. What can I say, great mecha battles in those ones.

Just to throw my opinion onto the pile... I haven't actually watched ep 5 yet. I decided to watch the whole series from the beginning so that everything is fresh in my mind for number 5. I've only gotten through the first two episodes this time around, but I have enjoyed them a lot more than the first time. I had initially felt that it dragged quite a bit, but now it seems to flow much better. For me at least, I feel it fits in very well with the other Macross series. I like Macross much more for the mechanical designs, characters, and war themes than the "spiritual/magical" stuff. As a result I much prefer the original seris, DYRL, and Plus over M7. But Zero provides a nice balance between the two extremes and ties everything together well. I'll see how I feel after I finish the other episodes. One thing that struck me is how much knowledge the UN had about the Protoculture before the Zentradi ever arrived. As a result, I can see why the Council was reluctant to acknowledge Global's and Misa's findings regarding the connection between the Zentradi and Humans. Presumably they feared that eventually the truth would come out about just how much they knew. Does that make sense? Perhaps it is common knowledge, but I haven't seen the original series in its entirety (apart from Robotech). Or am I way off base?

I was able to download it pretty quickly. Good timing or something?

Macross Plus for me. Like others, it was my first exposure to the true Macross universe. I've never looked back But I am going to go through Zero again in one sitting so see where it ranks...

Me too. I'm sure I posted once or twice, but I think I came pretty late in the game...

I just found M7 to be a little too "out there" for me. I hated the songs, and I just couldn't get into the characters and mecha, mainly because the other series do such a good job of making everything seem plausible. That being said, I don't mind Kawamori trying different things. I might not like everything, but it prevents the genre from becoming stagnant.

Opinions on the new movies aside, I think that it is safe to say that the movies and the merchandise spawned from them have been a commercial success. He has screwed it up in the eyes of a certain segment of the fanbase, but there is also a significant portion that like the new stuff. From what I have seen, people seem to think Jedi are a lot cooler now than when it was only Luke, Obi-Wan, and Yoda...Many seem not to like it because it is so different from the feel of the originals. I suspect the same would happen with Macross if they deviated too much from the originals. Hell, Macross 7 is pretty different, and look a the mixed feelings that gets.

But is there a huge demand in the US (and here in Canada )? Sure there are some diehard fans, but is there really enough in the general population to warrant such a thing?

Might someone post a transcript here afterwards?

What a refreshingly new idea!

I thought it was pretty weak. But I think my big mistake was listening to the dubbed version first...