My, my; how bitter. As a new fan I enjoy most of his music. Pretty Hate Machine is my favorite, though. I just purchased The Downward Spiral and SURPRISINGLY I don't really like it... Perhaps it'll grow on me.
I really like The Fragile, but I haven't heard much of With Teeth. Any good?
Maybe I'm just weird - but I think The Fragile has some great songs:
The Great Below
The Wretched
The Day The World Went Away
Just Like You Imagined (in fact I have the 300 trailers to thank for getting me interested in NIN)
Starfarters, Inc.
Okay, so it's a double album and I only like five songs so far. But I *really* like them.
EDIT: And so I don't derail the thread and get it locked - has anyone heard any news regarding Year Zero's follow up album?