At worst the scores are equivalent.
The plot is 85% the same.
Macross is a very DISJOINTED series. It has no true "flow" for lack of a better word.
Robotech is a true *EPIC* spanning GENERATIONS. The pieces (by PURE CHANCE I admit) flow together in a way that makes the sum far greater than its parts.
The dialogue is almost the same. The only thing about RT dialogue I hate are the needles "Wah?" "Huh?" "Oh." That stuff is stupid. But if you ignore that the story is incredibly mature.
The music is awesome. I have no complaints other than Minmei. I would certainly trade the American in for the Japanese equivalent, but other than one or two songs, the RT BGM is superior.
The narrator is my favorite part of RT. He does a great job of tying things together.
Macross is like flying in general--hours of bordeom interrupted by moments of sheer terror. It is very unbalanced IMHO. A decent show, but my vote if I compared all of Macross to all of RT would be for RT.
True meaning? What true meaning? **********YAWN*************
Long live the ROBOTECH.
Admit it, you love it.
I take pride in the fact I am mature enough to enjoy both. You should consider it.
( Besides, I thought you had me on ignore.)