Jump to content

Seto Kaiba

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    12876

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Seto Kaiba

  1. Seto Kaiba
    That's really just under the standard approach for rogue Zentradi... "avoid where possible, destroy where not". Hardly noteworthy. Those occasional Zentradi who try and fail to acclimate to polite society tend to be a bit more interesting... but they're also a lot more rare. Black Rainbow contained a number of former New UN Forces soldiers - like its leader Timothy Daldhanton - and was really not a threat to anyone except Latence. Odds are they've been stomped on by some VF-X unit in the background somewhere.
  2. Seto Kaiba
    Probably, though they also supposedly have much closer ties with Earth in general due to the shorter distance and more established nature of those settlements. (Master File offers an alternate explanation for the inconsistent depiction of the NUNS emblem as Earth and its closest partners keeping the old UN Forces roundel while more recent governments more readily adopted the newer postwar emblem until the Second Unification War saw the old one abolished entirely in the name of unity.) The goal of them was to explore the volume of space within 100ly of Sol, so they'd stay in that volume due to not being outfitted for a more extended trip.
  3. Seto Kaiba
    There are some weird moments for quality in this one thanks, I think, to that split-focus diopter setup they used so liberally. In the meeting in the observation lounge near the end McCoy looks like a thumb in a suit because his face temporarily goes all blurry.
  4. Seto Kaiba
    One thing to remember there is that that old content is... well... playing fast and loose with the setting, story, etc. due to Harmony Gold not exercising any creative control over its licensees. That's why HG disowned that old material and excluded it from consideration in the official setting. "Tiny" and "small" are relative terms. This is an issue that the Robotech fanbase has debated heavily over the years... with a lot of inflation of numbers going on. Neither the Southern Cross Army in Southern Cross nor the Mars Colony forces in MOSPEADA were particularly large forces. To give you some examples: In Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross, the military has only one branch of service in the official org chart published... it's an Army with its own Flying Corps. There is no separate air force or space force and many of the groups that are often mistaken by Robotech fans as branches or divisons are actually individual specialist units inside the regular infantry (Tactics Corps). The Alpha Tactics Armored Corps, for instance, is a specialism in the Tactics Corps and consists of just fifteen tank squads in total. That's only about 300 people if you assume the 15th was at full strength. The Southern Cross Army was so small it had only a handful of flag officers and most of the actual work running it was being done by Colonels and below. In Genesis Climber MOSPEADA, the 2nd Earth Recapture unit at the start of the series was by all accounts a very large force of... 10 Ikazuchi-type carriers, 40 Garfish-type transports, 160 troop landers, and 200 independently operating fighters. Excluding the crews of those ships and shuttles, the actual force being landed was about 6,000 combat personnel in total. For Mars Colony, that was an ENORMOUS force that contributed hugely to resolving their post-invasion overpopulation problem. The above has some amusing implications for Robotech. Taken in stride with RTSC, that force accounts for approximately 12% of the UEEF's available forces in the 2040s, meaning that whole force is somewhere around 50,000 men + ship crews. If you apply the same math to the fleet in RTSC's opening scenes, you're looking at around 7,200 fighters if every ship participating in the fight is loaded for bear. The whole UEEF fleet seen in RTSC, supposedly almost the entirety of the UEEF, was only 395 ships, 364 of which being small escorts. Remember, the UEEF wasn't planning to fight fair and square... their original mission was a sneak attack. 😉
  5. Seto Kaiba
    Oh, we intend to. They've been Trekkies since TOS so they're extremely stoked for this. This'll be my first time seeing a TOS-era movie in theaters. When I was a kid, the first Trek movie I got to see at the box office was Generations, so I've never seen Kirk on the big screen unless you count... ahem... a bridge on the captain? Kinda jealous that Fathom Events seems to have WAY better representation where my folks live. Their nearest venue is barely a block away. I gotta drive about 30min to mine.
  6. Seto Kaiba
    Not "low tech" by any means. In both the original and Robotech versions of the story, those were advanced ersatz nukes - thermonuclear reaction weapons in Macross, "reflex" weapons in Robotech - based on alien technology. In Robotech, the Zentradi were floored that humanity had something like that and in the original Macross version they were straight-up lost technology from the age of the Zentradi's creators that humanity reinvented based on the principles they discovered reverse-engineering the ship. It's much more explicable when you remember that that "massive fleet of clam ships" has no interstellar capability in Robotech's official setting. They are strictly sublight craft and their range is basically limited to ferrying troops between orbit and a planet's surface. The Invid were dependent on the Regess's teleportation and the Regent's small number of fold-capable ships to travel interstellar distances, both of which required vast amounts of protoculture... a resource that was in short supply for the Invid after the Masters were done glassing Optera. They didn't have the ships or the resources to sustain an extended raiding campaign. They could barely manage a halfhearted occupation of a handful of largely defenseless planets before being ousted by a force a tiny fraction of the size of, and far less advanced than, anything the Zentradi or Masters would've mustered.
  7. Seto Kaiba
    Y'know this isn't a R-word site, right? We really don't wanna look at something even that franchise considers part of an embarrassing past best forgotten.
  8. Seto Kaiba
    It's a pretty straightforward issue, IMO. The Masters destroyed Optera's biosphere after pillaging it for the resources - the protoculture - they would use to develop the weapons and technologies (like the Zentradi) that they would use to establish their interstellar empire. The Invid, for their part, remained on the devastated Optera until the events of Robotech II: the Sentinels when the Regess became too wrapped up in hunting for the Flowers of Life and her evolution experiments to hold the Regent's leash and he took off to take revenge on the Masters by invading their homeworld shortly before the UEEF arrived there. The ones with guns didn't pop up until partway thru the 3rd Robotech War. So really, just the claws. Mind you, they're only shown to be effective against human ships... explicitly the weakest, least advanced ones in the setting. Even if they had the guns, those are exclusively visual-range weapons and the Zentradi are a foe that can (and do) flatten planets from orbit or as far away as a light second with impunity in the series. A war where one side has to get within a few feet of the enemy to hurt them while the other side can destroy them and the entire planet they're on from 280,000km+ away isn't going to last very long, y'know?
  9. Seto Kaiba
    Going to see this one tonight. Got tickets for my parents as well, so they can go see it too. Very excited.
  10. Seto Kaiba
    So, yeah... remember when I said this? *gestures broadly at "the Zentradi and the Invid never fought"* Let's just call that People's Exhibit A. As odd as it sounds, he actually did have a factually sound point... but because it was buried in the demented honking about other nonsense it ended up dismissed as another minor example of crazy. The only depictions of the Robotech Empire-era Zentradi fighting the Invid come from the disowned/non-canonical comics from before the 2001 reboot of Robotech. In official setting materials developed for Robotech: the Shadow Chronicles, it was established that the Haydonites destroyed the first Invid homeworld and the Robotech Masters destroyed the second one (Optera). There is no mention or depiction of those two factions ever fighting each other in official material. The Invid Regent appears to be aware of what the Zentradi are in the Prelude comic enough to taunt them about having been "slaves", but that seems to be as far as it goes. As I mentioned in another thread, the whole idea of the Zentradi fighting the Invid makes very little sense if you think about it rationally. Not just because the Zentradi near-exclusively favor ranged warfare in space while the Invid near-exclusively favor close quarters surface combat, but because the sheer difference in scale reduces it to absurdity. A statistically-average Zentradi is 10m (32'10"), while your typical Invid is 2.5m (8'2"). Even the bigger ones are only about twice that, at 4.8m (15'9"). Scaled down to human size, the Invid are only about the size of a small dog (scouts) or a statistically-average seven year old (troopers) vs. an army of 6'7" basketball players with giant robots, machine guns, and body armor. Such an authentic impression it's like he's in the room with us! That's a favorite one of his, though he tends to get rather upset if you point out that even in the original Super Dimension Cavalry Southern Cross the Logan was officially stated to be an incredibly ineffective fighter with a high loss rate and that the Auroran (RT: AGACs) was rushed out to replace it. He was consulted on a few minor details, but if you visit their forums you'll find him voicing a litany of grievances with what they actually put in the books after HG shot down a lot of his positions and theories.
  11. Seto Kaiba
    Kaifun's something of a special case... given that he's shown to be rather hypocritical or insincere about his supposed pacifist views. The actual pacifists of the Macross 29 fleet are shown in rather a more positive light, though there are still some realistic consequences involved in that the fleet's problems were also caused by their commitment to total pacifism making them extreme doormats. In all fairness to Colonel Burton... the only civilian giving him flak was Basara, who excels at making soldiers and civilians alike lose their tempers explosively. The military was under civilian authority in each series... though in Frontier they made an unusual choice of having a military officer in the president's cabinet as his chief of staff and the coup was instigated by corporate corruption rather than from within the military. Ironically, a military coverup done for perfectly sound reasons.
  12. Seto Kaiba
    If I had to guess, I'd say partly just catching up to the real world's gradual introduction of 5th Generation fighter aircraft into actual frontline service mixed with Japan's government deciding to take a shot at developing their own 5th Generation fighter to replace their build-under-license version of the F-16. The VF-31's development history ended up kind of a whole-plot-reference to Japan's struggles and objectives there, ... I fear you may have had some very inaccurate fan material or "R-word" material mixed in there. After the First Space War, the Earth Unification Government that had been destroyed was replaced by the New Unification Government that operated along essentially the same lines as a representative democracy. The military was very influential, sure, but it was by not a military dictatorship by any means. You could say the military's influence was built upon its heavy involvement in the emigrant fleets (and as a major employer therein) and the understandable emphasis on defense in the wake of such a cataclysmic war. After all, nobody on Earth (or elsewhere) wanted round 2 to go the same as round 1. The New UN Government ran into some difficulties with its system of government as space emigration continued and emigrant fleets and planets became increasingly far-flung. Its new member worlds wanted more autonomy for practical reasons, since referring matters to the central government took a lot of time thanks to the time delays in fold navigation or fold communication, making it difficult to react quickly. So there was a small, but growing, number of little brushfire conflicts between pro-autonomy movements and the reactionary Earth supremacists who believed that governing authority needed to be centralized on Earth in order to present a united front against threats. Eventually, that sentiment boiled over when the Earth supremacists started mobilizing the military more and more to crack down on pro-autonomy movements and became the Second Unification War in 2050-2051. In the aftermath, the New UN Government adjusted its model of government to allow emigrant governments more autonomy and had become something more akin to the EU.
  13. Seto Kaiba
    Almost certainly not. For a very long time - indeed, even well after Macross 7 - Kawamori claimed to have never seen Macross II. His philosophy for Macross has always broadly mirrored real world design trends. When Macross Plus and Macross 7 were on the drawing board, much fuss was being made on the subject of things like stealth fighter prototypes and stealth warships. Particularly on the competition for the USAF Advanced Tactical Fighter program between the YF-22 and the YF-23 that inspired the design of the YF-21/VF-22. He always sneaks parallels like that into his work on Macross, like the talk about the 5th Generation Valkyries being "last manned Valkyrie" similar to how the 5th Gen fighters were originally tipped to be "last manned fighter", or the VF-31 program mirroring Japan's ATD-X program. By all accounts, even stories set after Frontier have the New UN Government still quite happy with its policy of avoidance when it comes to the Zentradi... even among forces that are armed with 5th Generation VFs. You can only do so much against overwhelming numerical superiority. Macross Chronicle tends to take the lazy way out and just show size comparisons for the Fighter mode. We've seen surprisingly few emigrant fleets up close, and almost all odd-numbered ones.
  14. Seto Kaiba
    Just got my tickets... I'm kinda surprised to see so few seats being taken in the theater this time around. There was a pretty respectable turnout for [i]Macross Plus[/i]. (Though part of me suspects the usual summer road work may be partly to blame, with folks opting to see showings closer to home.)
  15. Seto Kaiba
    The Birdhuman that the ancient Protoculture left behind on Earth wasn't nearly that heavily armed. None of the Fold Evils we've seen were, really. The Earth UN Forces had a rather different tactical ethos from the New UN Forces established after the First Space War. Mainly, this was because they developed their planetary defense strategy around the badly mistaken assumption that an alien aggressor would pursue a classic alien invasion scenario and were also VERY mistaken about the scale of space warfare. Once they learned the hard way that something like a Zentradi main fleet simply can't be fought on human terms, avoidance and stealth became the order of the day. Even before the First Space War, they were mostly structured around the idea of a carrier-based space force rather than a battleship-based space force like the Zentradi are used to. It was only really in Macross II where the UN Forces bothered building battleships, though their strategic focus was also predominantly defensive and relied on a mix of high-performance fighters, the firepower of the massive Macross Cannon-class gunships, and the Minmay Attack. There were around a hundred Zentradi ships left after the First Space War. The New UN Forces seem to have appropriated or built quite a few more since then... e.g. the ships of the 33rd Marines. Those Zentradi ships were implied to be used for things like short-distance emigrant fleets that looked for inhabitable worlds within 100ly of Earth, like the one that found Eden in late 2013. At least 160 emigrant fleets... it's the best estimation we can manage with the available facts, there having been approximately 100 short-distance emigrant fleets and the highest sequentially numbered long-distance fleet being the 59th. As to how many planets... we don't know. Not every emigrant fleet launched has found a planet yet, and there are some hints that suggest some found more than one inhabitable planet. Some may have been destroyed or lost before finding a planet, like the Macross Galaxy in the Frontier movies or the Megaroad-01.
  16. Seto Kaiba
    Good thing Starfleet has the gold breakdown package... it wouldn't be the first time the Enterprise ended up needing a tow.
  17. Seto Kaiba
    There are rudimentary forms of inertial damping in the Macross setting in the form of inertia capacitor systems like the Queadluun-Rau's IVCS and the ISC used by 5th Gen VFs, but since Macross's warships are generally not inclined to the kind of violent high-sublight accelerations that would turn the crew into wall-gazpacho they haven't become indispensible yet. Most warships peak at less than 2G of acceleration, because sublight travel is bullsh*t and it's way faster, easier, and more resource-efficient to just fold long distances. Structurally, ships are mainly getting by on how absurdly tough hypercarbon and related composites are. The hypercarbon composites used around the First Space War were 100x as strong as an equivalent thickness of armor-grade steel according to some of the oldest technical materials. Once ships get to a certain size, sailing under sublight power seems to become a bit of a waste and they seem to just fold everywhere they need to go the way Mobile Fortresses often do.
  18. Seto Kaiba
    What I'll say for the SNW Enterprise... while I don't much care for it being made so much bigger than it ought to be, I do greatly enjoy the care that the set designers and prop masters have shown in trying to give the original TOS/TAS sets and mattes new life and an aesthetic facelift for the 21st century. There is a lot there that says "labor of love" in the prepwork. I especially love that the engine room replicated the look of the TOS/TAS Enterprise's warp core.
  19. Seto Kaiba
    As noted previously, Gene Roddenberry's favored/official explanation was that the Enterprise-A was a pre-existing Constitution-class ship that was simply renamed. That said, Gene did flip-flop a bit on when the Constitution-class was retired. Picard's USS Stargazer was supposed to be a Constitution-class ship originally, but due to production circumstances that detail got overlooked and they developed a new starship class (Constellation-class) for it. That would've pushed the end-of-life for the Constitution-class out a good sixty-plus years. (Some of the notes produced around the time TNG was on the drawing board suggested that Starfleet ships were intended for MUCH longer lifespans than the Constitution-class ended up having. We're talking a century-plus, not the ~50 years they ended up with for the Constitution-class. At the very least, we can blame the extended layovers in spacedock between five year missions and series for the Enterprise's changes in appearance. Or simply dragged out of mothballs and given the minimum amount of restoration to get her spaceworthy before foisting her on Kirk, secure in the knowledge that he'd be so busy trying to get her working again that he wouldn't be able to get up to trouble for at least a week.
  20. Seto Kaiba
    Now that's closer to a hot take. 😉 Hey, if you're trying to bully an inanimate object like sand into doing complex mathematics you need to threaten it a bit first. Y'know, let it know who's boss. ... that is a depressingly safe bet. 😕 For better or worse, that small group of extremely noisy Masters Saga fans are their own worst enemy... and the saga's too. On the rare occasion they make a sound point that could gain some traction with a bit of evidence, they immediately undermine it themselves by getting all confrontational when it gets questioned. Mostly they just beat dead horses like the "Sylphid Veritech" and rail against Harmony Gold's decision to base its official stats on the Japanese OSM where possible, which tends to leave their theories at odds with established canon, the animation, and common sense. Maybe so... though then it would've looked like something from a tokusatsu hero show with a massively chunky torso and silly little limbs. Given how most of the designs in Southern Cross are pretty heavily derivative of what other franchises (read "Gundam" and "Macross") were doing at the time, I'd assume that if they considered that option it was probably vetoed for being too obviously derivative of Macross's VF-1.
  21. Seto Kaiba
    One thing you have to remember about the Varauta Fleet Flagship Space Carrier is that it is stupidly huge. If not for the Macross Cannon-class gunships in Macross II it would be the single biggest human-built warship in all of Macross at a whopping 4.32km long. Mind you, since it's not a cylinder like Zentradi ships but is instead shaped like a giant horseshoe, it's actually about 3x the size of a Nupetiet Vergnitzs-class fleet command battleship like Vrlitwhai's. The only human ships bigger than it in the main Macross timeline are the unarmed environment ships used in emigrant fleets... the City-class, Mainland-class, and Island Cluster-class. It is a completely over-the-top exercise in excess on all accounts, functioning not just as a supercarrier rivaling a Battle-class for capacity but also as a mothership for the smaller warships of its fleet, and as a massive mobile anti-fleet missile battery and gun platform bristling with massive high-angle beam cannons and eight Macross Cannons. The thing about Macross Cannons is they're big, they draw a LOT of power, and they have some pretty hardcore cooling requirements between firings. We're not entirely sure how the eight macross cannon systems aboard the fleet flagship space carrier compare to a Battle-class's gunship for firepower but with eight of them it's likely they're intended to be used in volley fire, with one or more firing while the others are charging or being cooled after firing. Since the ship is so gobsmackingly massive, it seems a safe bet it's outfitted with a truly insane number of reactor system clusters to meet the energy demands of moving such a massive ship, maintaining artificial gravity, and powering its weaponry and energy conversion armor. Macross tends to buck the sci-fi trend of ships being powered by a single large, central, reactor system like the Death Star's main reactor or a Starfleet ship's warp core. Instead, they use clusters of smaller reactors working in unison to meet their energy demand. The bigger the ship, the more reactor clusters it'll have. On the Battle-class and some other modular warships, the power grid is effectively decentralized by having a reactor complex in each of the ship's independently operable modules. Other systems, like gravity control and fold systems, are similarly decentralized on many larger warships. It's doubtful the cannons have dedicated reactor systems, IMO, but given the sheer size of the fleet flagship space carrier, it probably has a rather extensive network of reactor system clusters working in tandem to meet the energy needs of its various systems. Very few New UN Forces warships are outfitted with Macross Cannons, because as mentioned earlier they are large, unwieldy, energy-intensive weapons... and terribly unsubtle to boot. Firing something like that gets everyone's attention right away, and since they lack the numbers to confront a Zentradi fleet head-on the New UN Forces generally prioritize a strategy of avoidance based on stealth and advance detection a weapon like that is only really useful for when things have gone truly pear-shaped. Reaction weapons are also far more discreet, efficient, and scalable, so the New UN Forces have shown a definite preference for those in its predominantly carrier-based space forces. For most needs, the electron particle beam cannon technology that is the mainstay of the Zentradi forces is used on human-built warships as well for much the same reason... being extremely precise and scalable and coming in a variety of different configurations to suit various needs.
  22. Seto Kaiba
    One reason you definitely want to refer mecha repair to a qualified technician... those electric motors have to be way higher voltage than anything used today to move such huge and heavy bits of metal around so quickly and with such massive torque. Arc fault events are already pretty damn deadly with things like high voltage electric car chargers and electric rail systems, but the electical systems to make a giant robot go make those look like the humblest watch battery. We're talking the potential for "death by vaporization" here as a workplace mishap rather than an outcome of sci-fi raygun murder.
  23. Seto Kaiba
    So were all the UN Forces mecha pilots in Macross... both Valkyrie pilots and Destroid pilots. Unlikely. Harmony Gold licensing Robotech to Funimation doesn't change anything about the existing legal situation and the relationships/obligations they have with respect to their licensing partner Tatsunoko Production or Macross owner Big West. It's literally just them letting Funimation take up the reins of managing the franchise's distribution and some of its merchandise licensing. If anything, it should actually make the approvals process worse... unless they're using Funimation's legal team instead of Harmony Gold's.
  24. Seto Kaiba
    Ok, I have some reading to do...
  25. Seto Kaiba
    Dial the snark back, mate... it's in under-bridge territory right now. It's not like the design staff at Tatsunoko's in-house design group Ammonite weren't trying to do a good job. Designing a mecha that transforms while still looking slick in each of its modes is ridiculously hard and requires a very specialized skill set and mindset they didn't have. It's noted in one of the few interviews they did on the series that work on designing the Spartas's transformation alone took Ammonite's three professional anime production designers a whopping THREE MONTHS to resolve despite being fairly basic. There's good reason Kawamori is one of the few designers out there who makes transformation design their specialty. It would, in all fairness, be accurate to say that the designs were not well-received either in Japan in its initial/only broadcast and abroad as part of Robotech. ... snark aside, kinda? More like driving a cheap convertible with no seatbelts. When the emigrants found Glorie, it was basically analogous to Hoth from Star Wars V: the Empire Strikes Back... albeit as the result of a nuclear winter. If you take Wookieepedia seriously, it's still mostly in Hoth territory in winter (daytime temps at the equator on Hoth supposedly reach a balmy -32C, eight degrees warmer than Glorie's winter average) and is basically in American Northern-Midwest winter mode in Spring and Autumn. In Earth terms, it's kind of like driving a convertible in the antarctic three seasons out of four. It's only in summer that Glorie really becomes a not-unpleasant place to live. That, in and of itself, is kind of rare in sci-fi. You normally see humans only attempt to settle on planets that are conveniently so Earthlike they resemble central California. 😜
×
×
  • Create New...