Seto Kaiba
-
Posts
13136 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Seto Kaiba
-
As I pointed out in the other thread, the black text in the timeline on sketchley's site is plot material from role-playing game sessions held on macrossroleplay.org. Only the green text is canon, while the steel blue text is "Expanded Universe" material apparently gleaned from Master File.
-
I would, but really... sketchley already did. As you can see, the green text is canon, the steel blue text is Master File stuff, and black text is plot material from role-playing game sessions. It's material from the games run on MacrossRoleplay.org's forums. EDIT: Clever, sketchley... was that Frank Zappa reference your doing? I LOVE Zappa.
-
Nah, from start to finish it only took Harmony Gold about two years to produce Robotech: the Shadow Chronicles... this "sidequel" thing they're working on is supposed to be even more of an amateur-hour mess than its predecessor, so it ought to be ready soonish. IIRC, didn't they say that the sidequel's animation would be completed this year, and that it'd be ready to roll next year? Since the closing of Wildstorm put the kibosh on their "let's endlessly re-release trade paperbacks of comics from ten years ago" routine, having nothing to show for 2011 would certainly explain why Tommy's suddenly so interested in having Palladium get its act in gear and finish the New Generation RPG sourcebook. Business as usual, then?
-
Yes, it does appear that he did... though it's worth nothing that he wasn't the only Macross mechanical designer to do so. There's a sketch of what appears to be a VF-4 w/ Super Packs in the line art that was released with the 1/72 Musasiya VF-4 resin kit, which is included in M3's coverage of the VF-4. Macross II's mechanical designers also created a set of Super Packs for their version of the VF-4, which appeared in the Macross II prequel game Macross: Eternal Love Song. The DYRLverse VF-4 Siren had a VF-1-esque transformation and a set of super packs that mounted on the wing between the nacelles and the airframe spine, which contained missile launchers and (depending on the mission) funnels. (Yes, funnels... like in Gundam) EDIT: Got ninja'd by sketchley, tho the art for the Kawamori VF-4 Super Packs on M3 is somewhat larger and cleaner. Other than that, just corrections/detail for the VF-4S Siren's gear from Macross: Eternal Love Song.
-
Oh, you mean the one that won't be ready for release until 2012? Yeah, that's a healthy reaction... there's a LOT that's cringe-worthy about Robotech and the people who make it.
-
At least, until you notice that every "informative" post of his is just rephrasing something someone else said... often with a few errors slipped in in the process.
-
The most likely (and painfully obvious) candidate to be hacking Ranka's website would be Grace O'Connor, since she was Sheryl's manager and had an ulterior motive to keep Sheryl active for the sake of her plot. We see several times that Grace has some fairly advanced computer skills courtesy of her cybernetics. Does it matter? The series never suggests that she lost due to foul play, and what motivation would Leon have had to keep Ranka from winning when her significance as "Q1" wasn't confirmed by Grace until later in the show. Leon would only have known Ranka as a survivor of the 117th Research Fleet. Maybe Leon just marks to high standards, since Ranka fell over at the end of her performance. Grace's main ally in the Frontier Government was the president's chief of staff and a highly placed officer in the NUNS... he would have been able to come up with a convincing cover story, especially since he'd already covered for her and for Galaxy when the VF-27 came to light and he wrote it off as a foo fighter. Considering that we see Brera hand it to her, and we also see him playing it at several points throughout the series while he was outside his VF-27... it's definitely real. It was presumably the medium Grace was using to manipulate Ranka, since the harmonica had the same design on it as Brera's hairpin, which was the mechanism that let Grace control him, and it broke when Ranka was able to snap out of her depression... presumably as the result of a catastrophic mechanical failure. When Brera's hairpin broke, it damn near took out his eye.
-
Yeah, and it gets even weirder and more contrived when you realize that Scott's attitude towards Ariel/Marlene goes from "I can't be with you because you're a green-blooded space lobster in a human suit." to "We're the perfect couple!" in the space of about a day and a half. It's almost like the poor guy has bipolar disorder. After basically a lifetime of hating the Invid, he reverses himself and starts knowingly protecting (and then romancing) his hated enemy without ever explaining his sudden and dramatic change of heart... Isn't that the justification for about 80-90% of what's in Shadow Chronicles anyway? As if the Shadow Chronicles movie didn't already completely torpedo the ending of "Symphony of Light" already... To be honest, having him be picked up by a carrier along the way is one of the few parts of the movie that actually makes sense... he's not gonna get very far in a relatively slow and clunky fighter with no faster-than-light capability, unless our boy Admiral Hunter was just having a siesta just outside of lunar orbit. ... and that is the second most horrifying mental image I've had today...
-
Your favorite in-game/movie/anime universe
Seto Kaiba replied to Ghost Train's topic in Anime or Science Fiction
Hm... for me, it would probably be Mamoru Nagano's Five Star Stories. The "universe" of FSS might be geographically on the small side, but the stories cover a MASSIVE span of time in the Joker Galaxy even without counting the way Lachesis plays merry hell with space-time for part of the story. Because of that, and its sizable cast, the story can cover entire lifetimes of characters and have a lot of variety in themes and tone. It keeps the setting from getting stale, and it makes the universe feel absolutely massive even though the story is focused almost entirely on five planetary systems in close proximity to each other. Aside from having some of the most grammatically-torturous names this side of J.R.R. Tolkien, the cast is really engaging and relateable... even though fairly half of the lot are the descendants of genetically engineered supersoldiers or bio-androids. It's kind of a dark story, on the whole, but the way the characters interact and the way they occasionally throw in some knockabout comedy really helps break it up... (and the scene where one of the less sane characters brutally beats the stupid out of one of the galaxy's most dangerous knights with a chef's knife and a fairly sizable fish will stay with me forever...) -
I'm pretty sure that's actually a positive trait... As a rule... if a particular aspect of the Robotech series is actually tolerable, then it's practically guaranteed to have been a holdover from the original three shows rather than the invention of Carl Macek and/or Tommy Yune.
-
Rollin' it back to your unanswered question... we have an answer now, courtesy of Talos. Yes, the MK-82 LDGB conventional bombs on the VF-1 are from This is Animation Special: Macross Plus p57.
-
Bubble-bursting time... that's not an error, at least not on the Compendium's part. The VF-1 Valkyrie is 14.23 meters long in fighter mode, with a wingspan (at full extension) measuring 14.78 meters across. sketchley's translation of This is Animation Special: Macross Plus (link) says: ... which is entirely correct and matches perfectly with what's said in the Macross Compendium's old and new VF-1 entries, and on the following Macross Chronicle mechanic sheets: SDF:M UN Spacy #02A (VF-1J Valkyrie) SDF:M UN Spacy #03A (VF-1S Valkyrie) SDF:M UN Spacy #04A (VF-1A Valkyrie) SDF:M UN Spacy #05A (VF-1D Valkyrie - a different length is cited, probably a typo, same wingspan though) DYRL UN Spacy #02A (VF-1S Valkyrie) DYRL UN Spacy #03A (VF-1A Valkyrie)
-
Okay, you've got me there... that is an error, albeit a relatively minor one. It's an understandable mistake to make, either as a simple transposition error or confusing Macross VF-X2's Eden 3 with Macross Plus's Eden. Since you brought it to my attention, I checked it against the Macross VF-X2 Official Visual Guide and made the appropriate correction. Still, that's an error in the Macross Compendium Wiki, which is maintained and updated by fans... not the original Compendium that was written by Egan Loo. The Mk-82 bombs are mentioned in the VF-1 article in the original Compendium as well, which means the info came from some kind of official printed source. Anyway, we'll do our best to find an answer for you.
-
Could you give an example of an error in the Macross Compendium? (When I see Talos later today, I'll ask him to look in TIA M+ for you regarding those Mk.82 bombs)
-
Eh... if you don't mind my asking, what prompted this sudden desire to find sources for all of the aspects of the VF-1 that aren't from the animation? Egan Loo didn't just make stuff up, everything that's in there comes from some kind of official source. Some aspects might have been amended since the time of writing, but that information came from somewhere. Getting back to the actual meat of the question, the bit about Mk.82 LDGB conventional bombs definitely came from some kind of an official source, since it's cited in the first volume of the Variable Fighter Master File: VF-1 Valkyrie as part of the loadings charts for the VF-1's weaponry. Its original source would appear to be, as you conjectured, one of the later Macross publications to cover the VF-1. I wouldn't have expected the Macross Chronicle to mention it, since its coverage tends to be broad rather than deep in the mechanic sheets.
-
Granted, there are those few horribly stilted and false-feeling "romance" moments in Shadow Chronicles... but unlike the romances from the "original" series, they have nothing to do with the plot. Maia's supposed attraction to Marcus screams "obligatory romantic interest for the main character", and Louie might as well be romantically linked with a ham radio set for all it matters to the story. It's like whoever wrote Robotech: the Shadow Chronicles had only the vaguest idea how men and women interact, and contrived to just toss a romance in to tick off another box on a "obligatory Robotech cliches" checklist.
-
Ah, thank you. (At some point I really should knuckle down and buy a copy of This is Animation: Macross Plus, for completeness's sake)
-
Yeah, that's the thing... if you take the statements made by Harmony Gold's representatives at face value, the whole reason Warner Bros acquired the live-action movie rights to Robotech was to capitalize on the success of Paramount's Transformers and the 80's revival trend. Putting it off for ~10 years would completely defeat the point of having acquired the rights to compete with the Michael Bay Transformers movies... Robotech will be even more of a nonentity then than it is now, and the bubble they were hoping to ride with it will have burst long ago. The longer they sit on it without doing anything, the greater the chances are they they never will do anything with the rights. Goodness... my heartfelt apologies. I'm sure having to watch that film was traumatic for you. (I was lucky enough to have avoided Starship Troopers 3: Marauder altogether, by the simple expedient of avoiding anyone who was likely to give me a copy as a well-intentioned gift) Assuming, of course, that the "capacity to love" part makes it through the adaptation process intact. Robotech fans seem to think Carl Macek's post-facto arse-covering is practically holy scripture, so they're likely to want to pursue his final position on the show, which was basically that "music and all that wasn't important to the story, Robotech is about humans shooting evil aliens".
-
Eh... the VF-1B wouldn't have been included in the pre-Wiki Macross Compendium's coverage of the VF-1 Valkyrie if there wasn't at least some mention of it in official sources. Like the VF-X-2, the VF-1B seems to be a part of the Valkyrie's development history that came along later on... it's not listed in the books that came out around the same time as the series (the 3 This is Animation: Super Dimension Fortress Macross volumes and Macross Perfect Memory), nor is it listed or mentioned in the DYRLverse development history from B-Club Magazine Vol.79. Since I don't own a copy of This is Animation Special: Macross Plus, I asked my friend Talos to dig his copy out and check, and he found mention of a "B-type" in the VF-1 Valkyrie section on page 56. Also worth noting, even though the book it comes from isn't a canon resource, the second volume of Variable Fighter Master File: VF-1 Valkyrie ("Wings of Space") also mentions the VF-1B in a roundabout fashion via a mockup of a flight manual cover for the Block 4 VF-1 on pages 51 and 52. There's virtually no info on the VF-1B aside from its basic description, so I wouldn't expect to find it mentioned in many sources.
-
Yeah, it is on the long side... roughly six months seems to be the average turnaround time for going from theatrical release to home video. I don't know if it was ever confirmed, but there was some speculation that the 11 month turnaround time for Macross Frontier: Itsuwari no Utahime was because of the "Hybrid Pack" that also included the Playstation 3 game Macross Trial Frontier. If that's the case, then Macross Frontier: Sayonara no Tsubasa might come out on BD/DVD sooner rather than later if it's not also packaged with a video game. There were some folks here who were able to catch the movie in theaters, the thread for which is kicking around somewhere in this part of the forums.
-
Well... for starters, the Tornado Pack is a lot more streamlined than the Super or Armored packs and a good part of it is usable wing surface. The more traditional Super pack is a huge rocket booster with a missile launcher on the end which attaches directly to the VF-25's wings. I'm not sure about its mass, since I haven't been able to turn up a source that actually lists the mass of the Tornado packs, but I would be hesitant to trust the numbers printed on the display stands for the 1/250 Macross Fighter Collection. They do occasionally contain errors... IIRC, the 1/250 VF-2SS Valkyrie II's display base listed the fighter as being larger and heavier than its official stats indicate. To a certain extent, I would guess that you're getting a less-than-accurate picture of the Tornado packs since the one in the Macross Fighter Collection #4 is kitted out for space use. The version equipped for atmosphere is a bit more streamlined since it lacks the large underwing missile pods and the pods on the front of the rotary engine mounts. This is what it looks like when equipped for atmospheric use. None that I'm aware of... but if they stick to the pattern, it'll come out about a year after the movie hit theaters. Since movie two made its debut in February, I would expect to see it in either December 2011 or January 2012.
-
Variable Fighter Master File VF-25 Messiah
Seto Kaiba replied to Shin Densetsu Kai 7.0's topic in Movies and TV Series
Dunno... but it's still listed as in stock and shipping within 24 hours at HMV. -
Sounds about right... Still... realistically speaking, the only way that the live-action Robotech movie is likely to see the light of day is if it comes out as one of those horrid direct-to-video, shoestring budget, amateur-hour embarrassments like Starship Troopers 2: Hero of the Federation. The management at Warner Bros clearly doesn't see Robotech as the guaranteed blockbuster Harmony Gold (or rather, the Tommy Yune stooge squad) occupies itself by telling the fans it is. If they did, they would've moved on it by now instead of dragging their heels for over four years. Robotech is not a deep or complex story... evil aliens attack Earth to get back their magic flower fuel, humanity fights back, both sides massacre each other, lather-rinse-repeat. This should be the kind of script that any halfway-competent writer would find deeply insulting, and any hack could fart out over a single pizza-and-beer-fueled weekend.
-
It would probably be more accurate to say that Robotech fans shouldn't expect ANYTHING, lest they end up headed for a big disappointment.
-
Well, there's an impending Newbie Question thread merge coming, so I'll be brief... there's not a lot of information about the VF-25's Tornado packs. You can find what little information exists in the Macross Compendium wiki's VF-25 Messiah article. There's likely a bit more information in Great Mechanics.DX 11, but I don't happen to have a copy of that one. Aesthetic, not so much... the Tornado packs are an all-regime set of FAST packs, designed for use in atmosphere and space, so those big wings are for functional purposes. The large pods on the wingtips are actually engines, on rotary mounts that allow the engines to turn for maneuvering and braking purposes. The "giant tail" you refer to (the large rod coming off the back of the plane) would be the beam turret's FED-115R power capacitor and refrigeration unit (its cooling system). The large pods mounted under the wings would be micro-missile pods added for space use. Not quite sure what you mean by "four long under-and-over-wing pods" though... EDIT: On consideration, I'm betting you mean the sections that fit over the VF-25's wing gloves, which are where the Tornado pack connects to the VF-25's wing, and also contains verniers and presumably fuel tanks for same.