Jump to content

Seto Kaiba

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    13814

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Seto Kaiba

  1. Seto Kaiba
    😆 So the important bit is barely long enough to boil an egg and the rest is filler? This feels a lot like that suggestion that Star Wars's creative team use the World Between Worlds from Rebels to retcon the sequel trilogy out entirely... which would then require them to explain WTH the World Between Worlds even was, and feel like the same kind of cheap knee-jerk as what it replaced.
  2. Seto Kaiba
    Another possible explanation for it is that they screwed up what was meant to be the same reference to its pilot that can be found in the game's loading screens. Several machines in the loading screens that are associated with specific characters have a / followed by the character's initials including: YF-29B Perceval /R.B. Custom VF-22 Sturmvogel II / M.J. Custom VF-22 Sturmvogel II / M.F.J. Custom VF-22 Sturmvogel II / G.K. Custom VF-27 Lucifer / M.R. Custom Queadluun-Rher (sic) / K.K. Custom YF-30 Chronos / R.S. Custom Though this convention is NOT applied to the pics for Aisha's VF-19E or Mina's VF-11C. If it had been, they would simply have put the wrong name after the slash since the VF-11C is Mina Forte's custom aircraft, not the VF-19E.
  3. Seto Kaiba
    Yeah, between Variable Fighter Master File: VF-19 Excalibur (2010), Macross the Ride (2010-2011), and Macross 30: Voices Across the Galaxy game (2013) and novel (2013) versions, the question of WTH the VF-19E even is has become thoroughly muddled. I've ranted about this one before on several occasions. 😆 Macross 30's is probably the most problematic, since it implies that the VF-19E is a 1st mass production type not the 2nd type like several previous works had said. Not that Macross Chronicle is helping by identifying Aisha's VF-19E as a mass production type and saying nothing whatsoever about customizations. Probably should be shrugged off, because it's a typo in the fan translation of the light novel. 😅 The original Japanese text of the light novel doesn't have the "A", it's just VF-19E/MF. I've got some stylistic quibbles with the translation, but I'm not about to complain about it too loudly since someone actually took the trouble. What is slightly frustrating is the /MF, which denotes a local specification but we don't know from where. It's possibly they meant "Macross Frontier", which would/should make it VF-19E/MF25.
  4. Seto Kaiba
    Nah, it's just a sign of Business as Usual at Disney LucasFilm. Bringing a character back from the dead unnecessarily for the sake of a hackneyed redemption arc and the promise of The Continuing Adventures is right up Dave Filoni's alley. So much so that it'd be like the third or fourth time he'd have pitched such a story in the last couple years. That was the entire premise of The Book of Boba Fett, bringing Boba's dusty arse back from being sarlacc chow to be a crime lord in name only who saves Mos Espa from the real crime lords. That was Asajj Ventress's story in Tales of the Underworld too, her coming back from the dead unable to go back to her old life and becoming an antihero. I kind of imagine the meeting worked out like that one Jimmy Neutron meme. "Dave, this is the third time you've pitched us a story about a lame and overhyped villain coming back from the dead to become a nominal good guy. Maybe get some new ideas? Ones that aren't demonstrably shite?"
  5. Seto Kaiba
    Sometimes, it's just that the producers oversold the movie's prospects in order to get funding and in so doing set the bar for "success" higher than was realistically achievable. Sometimes, it's because someone else overpromised and underdelivered or just plain overspent and gave the executives cold feet.
  6. Seto Kaiba
    A "canon" with one 'n' is something the author stands behind. A "cannon" with two is something it's unhealthy to stand in front of. Official media has not, as far as I can recall, identified where exactly the pinpoint barrier emitter is. Master File actually supports your hypothesis, though. The VF-19 Master File says that the VF-19's pinpoint barrier system has three discrete emitters: one in the antiprojectile shield and one in each shoulder. The VF-22 Master File similarly indicates that the PPB system is located in the forearms adjacent to the stabilizers that are used as reinforced shields. Presumably this arrangement carried over to later models. Yep, that's where they're hiding, even if they're almost never visible on the VF-25 in the animation.
  7. Seto Kaiba
    That'd make a pretty short film, wouldn't it? He dies, and his spirit inhabits a clone body and that's all she wrote. Pretty much the same as in those terrible old novels. He dies, his ghost goes to possess a new body that immediately starts falling apart because of his evil dark side magic, lather, rinse, and repeat. That would've made the tantrums feel a bit less undignified.
  8. Seto Kaiba
    Oh, undeniably. I'm sure there's some OTM shenanigans that make the wing surface a more effective radiator than it would otherwise be, but the main way to dispose of the coolant that has absorbed heat from internal components is much more straightforward. It's also propellant, so they can just get rid of it by shooting it out of the main engines or verniers as the Valkyrie maneuvers. (Thermoelectric converters are also used in the VF's power systems, so maybe that plays a role too.) Probably just a smaller shield like the VF-19F/S's vs. the larger one on the YF-19/VF-19A/C. By this generation, the shield itself almost seems redundant given that they're working with the second generation of pinpoint barrier technology.
  9. Seto Kaiba
    Nah, Kylo Ren/Ben Solo wasn't even a real Sith. He was basically Palpatine's unpaid intern. He ain't just gonna walk off death itself like everyone's favorite evil space wizard.
  10. Seto Kaiba
    Iger and Bergman 100% made the right call there. There's no way they were going to be able to sell the audience on more of Ben Solo, after that painfully cheap and forced redemption in the last movie of the sequel trilogy. He was such an ineffective and unintimidating villain that they literally had to bring someone else in to pinch hit for him in the final film of the trilogy. Lucasfilm might have thought that was a good idea, but their judgment under Dave Filoni is suspect at best. Let the past die, Adam. Kill it if you have to. It's the only way to become what you were meant to be... the guy they hire when they can't get Keanu Reeves.
  11. Seto Kaiba
    If nothing else, that could look pretty cool onscreen in a future series. It could maybe be helpful in concert with the same kind of ECM the Aerial Knights were using early in Macross Delta.
  12. Seto Kaiba
    I'd assume the "there's a rotator joint we forgot to mention on the wingtip" is something they came up with for the movies... hence the more traditional Super Pack design the VF-31 Siegfried/Kairos uses. I'm not sure you'd be able to get all the way to where the VF-1 or VF-17/VF-171 get with it because of the wing shape, but I'd also argue the "cape" is probably intentional/practical. After all, the YF-24 Evolution and its derivative run their reactors hotter than any previous generation's and even though they're more efficient they do still require a lot of propellant for space flight and coolant/radiator surface for cooling in space. It's been noted that the liquid/slush propellant pulls double duty as a system coolant and the wing surface itself is also pulling double duty as a large radiator for cooling purposes outside of direct combat. I dunno, ask Shinsei Industry... it took them 17 years. 😆
  13. Seto Kaiba
    Nah, the VF-27 had a different sort of cover. Namely, the Macross Galaxy fleet never made the legally-required disclosures of the VF-27's existence and specifications to the New UN Government. So when Brera's VF-27γ is first sighted during the mission to rescue elements of the Macross Galaxy fleet it gets reported as an unidentified aircraft. When that report is relayed to the New UN Forces by their own representative on the Macross Quarter it is quickly dismissed as a "foo fighter" without supporting evidence. Thereafter, there's the implication that Chief of Staff Mishima is working from within the Frontier NUNS to cover up Macross Galaxy's involvement until Brera openly declares his affiliation after the Gallia IV incident.
  14. Seto Kaiba
    While that probably wouldn't be very useful in combat given the main detection and ranging systems are non-visual (radar, lidar, infrared), that's not to say it wouldn't be very useful in a defensive context. Using the programmable coating to make the exterior of a parked aircraft match the color and texture of the ground underneath them would go quite a ways towards hiding aircraft from aerial or satellite photography. Like the camouflage netting used to conceal aircraft on the ground today, but built directly into the aircraft. We also see Delta Flight switch seamlessly from airshow colors to low-viz greys at one point in the series, which would also be very useful for avoiding detection and identification by strictly visual means (since they have active stealth to hide from radar).
  15. Seto Kaiba
    Pretty normal for a Macross inclusion then... the same approach Kawamori normally uses. Drawing on both versions freely and interchangeably with an explanation that's a polite-ish way of saying "I do what I want". 😆 Yep... thanks to that smart coating technology, there's strictly speaking nothing stopping anyone in-setting from doing something like the above... which is an official plamodel kit with official decals. (The Bandai 1/72 Roid Brehm use Sv-262Hs Draken III.) Then again, the Frontier New UN Spacy didn't seem to mind its pilots putting racy paintings on their strictly-military-issue aircraft even without the benefit of the programmable smart coating: How Maruyama sold his superiors on this paintjob for frontline combat use might just be the greatest story never told. That's his commanding officer's girlfriend! Well, that or how Canaria Bernstein persuaded the famously overprotective Ozma Lee to let her paint an explicit picture of his little sister Ranka on her VB-6 Konig Monster... 🙃 Passionate Walkure was at least partly a compilation movie, so I wouldn't call that "slapdash" so much as "par for the course". Normally when a protagonist switches machines in a Macross story they move to a completely different and visually distinct aircraft. I think Macross Delta might be the first time the protagonist switches back to the old machine with a different paintjob.
  16. Seto Kaiba
    Huh. I guess I've been under a rock because I didn't know Super Robot Wars Y was even out. 😆 Anyway, that noise you heard was my brain changing gears without a clutch because I honestly could not remember of the J改 was exclusive to the TV series or not. Turns out, yeah... it's not a thing in the movie timeline. The VF-31J改 only exists in the Macross Delta TV series version where Hayate's original VF-31J is destroyed on Ragna when the New UN Spacy attempts to sink the Sigur Berrentzs with a thermonuclear reaction bomb. Hayate uses Messer's VF-31F for a while after that and then switches to using the VF-31J改 for the series finale. 'course, I wouldn't be me if I stopped there would I? I decided to look into whether there are any actual differences between the VF-31J and VF-31J改... and the answer I found is "Not really". The identified differences all relate to software and calibrations, with the flight control program including some data from when Hayate was using Messer's VF-31F. The rest is just the settings of the programmable anti-beam coating the VF-31s and Sv-262s use in lieu of paint. The aircraft's colors and markings are just settings programmed into what is essentially the lovechild of an e-paper flexible display and a vinyl vehicle wrap that covers the entirety of the aircraft's armor skin and also functions as ablative armor against energy weapons. Theoretically, Hayate could change the colors of his VF-31 just as easily as Mirage changes the colors of the Sv-262Ba she steals in Passionate Walkure. If he wanted to add some black accents and a personal mark to commemorate Messer, it wouldn't require anything except a design to feed into the system and he could change the settings back whenever the mood struck him. So it's a continuity error caused by recycled footage, but also something that can be explained away very very easily.
  17. Seto Kaiba
    Had a lot of great times thanks to Itagaki-san's work. When I was in HS, a bunch of us band kids used to sneak into unused classrooms after school to play video games using the big old CRT TV carts while we waited for tuesday night marching band practice to start. Dead or Alive 2 on the Sega Dreamcast was one of our go-to games for years. From what I've read about him in the past, it always sounded like he would've been a blast to work with. The industry has lost one of the real ones.
  18. Seto Kaiba
    Went back and finished that third episode of Let's Play... and I have to say that the series is thought-provoking in its own way. That said, the thoughts it's provoking aren't necessarily the ones the original author intended to provoke. There are two things that it most strongly reminds me of: I'm probably going to drop this one, mainly because its story frequently devolves into pure cringe fuel. The Banished Court Magician Aims to Become the Strongest is hitting all the most generic and formulaic plot beats of the "The Protagonist is Horribly Overpowered and We're All Just Lucky to Have Them" wish fulfillment story. It's not bad. The animation's fine and the story is competently organized and presented. There's just no spark of creativity to it. It's all the boring and conventional overpowered hero tropes proficiently laid out end-to-end in an almost mechanical procession devoid of human feeling. It feels cynical, like a story the author wrote because they lost a bet or wanted to prove that anyone could get a suitably generic trend-chasing fantasy story published. Let This Grieving Soul Retire does a little trolling this week, and it's actually pretty fun. Got some good chuckles out of it too.
  19. Seto Kaiba
    May I Ask for One Final Thing? continues to be an absolute treat. Not only is seeing Scarlet gleefully, dare I say giddily, beat the tar out of the very worst and most evil kind of people in high society is deeply amusing and terribly cathartic in its own right... the author of the original work was clearly having entirely too much fun subverting the usual otome narrative tropes here. True, but that cooler's usually got provisions for a few people in it (since most folks don't go camping alone) and a few brews spread over the course of an afternoon of activity is a bit different from clearing a whole case of beers in a single protracted sitting. Gen's cooler is a 24+ can capacity model and it's still visibly full after he's had like three (and we know that he didn't pack it with ice, since he mentions using the frozen pork for that purpose). There's at least one occasion earlier in the series where he runs out of beer in just one day and ends up walking to the nearest store for more. He has like, seven or eight beers just onscreen in the course of this one episode. Let's Play served up another cringeworthy episode that feels like someone asked ChatGPT to write a romance anime using nothing but the contents of TVTropes articles.
  20. Seto Kaiba
    Is it? Genuinely asking. The folks I know who go camping inevitably pair camping with other outdoor activities like birdwatching, hiking, caving, kayaking, swimming, fishing, hunting, and the like. I've never encountered a camping enthusiast whose idea of camping is just "pitch a tent and get sh*tfaced". Even the campers in horror movies do more than that with their time outdoors (excl. getting chased and/or killed). Gen's cooler's like a 30+ can affair and he's emptying that sucker in a single sitting.
  21. Seto Kaiba
    On the subject of "the VF-24 as a VF-25 with different wings", it reminded me of this custom kit by VF-1Riders that they dubbed "VF-25 Messiah Legacy". The resemblance really is uncanny.
  22. Seto Kaiba
    Honestly, at this point it seems like every character in Solo Camping for Two is an alcoholic and is using (solo) camping as a cover for their drinking problem.
  23. Seto Kaiba
    Well, if you take Master File's word for it they do a LOT of computer modeling and virtual testing before they ever move on to a physical test article. Partly because of how hard it is to actually physically deconstruct and recycle the functionally graded composite materials used in VF and warship construction. They do have enormous manufacturing muscle with dozens of factory satellites and factory ships though, so building everything is way way faster. Mass production of the F-22 took about 15 years to get to 195 aircraft. The Macross Frontier fleet ran out 156 VF-19EFs, with multiple variants including recon and command models, in about a year. Said "bulb feature" is probably the same kind of composite sensor found on the noses of other Shinsei Industry Valkyries like the VF-19. The VF-25 and VF-27 have similar types of composite sensors, but they sit higher up on the nose. (The little blue panels seen here)
  24. Seto Kaiba
    Not quite what I was getting at there... that's something different. The regular vs. special forces versions of the VF-14 and the 1st and 2nd production types of the VF-19 are variants with different appearances, sure, but they're still "universal" models available around the galaxy. It wasn't until Macross Frontier and particularly Macross the Ride that they really properly introduced the idea of emigrant governments locally developing their own major and minor variations of existing Valkyrie models. The first proper example being the VF-171EX and VF-171 Block IIIF in the TV series and movies respectively. Both used the VF-171 Block II as a starting point but modified that design to incorporate improvements and new features and capabilities based specifically on the needs and wants of the Frontier fleet's local New UN Forces and initially existed there and nowhere else. The VF-19EF Caliburn is another good example. The Frontier New UN Forces wanted their special forces to adopt the VF-19E, but they weren't happy with the performance and capabilities of the export specification VF-19E in its stock state. So they changed the design and made their own version. They altered the aerodynamics, adopted a new wing design, reintroduced the canards, included some proprietary parts, calibrations, and software, etc. and when the dust settled they had a VF-19 that was uniquely the Frontier fleet's and it'd changed so much it got a new variant letter issued as VF-19EF (VF-19E Frontier fleet specification). Macross Galaxy did something a bit less extreme with the VF-19C, tweaking the design in various minor ways leading it to be designated VF-19C/MG21 (VF-19C produced in Macross Galaxy specification). Macross Delta lowkey ran with it and the VF-171s in that series are described as a "Rim world model" or "frontier/remote space model" implying they are different from the VF-171s used elsewhere in some way.
  25. Seto Kaiba
    My Awkward Senpai is out here asking the real questions... like "What do you call a romance comedy that has no comedy to speak of and practically no romance?". Kind of a "shaped like itself" question if you think about it.
×
×
  • Create New...