Jump to content

Seto Kaiba

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    12940

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Seto Kaiba

  1. Seto Kaiba
    "Right next to" is a fairly substantial exaggeration... the ruins were a good distance outside town and away from Darwent Castle, and the dimensional warhead deployed was a low-yield tactical model. ... what? When the New UN Forces approved the plan to attack and destroy the Protoculture ruins and Sigur Berrentzs, the Kingdom of the Wind had been at war with the New UN Government for 8 months. I would call declaring war on the New UN Government and then spending eight months shooting at the New UN Forces reasonably clear evidence of hostile intent. As noted in the preceding paragraph, your contention that it was an unprovoked attack is false... the Kingdom of the Wind had declared war on and attacked the New UN Forces on Windermere IV over 8 months before and had been in a state of open warfare ever since. As to the illegality of the dimensional weapon. Treaties prohibit their transportation and use in the normal course of operations, but as we see later in the series the New UN Forces may deploy them under extraordinary circumstances with the appropriate approvals. (The bit about it being illegal is from something Arad said, before the cast learned the truth about the op. Arad was a junior officer, so naturally he wouldn't have had any way of knowing the NUNS internal cover story that Wright'd stolen an undocumented warhead was a cover for an approved mission to destroy the ruins.) Also, as noted in my previous reply, the only reason the dimensional warhead was detonated over a population center was that Wright Immelmann disobeyed orders and deliberately loitered in a city's airspace while carrying a WMD. His orders were to proceed to an unpopulated location and bomb that. Whether Wright Immelmann actually stole the Star Singer DNA or simply found it before the locals did while investigating the ruins is unclear. It would hardly be the first time that anti-government forces made a claim like that to vilify their opposition in Macross.1 Given that we're shown that the ruins/ship can conceal or reveal information selectively, that he simply found the system that DNA was kept in first seems reasonably likely. The NUNS plan was to detonate the ruins using a reaction warhead to hinder Windermere's plan to establish their fold network. Collecting as much data as they can before withdrawing in the face of an enemy fleet that outclasses your own is pretty basic strategy. Also, what weapon program? The only thing the NUNS is ever depicted having developed because of the study of the ruins is the fold jamming system to protect their ships and troops from the bio-fold waves Heinz was projecting. 1. D.D. Ivanov and Nora Polyansky in Macross Zero claimed that the UN Government stole the variable system behind Variable Fighters from their homeland... Macross Chronicle refuted this claim, indicating the technology was shared
  2. Seto Kaiba
    Thanks to the block on exports, Macross is one of the most-pirated anime titles whenever a new one comes out. These days, there's ample evidence that most would rather purchase legitimate product and support the creators rather than resort to piracy not just in the Macross fandom, but among the anime hobbyist community in general. (It's basically Crunchyroll's entire business model...) Macross is, I think, more mainstream than you're giving it credit for... especially since Frontier. There has always been a fairly significant underground fanbase, and one of the biggest obstacles to them has always been the huge markups that come with buying media direct from Japan. Lately, the industry has picked up to the point that even light novels are more routinely ending up translated into English and selling rather well.
  3. Seto Kaiba
    No, plenty of people who were paying attention think Delta's attempt to paint the NUNS as shady or villainous fell pretty flat. (We were pretty clearly supposed to think that, but it doesn't fit with what's actually said and shown in the series.) It's all there if you pay attention to the bits that don't have Walkure in 'em. You're right. Sorry. I wrote that last one from memory while I was being bored to tears in a Skype meeting.
  4. Seto Kaiba
    Very little is said about it. All we really get from Macross Chronicle, for instance, is that it was a test article for an optional part of the YF-19's FAST pack that had high attack power and that it was not typically included. Why the pack was dropped from the final configuration is anyone's guess. It had one large-bore beam gun, two small-bore beam guns, and five missiles IIRC. Officially, the bits that dangle off the sides of the shoulder are only referred to as "Shoulder Armor", and the Macross Chronicle Mechanic Sheet that describes them identifies them only as being there for protecting the shoulder. (Kind of a "shaped like itself" statement, really.) Variable Fighter Master File: VF-19 Excalibur finesses this a bit on page 062, and adds the wrinkle of that armor piece also being a small conformal fuel tank designated NP-FB-FA07. About all that the book says about its merits is that its mounting location enables it to be fitted in addition to booster packs and the larger conformal tanks on the legs. There are two micro-missile launchers in each of the leg packs. There are a few reasons for that: The YF/VF-19's engines arguably didn't need the help. Its thermonuclear reaction burst turbine engines offered a significant improvement in fuel efficiency vs. previous generation engine tech, and the larger airframe meant more room for onboard fuel storage. IMO, this is right about the point in Macross history where FAST packs started to be less about extending range and more about minimizing the impact of adding scads of extra firepower. Likewise, the YF/VF-19's existing defenses were likely enough that the extra mass of the bolt-on armor was judged detrimental. Its armor was comparable to or better than a VF-17's, and that had ballistic resistance rivaling the Armored Valkyrie. Plus it had a pinpoint barrier system and anti-projectile shield made of layered energy conversion armor for additional defense. It preserved the airframe's passive stealth properties. 3rd Generation Active Stealth was still in development at the same time as the YF-19, so a lot of features of 4th Gen VFs were designed with passive stealthiness in mind... hence the internal ordnance bays, stealth gunpods, and the conformal FAST packs. It didn't really become ubiquitous technology until the VF-171's second production block. The default configuration being micro-missile pallets meant that the internal bays in the engine nacelles could be given over to larger ordnance like medium and long-range missiles that would increase drag and diminish passive stealth if hung on the wings. It meant that the FAST packs could be operated with equal ease in space or in atmosphere.
  5. Seto Kaiba
    What corrupt NUNS officer? The Macross Delta TV series sort of halfheartedly tried to make Major Valan look evil or at least duplicitous... but the actual story undermines that pretty thoroughly with the repeated reveal that the local NUNS brass are just way better informed about the scope of the threat than Xaos is and kept it close to avoid causing a panic as they worked on countermeasures. Even their shadiest move, deploying that dimensional warhead during Windermere's first war with the New UN Government, turned out to be a well-intentioned and strategically sound move which only became a controversial disaster because they didn't realize that the elite pilot selected for the mission had been compromised. (Incidentally, manually setting your text color to black makes it hard to read when the default board style has a very dark grey as the background color.) I'd bet against this one, though a new FAST pack seems to be almost a given. They haven't finished doing DXs for the TV series designs yet. (It'd be hard to explain Xaos getting a new VF the way SMS did, since the Brisingr globular cluster's whole schtick is that they're broke and economically underdeveloped. The whole reason the VF-31 was developed was to stimulate their economy by keeping development local instead of buying an export model 5th Gen VF. Maybe if Xaos hadn't already been flying Ace Customs...) With who, though? Macross Delta: Passionate Walkure ended with the Kingdom of the Wind's forces retreating from Ragna and proposing peace talks. Maybe the New UN Forces are going to come knocking now that they know Xaos and Lady M have broken interstellar law by creating and weaponizing an illegal clone (Mikumo). Maybe better drones... their ethos is all about the aerial dogfight and close-quarters combat, so I can't see them going in for a heavy Armored Pack. Maybe something along the lines of the YF-25 Paladin Pack, which focused on a lance for close combat? There are few bets safer than that one. Didn't she say in the series and movie that her parents are dead? (IIRC it's the village mayor of her hometown who was trying to marry her off when she skipped town and the planet on a cargo ship.) The novelizations will scratch that itch for you, that I can guarantee... We'd all like that, yes. Seems unlikely, IMO. She's only really valuable to the story as a one-woman Omniscient Council of Vagueness that dispenses exposition by proxy. Macross Delta's creators never determined an identity for her either, and Berger Stone's whole story doesn't fit with other info about her, so it's unlikely she'll be anyone we already know. If she does put in an appearance, I'm betting on a "remember the new guy?" like Millard Johnson, Timothy Daldhanton, Naresuan, or Richard Bilra... a new character whose backstory puts them as present for the events of the original series. She'll be back to her VF-31C.
  6. Seto Kaiba
    Eh, I'd call some decent art or scenes of the Sv-154 Svard a nice consolation prize.
  7. Seto Kaiba
    Yeah, I know five or six volumes of Variable Fighter Master File already have been fan-translated into Chinese.
  8. Seto Kaiba
    Yeah, I'm definitely not getting my hopes up until I see some news of actual substance. IMO, Macross Delta's concept and cast weren't bad... they're just badly presented. If we get different (read: "better") writers, this movie could be something worth getting interested in. Bring back Hiroyuki Yoshino to clean up Toshizo Nemoto's mess and you'll really have my attention.
  9. Seto Kaiba
    It's not unheard of... they did it in '94 with Macross Plus and Macross 7.
  10. Seto Kaiba
    We're almost certainly headed down the recycled design rabbit hole. Maybe a new FAST pack, but I wouldn't count on anything else.
  11. Seto Kaiba
    That's just the way new Macross project announcements are... we usually don't get any meaningful information until the second or third event where the project is teased. That's what I kept pointing out WRT a new series... that the pattern from the last few meant that we wouldn't expect them to even admit they were working on one until late September, reveal the title in October, and we wouldn't actually see anything substantial about it until November or December. Since a new Delta movie is about the most disappointing announcement they could possibly make, I'm really hoping this topic is not mistitled and there will be a new (non-Delta) series developed in parallel. Given that Walkure is the real money spinner and Macross Delta itself seems to be mostly a footnote to the group's self-promotion, the concerts are probably to keep the gravy train going.
  12. Seto Kaiba
    The recent Walkure live event, which announced this new movie and two crossover live concerts. ANN has a brief article about it. https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2018-09-23/macross-franchise-gets-new-delta-film-new-crossover-concerts/.137201
  13. Seto Kaiba
    Worldwide? Yeah, I'm pretty sure I could sell ten thousand copies of a licensed Variable Fighter Master File volume's translation no problem. Such as it is, I'm not likely to ever get a license due to the ongoing legal reasons and not owning a publishing company, so instead my humble circle of amateurs are focusing our attentions on just doing it for love of the game. Those who attempted this year's Super Dimension Convention's collectibles panel will have heard that we're working on a complete translation of Macross Journal Extra: The latest version of SKY ANGELS: VF-1 Valkyrie Special Edition. The original plan was to have that one done and ready for uploading by SDCon to promote our new website project, but life got in the way when one of my day job's projects got moved up a full year without warning so now it's targeted a launch title for 1/1/19. I just got to the bit about the engines (page 38) last night.
  14. Seto Kaiba
    Oh, I hope not. I'd like to continue to live in hope that we'll get a new Macross story with a competent writing staff behind it. Macross Delta didn't deserve the first movie, let alone a second. The Macross Delta TV series had enormous potential that ended up almost completely squandered by the sheer ineptitude of its writers and their bloody-minded insistence on promoting Walkure over telling a coherent story. The compilation movie Passionate Walkure exacerbated a number of the writing problems that were dragging the series version down (like its inability to focus on telling the actual goddamn story) and only improved the story in the sense that it's less agonizing to watch because there's so much less of it. I could maybe work up some enthusiasm for it if this new, all-original Macross Delta movie shares no writers in common with the previous film and TV series. If it's the same lot of idiots, then it's a virtual guarantee the movie will be a barely coherent Walkure commercial with a plot so thin you could see daylight through it.
  15. Seto Kaiba
    Yeah, the quote came in at $24,575 and four months turnaround time... an amount that's nothing to sneeze at even in the 1st world and not really that much faster than my group can do it on our own. We inquired out of idle curiosity, and that princely sum was enough to convince us to inquire no further. It wouldn't be so bad if we had a license to commercially exploit a translation, since that cost could be spread across the sales of a few thousand books, but it's too steep for doing it simply for the love of the game.
  16. Seto Kaiba
    Oh, I will... but between the amount of stuff in the To-Do pile and the estimate that each volume of Master File will take 4-6 months to complete, it'll be a year or two before I get there.
  17. Seto Kaiba
    It was the first planet outside of our solar system to be colonized, yeah.
  18. Seto Kaiba
    If you are, so are the rest of us... so you either aren't, or you are in excellent company. The only sections I've done out of Variable Fighter Master File: VF-19 Excalibur so far are the variants list, block numbers list, and some stuff way at the front of the book about the cockpit and mobile seat. I would assume, given that the events of Operation Phantom Sword are dated late 2041 and it says they were using the FBF-1000A fold booster, that the VF-19As are equipped with two of them because they need to: Fold a distance of greater than the 20 light years the FBF-1000A was rated for, either by making two fold jumps or having those fold boosters work together. They needed to generate a larger fold effect for a single jump to carry something (as Basara tried in Macross 7 during the attempt to rescue the captured Macross 5 civilians in the spiritia farm. They want to make a return trip without being serviced by the carrier, since the FBF-1000A was rated for a single use only. Eden was stumbled upon by a short-distance emigrant fleet, one of the ~100 that ended up exploring space within a few hundred light years of Sol. It was discovered between the launches of Megaroad-01 and Megaroad-02. Both fleets were basically flying into Vajra space intentionally... Frontier was pursuing Richard Bilra's dream of freeing the galaxy from the limitations imposed on fold travel by fold faults, where Galaxy was pursuing Grace O'Connor's implant network theory. By the time of Frontier, fold boosters were longer-ranged, more reliable, and good for multiple uses. Alto appropriated Michael's because it was handy, since he didn't have time to go hunting for the one he'd left up in orbit with his Super Pack (which may not have even survived the dimension eater detonation).
  19. Seto Kaiba
    Offhand, I don't recall any particular reason being given for Megaroad-01 and its escort fleet setting a course for the galactic core. (Considering where Sol sits on the Orion-Cygnus arm, the vast majority of the Milky Way galaxy is in the general direction of "towards the galactic core".) やさしさSAYONARA ("Farewell to Tenderness"), which shares its title with the episode itself.
  20. Seto Kaiba
    When it's not telling you Kawamori's hovercraft is full of eels... (It's getting better, but every now and then I see it produce something spectacularly wrong.)
  21. Seto Kaiba
    Odds are there's probably at least a little lithium in the reaction as it is, as a consequence of decaying Beryllium-7 produced by fusing Helium-3 and Helium-4.
  22. Seto Kaiba
    Honestly, I wouldn't expect much to change outside of maybe getting Macross on one or more of the popular streaming services (Google Play, Crunchyroll, Netflix, Hulu, etc.). Big West and Bandai have at least proven on a conceptual level that cutting out the middlemen and having the Japanese head office market translations directly to westerners is a viable tactic through the Macross Delta series and Macross Delta: Passionate Walkure movie. I'd expect to see them keep expanding on that approach, and having a growing selection of direct-from-Japan media presented with an English option.
  23. Seto Kaiba
    Individually, yeah... the only way to make that tenable would be for a professional distributor to do a translation with intent to sell, or to crowdfund it. Since neither option is likely to pan out in the near future, I'm just gonna keep slowly plodding away at 'em. True, though since those often include staff/cast interviews, production info, and other goodies on top of the art, being able to read them definitely adds value.
  24. Seto Kaiba
    Most folks, yeah. I'm kind of weird in that I specifically got into collecting them with research as a goal (to fix the many errors in the old Macross II RPG). There's just too much coming too fast for fan translators to reasonably stay on top of things, so the percentage of material made accessible to western fans is presently quite low. (On a lark I got a price quote on what it'd take to get something like Variable Fighter Master File volumes professionally translated and it came out to a bit under $25k per book.)
  25. Seto Kaiba
    "A lot like Gundam" would be the honest answer. Due, in no small measure, to Macross II, Macross 2036, etc. having drawn on staffers from the various recent Gundam titles. Macross II was a very "safe" sequel, typical of the anime industry in that it took the bare minimum number of risks, pushed no envelopes, and stuck close to a proven formula. Macross in general is rather atypical in the extent that it reinvents itself and mixes up its formula in each successive installment.
×
×
  • Create New...