Jump to content

Seto Kaiba

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    13816

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Seto Kaiba

  1. Seto Kaiba
  2. Seto Kaiba
    That'd be a hell of a plot twist...
  3. Seto Kaiba
  4. Seto Kaiba
    There may well be. Then again, there may not. Someone has to be brave enough to actually test the hypothesis first before we'll know for sure. Disney's not as confident in the brand as they were when they were before fans tore them a new one over the sequel trilogy and Solo. With Andor handily grabbing most of the attention, I suspect we'll see more efforts towards original storytelling with a minimum of fanservice. Nothing succeeds like success, after all. If they can keep bringing fresh product like Andor that isn't buried in self-indulgent fanservice they can probably undo a lot of the damage the sequel trilogy and Solo did. Yes, novels are adapted to screenplays all the time... but there's a big difference between adapting an already-popular novel that had broad appeal like, say, Jurassic Park or Harry Potter, and adapting a licensed novel intended to cater to a much smaller audience. It's almost exclusively the former. (It can work under the right conditions, but because western audiences are still locked into "animation is for the children" Japan's cheap way of doing it is seen as unattractive to most studios and the production cost of these direct-to-streaming shows is absolutely insane so studios are being very cautious. Mind you, being cautious is not the same thing as exercising good judgement either... it's possible to very cautiously make huge numbers of terrible decisions, like The Rise of Skywalker.) Being a fan of something does not mean you are not able to recognize its flaws. It usually means you love something despite, or even because of, its flaws. If there are writers who are fans of the EU, they're no doubt exercising their professional judgement to separate what they personally enjoy from what's workable for the general audiences. 😉
  5. Seto Kaiba
    Well, they can't all be gems... but talk about a missed opportunity for a prequel meme!
  6. Seto Kaiba
    Considering how many questionable mushrooms he ingests, it's possible he's just having a REALLY bad trip.
  7. Seto Kaiba
    Forgive me for belaboring the obvious point, but there's quite a galaxy of difference between the kind of writing in licensed works that is intended to appeal to die-hard fans and the kind of writing intended to appeal to and engage general audiences. What die-hard fans might consider good or even exceptional writing in Expanded Universe material is not at all likely to be well-received by the casual audience because the fundamental expectations regarding what constitutes "quality" are different. One of the main reasons Andor stands head, shoulders, knees, toes, and a human pyramid of wookiees above its contemporaries in the Star Wars franchise is that its writers are actively avoiding the self-indulgent obsession with fanservice that is the hallmark of EU writing and that too often becomes the norm when you have fans working on properties they started as fans of.
  8. Seto Kaiba
    That is just plain cruel. 😅
  9. Seto Kaiba
    Well, technically speaking everything the Zentradi use is a "Protoculture design"... but given that the ship was configured to be crewed by giants and there is mention of battle pods recovered from the wreck, it's a very safe bet it was something the Protoculture designed for the Zentradi to use. Possible explanations for why the class itself is associated with the Supervision Army include that it was manufactured by one specific region of the Protoculture's civilization for the Zentradi fleets protecting them and never achieved widespread adoption, or that the factory satellites for the Zentradi fleets operating around Earth were destroyed long ago and the Supervision Army forces are the only ones still operating that class in that region of the galaxy. (In DYRL?, its origin was changed to being a Meltrandi ship, as they became stand-ins for the Zentradi's enemies in that in-universe movie.)
  10. Seto Kaiba
    It's worth noting that that rule did bend quite a bit in the recent movie, and has had the occasional little deviation here and there in previous works.
  11. Seto Kaiba
    Yes, it did. Exactly like that, in fact... because that art by Kazutaka Miyatake depicts Alien StarShip 1 shortly before she crashed on Earth. It's based on the production line art that Miyatake drew for the Supervision Army gunship encountered in "Viva Maria" which was said in-series to be the same type as the Macross, and which official publications (e.g. Macross Chronicle) use as art of the Macross's original (pre-refit) appearance.
  12. Seto Kaiba
    Spoiler tag your spoilers, the movie just became available to most fans outside Japan. Boy did I ever underestimate what a bunch of hacks were working on Delta... Quite a lot of fans seem to be rather upset by the whole thing too, both because it's a cheap and meaningless attempt to garner some interest from older fans that has no real impact on the plot and because it's a tediously mundane answer to the setting's most enduring mystery.
  13. Seto Kaiba
    Wow, so Chris Pratt's Mario voice is just... regular-ass Chris Pratt voice. Having seen Super Mario Bros. in theaters as a kid my hopes were not high to begin with, but it's weirdly disappointing to hear Mario not sounding like the outrageous (but not entirely unrealistic) Italian stereotype Charles Martinet has been voicing since 1992. EDIT: In a way, it's even weirder to hear Mario having actual dialogue instead of just various reaction sounds.
  14. Seto Kaiba
    Misa is really bad at parallel parking. Yeah, and the liner notes actually mention that there was concern about even giving Max a blue YF-29 because they were concerned it being a YF-29 might get it mistaken for Alto's or its blue paintjob and Frontier connection might get it mistaken for Michael's. Regardless of model, it was going to be Blue Valkyrie No.2 in the movie since blue is also Hayate's signature color. (Master File also offers a blue paintjob for an Emerald Force VF-25.)
  15. Seto Kaiba
    From the outside looking in, the "Why not?" is pretty obvious. Andor is the exception, not the rule. It's the only one of the four Disney+ Star Wars series so far that is being carried by the quality of its writing and acting rather than the quantity of its self-indulgent fanservice. There is absolutely no guarantee that they do any other story, regardless of genre, at this level of quality. Goodness knows if they could do that on command they would've done it where it counted... like in Solo, the sequel trilogy, the prequel trilogy, the other three shows, the Expanded Universe, etc.
  16. Seto Kaiba
    No, the Varauta forces in Macross 7 are using modified versions of the same ships and mecha they used before their planet (named Libera, according to the recent movie) was taken over by the Protodeviln. Even Gepernich's huge flagship is just the former flagship of the Varauta NUNS with some modifications. The Fz-109 is a modified VF-14 Vampire. The Az-130 is a modified VA-14. The FBz-99 is a modified VAB-2. The only original design that the post-Protodeviln Varauta forces had was a large aircraft carrier that is just a stretched version of their standard model. Contrary to what the name might make you expect, the Supervision Army was not founded as anything like an organized formal military service. It was a force the Protodeviln threw together out of whatever ships, mecha, and spiritia-drained personnel were on hand and its approach to "recruitment" could best be described as the stuff of vampire action movies. They would attack Protoculture settlements and anyone who wasn't killed in the fighting would be drained of their spiritia and subjected to mind control for use as soldiers to attack more Protoculture settlements and capture more people. Lather, rinse, repeat. The Supervision Army and Varauta Forces are basically legions of ghouls created by space vampires. Odds are their equipment was initially nothing like standardized and they had little or nothing developed for them. It was a force made up entirely of captured ships and mecha that were crewed by the Protodeviln's mind-controlled victims. Millennia of warfare probably saw it deteriorate into something like a standardized force after irreplaceable Protoculture ships were all lost fighting the Zentradi and they were left with the equipment and personnel produced by captured factory satellites.
  17. Seto Kaiba
    I consider this video meme completely appropriate and even on topic considering the big-eared Ferengi-like aliens we see in The Labyrinth of Time. The first one is actually answered in the Macross Delta TV anime directly, so I don't see a reason to spoiler tag that one. By "ruins" I'm assuming you mean the Protoculture System. Yes, the Protoculture System's resonators are physically real. They're hidden/stored in fold space when they are not active, either because the Protoculture were concerned someone might tamper with them after they died out or simply to keep them out of the way. For the record, the answer is the egg did. Eggs predate chickens by approximately 340 million years. </overlyliteralgag>
  18. Seto Kaiba
    Macross Chronicle. You can see one of the prepunched holes for the binders on the left side of the image.
  19. Seto Kaiba
    That kinda already happened once... Mariafokina Barnrose spanked NUNS Special Forces ace Aegis Focker in a VF-1X when he was using a VF-19A.
  20. Seto Kaiba
    Probably not, given that... By the specs, the YF-29's flight performance is around 20% higher than the YF-30's. All in all, Leon did have a bit of an advantage in that the fight with Rod took place inside of a base where Rod couldn't leverage the YF-29's maneuverability. I am told the New UN Government and New UN Forces do not negotiate with terrorists. Based on the official materials I've seen, the YF-29 is still considered to be a 5th Generation VF. An extra feature on the Macross Delta TV anime Blu-rays tries to claim the VF-31 Siegfried is a Gen 5.5 unit but there is no real indication what constitutes a 6th Generation machine and the Siegfried isn't a production unit anyway so its classification should be the same as the parent machine (5th Gen). There was, of course, the Third Option of having Max use a different 5th Generation Valkyrie closer in performance to the VF-31. He (and Milia) had VF-25s in the novelization of the second Macross Frontier movie. Or even just giving Max a Siegfried with the FSW after Delta Flight changed to the Kairos Plus.
  21. Seto Kaiba
    In principle, the Varauta forces were Supervision Army 2.0. The main difference - apart from the victims being Human instead of Protoculture - is that when the Protodeviln escaped the second time and brainwashed the New UN Forces survey team and then the colony on the neighboring planet, they were aiming to create a sustainable, renewable source of spiritia instead of simply rampaging across the galaxy. Gepernich's grand goal was a "Spiritia Farm" that would enable the Protodeviln to be self-sufficient without destroying any (other) civilizations.
  22. Seto Kaiba
    Since the Macross Delta: Absolute Live!!!!!! Blu-ray booklet decided to offer nothing useful, our last best hope is Variable Fighter Master File. We'll know if THAT was a waste of time in December. I've already preordered multiple copies as per my usual. An improvement it most assuredly is, but likely not one suitable for mass production for reasons of cost and the additional maintenance requirements caused by overstressing the VF-31's airframe. The VF-27 was as close as anyone could get to an actually-economical mass production version of the YF-29. General Galaxy completed the VF-27 using YF-29 development data leaked to them by LAI and pushed the envelope as far as they could with their bleeding edge tech, but because the ISC systems available couldn't keep up it became necessary for the VF-27's pilot to be a reinforced cyborg. It is still the highest performance production 5th Generation VF we've yet seen. (AFAIK, the only outside users of the VF-27 shown to date have been Zelgaar Heavy Industries on Pipure and the Hunter's Guild on Uroboros.) The AIF-9V "Ghost V9"? They are a Macross Galaxy-developed improvement upon the mass production version of the Ghost X-9. Earth was shown to use the AIF-9B in Macross VF-X2, though it was outwardly identical to the Ghost X-9 prototype.
  23. Seto Kaiba
    Did you forget Xaos was basically keeping Mikumo as a slave from the moment of her creation until... actually, there's no evidence that they've ever stopped keeping her as a slave. Her interactions with Walkure were strictly limited and she wasn't allowed out into society in order to conceal that she was a 3 year old illegal clone with virtually no understanding of social behavior. She was created to be a weapon, indoctrinated and trained to be a singer, and shuttled from one battlefield to another with no real opportunity to object or even consider an alternative lifestyle.
  24. Seto Kaiba
    Ah, that's incorrect. The YF-30 was not developed to surpass the YF-24 or anything like that. It was developed as an Experimental aircraft (an "X-plane") and built to evaluate several new technologies, the most important of which was the Fold Dimensional Resonance system that was developed as a way to cross dimensional faults. The reason it was designated as a prototype (YF) instead of an Experimental aircraft (VF-X/VX) was to exploit a loophole in the New UN Government's laws about disclosing newly developed technologies. Classifying it as a prototype allowed SMS Uroboros to avoid having to make those disclosures to the central New UN Government and continue testing in secret for much longer than they normally would have been able to. The YF-30's performance is actually lower than the YF-29's by a fair amount, and it's much less heavily armed as well because it was not developed as a combat aircraft. For its part, the VF-31 was nominally developed from the YF-30... but it is a heavily economized model that shares little in common with the YF-30 apart from its basic design and transformation. It was not developed as a successor to the VF-24. In fact, its performance is on the same level as the VF-25's and it shares a lot of parts with the VF-25 as well. The VF-31 was locally developed within the Brisingr cluster as an economic stimulus and for export sale to other governments. Rather than purchase a 5th Generation VF from another government like buying VF-25s from the Frontier fleet, they developed their own new model locally to keep that money inside their own economy and create jobs. Their other goal was to bring money into the cluster by selling VF-31s to other governments that hadn't already purchased an export variant of someone else's 5th Gen VF design. (Its backstory is heavily inspired by Japan's own domestic 5th Generation fighter program that had the same motivations.) The VF-31 Siegfrieds used by the Delta Flight of Xaos's Ranga branch 3rd Fighter Wing are "aftermarket" customizations of the stock VF-31A Kairos that adopt a detuned version of the YF-30's engine and a much less capable, but still gobsmackingly expensive, version of the YF-29's Fold Wave System. The modifications push the VF-31 airframe to its limit but only really improve it enough to rival the performance of the VF-27. The VF-31AX Kairos Plus is...
  25. Seto Kaiba
    Eh... I know I'm probably being a bit harsher on that half-arsed creative decision than I actually need to be, too. I've probably said this before in other threads, but I kind of dislike the YF-29 on principle. It's Macross's first real Super Prototype. It is, in Macross, the same kind of thing that the Gundams are in most Gundam shows. It's an irresistable force AND an immovable object. It's an impractical superweapon that is so expensive it can never be mass produced or used widely, but not so expensive that there can conveniently be just one of them hanging around somewhere in case someone needs to be play the next mission with the cheats enabled. It's so incredibly expensive and resource-intensive that there's no believable way for someone to just have one. Giving a YF-29 to any member of the Jenius family other than Mirage would be grotesque overkill. Giving a YF-29 to Max basically allowed him to hijack the entire film and steal focus from the main characters at least three times, including during the climax of the film! We've got no specs for the VF-24 used by Earth and the central New UN Forces, so it's hard to say. It is worth noting that every 5th Gen VF was developed from a redacted version of its specs that omitted key/proprietary technological advancements, leaving emigrant governments to fill in those gaps on their own. We know the YF-29 was developed to exceed the performance of the YF-24 Evolution but it's left unclear if it truly did so and if so by how much. I'd assume the YF-29 probably does surpass the VF-24, but ends up on the losing side of the equation because the VF-24 can be mass produced and the YF-29 can't because of its massive price tag and the insanely high fold quartz requirements.
×
×
  • Create New...