kalvasflam

Stratigic location is a posibility. Though when it comes to making powerful weapons Orb knows what it's doing. The Izumo-class battleships, Gold Frame Amuterasu, the first five Gundams. Orb indirctly had a hand with the Strike Daggers (being GMs of the Strike Gundam), the Archangel-class and possibly even the three new Gundams. Even ZAFT has to thank Orb for something, Orb is indirectly linked to Freedom and Justice. Imagine Freedom and Justice with no phase shift and no beam weapons. The some of the engineers who worked on the Archangel-class most likly fled to PLANT. Why do you think Minvera shares a lot of the same technology and design elements of the Archangel-class, when ZAFT never got thier hands on the ship. Minvera definatly looks closer to the Archangel-class than the Nazca-class. Right now without Orb helping them, the most the Alliance has are Windams and refitted Agamemnon, Nelson, and Drake-class ships. Right now we don't know who is responsible for Girty Lue. If it wasn't Orb, then it was most likly technology dreived from things Orb had a hand in making. The Alliance and ZAFT aren't after Orb the country they're after Orb the weapons developer. You're mixing up GSD now with GS. Yes, Orb developed gundams, and BB in GS. What have they done lately? Nothing. Murasame = Zaku = Windam. We're talking about mass produced MS only. Do you see Orb fielding a better mass produced MS? Ok, so in GSD, we're agreed that technology is about equal. No. If you want to talk about weapons development, that's largely a function of having Coordinators in Orb, if those go away, there goes the advantage for the Alliance. Besides that, the newest Gundams are developed in ZAFT. It doesn't matter if the guys used to be Orb citizens, in the GSD time frame, those guys are on PLANT, not Orb. So, if the primary weapons developer in Orb were coordinators, Alliance derives no benefit from picking up Orb, because they end up throwing out the coordinators. Finally, you can't assume a prototype model will be a mass production variant. If that was the case, ZAFT would be rife with Freedoms, and the new prototype gundams. EA would be flooded with the GAT series, and Orb would have all their Astrays turned into one of the five original gundams. It's a issue with cost.

Ok, just to be sure I get it right, this is separate from the GSD post above, we're talking about GS only at this point. I think if the fight became protracted, ZAFT wins. You know why, they didn't have the Yzak character shield. After all, you wanted to use that when describing the fight with Orb. So, at Panama, Yzak was around, none of the druggies. Without EMP, Yzak wins. The best you can hope for is there is no evidence either way. But from what's happened in the show, ZAFT wins Panama without EMP. We can keep this up forever, and it'll still be difference of opinion. No, the fact they didn't attack Australia and wiped out Victoria indicates that ZAFT still had too much forces at Australia. Australia throughout the show is billed as a major ZAFT base. Remember, they also need the mass driver facility, and as important as Australia is, it probably has one. Remember, ZAFT offered its support to Orb. You say they couldn't muster enough troops, yet you don't know that Klueze's sub was the only one there. They left when it was obvious Orb would fall and they still won't call for help. The only thing you know for sure is that Orb refused ZAFT support, so there is at best no idea how much support ZAFT can offer. Also recall, according to the show, ZAFT deployed a large force at Victoria when it was overrun. If as you say, they had been so damaged, where the hell did they get that large force. You mean suddenly between the invasion of Orb and the taking of Victoria which happened almost immediately afterwards ZAFT magically had more forces appear? Don't think so.... Ok, time to go to the nxt post since you start talking about GSD again so that there isn't any confusion.

First off, you're mixing GS and GSD. You are looking at now and applying it to then. Different time, different circumstances. ZAFT regulars won because they had the EMP. There is no way to show whether EA or ZAFT was winning because as soon as ZAFT secured certain spots, they deployed the EMP. Plain and simple. So don't think ZAFT would have won or EA would have won. As soon as ZAFT deployed the EMP, the game was over in the 2nd inning. And Panama was attacked with a small ZAFT force. Alaska dealt a serious blow to ZAFT. Back in GS, ORB was a major technological country. In terms of mobility, Astrays performed better than the Strike Daggers and outclassed GINNs. It also had the Izumo-class ships. These ships outclassed any EA ship in technology. Most EA ships used conventional weaponry. Most the Archangel's design stems from ORB, as I said earlier. Even ZAFT didn't integrate some of the weapons found in the Izumo and Archangel-classes until GSD. Two years later in GSD, these problems leveled themselves out. So the board is even. ZAFT can help those refugees in in the Suez in GSD because they have help from local governments. The world changed in GSD. Eurasia no longer wanted to stand with the Atlantic Federation. In GS, ZAFT suffered a good lost of troops at Alaska. They could have offered ORB assistance but it would not have done any good. With the lost at Alaska, the order came down to pull forces back to space where they could regroup. Panama was a parting shot. ZAFT also had a decent force holding Victoria and they still were defeated there. ORB would have fallen with or without ZAFT's help. Ok, let's try this again.... Keeping everything in GSD. GS detour came up because some of the same basic references to military capabilties apply. i.e. similar naval operating tactics (ZAFT using subs, EA using surface combatants centered around carrier groups) My points in all of this started out as: 1. Orb could stay neutral without too much trouble because they just don't have all that much worth while. Even if they did have something that important, they could stay neutral by threatening to ally to the enemy of whichever attacked them first. 2. The real question is why would anyone bother with Orb in the first place. So ground rules: We're agreed that technologically in GSD, everyone is pretty much even, Orb = EA = ZAFT right? We're agreed that Orb is a relatively small country with limited population, right? So, given that set of circumstances, why is there a disproportionate regard for Orb? Ok, to support point 1, it's purely a question of how fast Orb's new allies can deploy their forces to defend Orb against their new enemy. If the enemy was EA, their tactics seem to involve using carrier groups to physically take and hold ground. It takes time to assemble that force and move it with ships, so providing enough warning to Orb and their allies to properly redeploy. Further, if the enemy was ZAFT, the tactics would likely involve shock attacks, probably using subs, in conjunction with orbital drops and air deployed mobile suits, as seen throughout both GS and GSD. The objective wouldn't be to hold ground so much as destroying a valuable target. This would be much more difficult to defend against, but Orb itself would likely not be conquered as in physically invaded with troops deployed on the ground. Now, onto point 2, if on technology, Murasame is equivalent to Windams and I suppose Zakus... then it doesn't really matter that much. With its limited population, I just can't see Orb as a major military power. If it had that much troops to be able to swing battles in the first place, neither side could risk going to war with Orb and risk a second battle. The only plausible reason left is that Orb is a huge manufacturing giant. I can't dispute that, but there is no proof so far to that regard. Strategically, they might be well located against the Australia base for ZAFT that's it. So, the bottom line is, what's so important about Orb?

Yet the ZAFT regulars took down Panama after the loss at Alaska when arguably, the Alliance was more powerful at Panama with their MS. I'm sorry, that line of argument doesn't hold water. The EMP was a fast way to win, you had no obvious way of showing that EA was winning at Panama before the use of EMP. Azrael's trio is cancelled out by Freedom/Justice. No, ZAFT's presence would've made a big difference because Orb was overwhelmed by numbers. With ZAFT around, that would not have happened. If you turn around and say that the trio would just focus on normal suits, then so could the Freedom and Justice, and you'd still end up with a bloody draw. You need to properly define what you mean by equal terms. Because if it's technology, then Orb makes no difference to either ZAFT or EA in the grander scheme of things. If it's military, then no one would've used the EA will wipe out Orb argument. And Cagalli would've had a stronger come back against that line of reasoning. Azrael, if Orb asked for help from ZAFT, they would've had indications of aggressive EA moves ahead of time. Remember, you can't just have a fleet of warships magically appear off your coast with no warning. ZAFT may be capable, because they could theoretically deploy a entire fleet of MS carrying subs right off of Orb. But EA is centered on surface carriers from what we see. So, we're not talking about two days of fighting, we're talking about much longer time frame when EA is deploying. EA doesn't have limitless forces, to effectively take over Orb, they have to draw down somewhere. And if ZAFT is able to expand resources helping those refugees in the Suez region, then I'm sure they can find ways to help Orb if an alliance was in the offing.

Nice shot of the Russian carrier. Did they ever make the SU-30 IB, or whatever it's called (Platypus I think) into a carrier version? Last I recall the SU-25 would've been used as the carrier strike aircraft, but those things are just so darn ugly... yet incredibly effective against ground targets.

Hai hai. Although I would word the opening statement as as small military power, large technological and scientific know-how. If ORB allied with ZAFT, they would have been attacked by EA. ORB didn't win the last time they fought EA. What makes you think they would win this time? ORB now has allied itself with EA. They are open to attack from ZAFT. And ZAFT is pounding on EA in the European region (i.e EA is losing territory). As Anubis pointed out, had Orb been allied with ZAFT the last time, the balance would've seriously been tipped the other way. Orb lost because they got outnumbered and fought by themselves. This would not have necessarily been the case if they had ZAFT backing them. Now all of a sudden EA would've had problems Anubis, you point out that it would take time for ZAFT to deploy to Orb to support. I agree. But, considering how close ZAFT's base is to Orb, it would not take very long for them to get to Orb. They could also do orbital drops. Which would provide the most immediate need for Orb in case of an attack, troops. But beyond that, there is a consideration of movement. Whoever moves against Orb cannot do it instantaneously. Judging from how EA military works, it would be a massive fleet that would take days to arrive. Giving everyone advance warning. And then more than enough time for Orb to get reinforcements. The same would probably apply to ZAFT, although they don't seem to have as a massive presence on Earth, and are geared mainly to holding strategic areas with the ability to deploy lots shock troops, it doesn't seem as if their infrastructure is geared as well to holding positions. (very analogous to the U.S. military today, great for smashing aside any opposition, but not nearly as good in holding territory they conquered) Orbital drops by themselves cannot take all of Orb. It would be like sending in tanks without infantry or air support. The technology part I just don't buy, at least, not any more. On the surface, the Windams seem to match Astrays. Now, the Murasames may be a bit better in terms of mobility, but that's about it. I just don't see Orb as having as much of an edge in destiny as they had in seed. If they're on the same level as the Alliance, then that means they don't mean anything unless they had a sufficiently large military. (Which doesn't seem plausible considering how small their overall country is) It's like comparing the U.S. to Singapore. Same level of technology and scientific advances, but you don't gain much by bringing Singapore nto the U.S.

Agreed, it was a no-win situation. Cagalli has now, tried everything she could to not involve ORB in the war, but everything she's tried has failed. Cagalli is not so much trying to stop a war but, trying to keep ORB out of the mess. That is the reason why she went out. ORB is her home country. First and foremost, Cagalli is doing what she should as a leader, protecting her country. She already tried to stop the war and it didn't work. Now she tried to stop her own people from getting involved. That has now failed. She doesn't have many options left but to do things the hard way...again. But in a funny way, that's what Yuna and company are doing. Although their motivation seem to be power for themselves. Realistically though, if you take a detached view of things, Orb's position around episode 8 and 9 would've been pretty easy. Everyone else is at war, adding Orb as an enemy would make no sense. If neutrality was so important, the easiest thing to have done would've been to put out a statement that indicated that Orb will side with the opponent of the first side that attacks it. Now, this is a good way to get run over by trains from both direction, but it's not unreasonable. And people keep mentioning how powerful Orb is and how it can change the calculus of the war, but that's ridiculous. It's a pathetically small country. If it was that powerful, it wouldn't even need to worry about violation of its neutrality.

well, she could've always resorted to pulling out her little brother with his unstoppable war machine. Calls in the parlimentary meeting, and then make a phone call: "cough cough, I am feel naseous, will be 15 minutes late." In the interim, Kira accidentally blows up the building... Ok, it's a real good point though. She was just in a bad spot, the fact her only mentors were the people who wanted to usurp her pretty much screwed her.

She's starting to turn into another Relena, which doesn't make me happy at all. I had enough of Relena's "we can't fight" crap in Wing, and the first Seed put just enough in not annoy you. Now she's spewing that stuff in a situation where you don't have anymore choice but to fight, and kick ass quickly so it doesn't drag out anymore. At least Cagalli isn't voicing pacifism, but it's still kind of annoying, since its obvious even her own nation isn't going to listen to her. She wasn't able to handle being sovereign of that state. If she was she would have told Yuna and co. to screw off it's being done her way, but no. Athrun's gained points in this show (I wasn't a real fan of him in the first show), but she's lost some this time. Actually, Cagalli was pretty much in a no win situation. Even if she told Yuna to screw off, the captain of the Orb carrier would've still continue to follow Yuna's orders. The reason is simple, the captain in charge of the Orb squadron is responsible for his men and to a lesser extent his country. He figures correctly that if he suddenly decided to be neutral, his fleet would be screwed, the same goes for Orb. His fleet is essentially thousands of miles from home, he'd have to cross over enemy territory, and he'd never make it that far. The EA would just keep pounding his fleet until it all went under. Cagalli wouldn't sanction that fleet joining ZAFT due to her neutality stance, so basically, that fleet would have no support and couldn't make it home. Orb is in big trouble since they would now be minus what seem to be a pretty large force and their own country is significantly weakened against any potential EA attack for breaking treaty. The situation had to play out that way. You really can't blame Cagalli cause let's face it, she's just a kid and doesn't understand what she would be asking other people to do. The best time to tell Yuna and company to go to hell would've been back in episode 8 or 9. Then at least things would have been more tenable.

cool, how useful, I'm headed to NYC myself in a week. gonna definitely check out the hudson hotel bar. Any other similarly interesting places?