sorry, but this is still subjective. in the end, different viewers will take away different things. Maybe person A is more concerned with character animation and textures and person B is more concerned with action seuqences and set pieces.
Case in point, in the Justice League thread, Fatalist tore me a new one because I didn't like animation team behind Beowulf. Fair enough, to me, character animation trumps textures and model complexity but not everyone may think so, I'm sure a lot of people may find the realistic models and textures to be more important than motion capture/animation.
In the end, who's right? Each viewer has a different set of criteria going in and each viewer will take away somthing different.