It looks a bit different than the SHE, with some screws hidden.
But I always thought that the SHE and Tamashii were the same version??
Personally, i love my Yamato version, although I know it gets a lot of hate. I think people just misunderstood it, and it was ahead of its time.
Mine is tight in both forms, and made of high quality plastic. Classic Yamato quality.
People complained it was floppy during transformation: Of course it is. Look at all the valks we have had since. They're a mess during transformation and you need about 3 hands to get them anywhere.