Well it didn't come from Atlantis, but my 'dream weapon" showed up today. This thing is incredible for the price. The bluing is deep, inky blue/black, fit and finish seem very close & tight, and the heft is just right. The cylinder spins nice and freely at half-cock and it makes the legendary four clicks to cock (old timers said it spelled C-O-L-T) and when it is at full cock it is tight! The grips have nice, plain stained finish as opposed to the glossy varnish on my Uberti 1851. After a thorough external inspection I've declared it "flawless." When I get ahold of my dad's Chapman tool kit I'll break it down to check out the internals and clean out the gunky oil it was covered in for shipping.