I disagree with the "waste of time, effort, and bandwidth" part, but maybe this Hurin character will let me join his debate club. Anyway, somebody is always going to be new to a product most of us are familiar with, and just because it was a thread topic, last month, doesn't mean it is off limits, now. I don't really see the harm; it's not like new thread topics pop up every few seconds, like on some message boards.
Oh yeah, I happen to like the "bloodletting," too.