What I want is a realistic war story. A Macross "Band of Brothers" so to speak. Or perhaps even something like Gundam's MS Igloo series.
Yes, darker and grittier. But not too much of the melodrama. I don't want one of those stories where every character seems to have emotional problems and is seen brooding, whining, shouting, wailing every other episode. And none of this Evangelion-like psychoanalytical mumbo jumbo.